COPY NO. IMPERIAL TOBACCO LIMITED RESEARCH LABORATORY MONTREAL RESTRICTED PROGRESS REPORT RESEARCH DEPARTMENT July - December 1975 ISSUED BY: Dr. T.A. Smith DATE ISSUED: January 20, 1976. DISTRIBUTION: Copy No.: 1. Lib rary 21. Mr. R.D. Nicholls 2. Lib rary 22. Dr. M.H. Bilimoria 3. Mr. R.M. Gibb 23. Dr. P.J. Dunn 4. Mr. R.S. Wade 24. Mr. E.R. Freiesleben 5. Dr. T.A. Smith 25. Mrs. J. Johnson 6. Mr. S.M. Candlish 26. Mr. A.F. El Naggar 7. Dr. G.W. Boswall 27. Mr. R.L. Rice 8. Dr. S.J. Green 28. Mr. M.P. Scherbak 9. Dr. S.J. Green 29. Mr. L. Bouchard 10. Dr. S.J. Green 30: Mr. H.C. Roubicek 11. Dr. S.J. Green 31. Miss R.R- Smith 12. Dr. S.J. Green 32. Mr. B.J. Stirling 13. Dr. S.J. Green 33. Mr. C.J. Brown 14. Dr. D.G. Felton 34. Mr. E.P. Gage 15. Dr. D.G. Felton 35. Mr. W.A. Gray 16. Dr. F. Haslam 36. Mr. A. Kalhok 17. Dr. I.W. Hughes 37. Mr. N.D. Maclennan 18. Dr. R.A. Sanford 38. Mr. W.J. Ross 19. Dr. R.A. Sanford 39. Mr. A. Schaffer 20. Mr. R.D. Nicholls C-~ r1 j c0 BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 SUMMARY OF RESEARCH DEPARTMENT ACTIVITIES July - December, 1975 This report outlines recent progress in the work of the Researcn Department, while the work of the Product and Process Development Department is covered elsewhere. Our work has continued in three areas: 1. product development; 2. product modification and control; 3. research related to the development of safer cig- arettes. Details on individual projec-~s can be found in the accompanying progress report. 1. Product Development Research at BAT's Group R & D Centre (GR & DC) at Southamp- ton during the past 2-3 years on "coated-carbon" filters has indi- cated that such filters may be subjectively more acceptable than other carbon filters, giving less of the so called carbon off-taste to the smoke, while it the same time retaining the well-known effec- tiveness of carbon in partially removing some irritating and potentially harmful vapour phase components of smoke. As a result of this research, since the summer we have been seeking a practical means of preparing such a carbon with reproducible filtration characteristics, for potential use in a new product (T-7338). We have made some encou- raging progress, but reproducibility is still a problem. Studies are also in progress on the applicability of two filters, developed by Brown & Williamson, for our flue-cured cig- arettes. In a renewed look at one of these, a filter containing a pocket of granules of an ion-exchange resin (Duolite) designed to reduce the subjective irritation of smoke, a poor taste was found for the last puffs of a flue-cured cigarette (T-7339). The second filter, a version of the Programme filter, is being developed and eva- luated in an attempt to offer smokers a more even delivery of smoke per C:) co Co 110 011 BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 puff down the length of the cigarette, and a more satisfying smoke for most of the puffs than that expected from the tar and nicotine numbers (T-5505). Efforts are also being directed towards identifying the best design for a very low tar cigarette (Project Trojan 2; T-7095). A prolonged search for flavour-enhancing agents for low tar cigarettes has been virtually stopped (T-6810). after having identified the 2 best candidates based on work on Matin6e cigarettes. To further prove their value requires consumer testing, either per se or within the scope of one of the other product development projects. Further work on Project Gourmet (T-6811), aimed at developing a cigarette with a novel, recognisable flavour which will appeal strongly to a small but significant segment of smokers. is dependent on the scheduling of a second series of consumer tests using a single cigarette technique in shopping centre booths. Analysis of the results of the first series of such tests is awaited. The development of coated sweetened cigar dips for Old Port Cigarillos and Colts was initiated because of a rapid escalation in the price of saccharin. The coated tips would reduce our saccharin consumption by 99% and have been shown to be acceptable in consumer tests. However the potential cost saving has recently decreased by about 75% to between $50,000 and $70,000 per annum, due to a dramatic drop in saccharin price in the past 8 months. In the light of this, and the large volume of business involved, the Marketing Division has decided not to implement this technique at the moment, but it may prove useful in future if other flavour tipped products are required. 2. Product Modification and Control A detailed comparison is being made of Matin6e Regular and Craven A Regular cigarettes to find how the opposition brand maintains c0 C-0 BATCO document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 a lower tar level, so as to be abl ~ to lower Matinee's tar yield to below that of Craven A (T-7093). Last September, the carbon monoxide (CO) deliveries of 20 major Canadian cigarette brands were published by Forbes and co- workers (the Government's source of tar and nicotine figures) in a scientific journal. Although the figures were not publicized by the news media, we should expect increased Canadian public interest in the carbon monoxide content of smoke, based on attitudes in other countries. Our latest survey, in contrast to the previous one, showed that our brands give CO deliveries comparable to those of the opposition. This was achieved when we increased the paper porosity for a number of our brands to adjust tar levels. However it should be remembered that most cigarettes still give more CO than tar, and CO cannot be removed by filtration (T-7275). Close control of tar and nicotine yields of cigarettes has had increased importance since they have been printed on packages and in advertisements. A review is being made of 'a potential source of variability in these yields. namely the degree of variation in dryer operation at our different plants (T-6130). From a detailed study conducted in the Montreal plant, preliminary indications Ar, that this variation has only a small effect on smoke yields (through changes in apparent volume and hence cigarette pressure drop). We have completed a study of the combined effects of paper porosity and paper burn additives, and additives applied to tobacco, in the control of smoke yields of tar and nicotine (T-7088). This work has produced a possible alternative means of maintaining cig- arette puff number with reduced tobacco weight, should the present approach (electrostaticly perforated paper) prove unsatisfactory. This alternate involved applying 3% diammonium phosphate to the tobacco. We have assisted in the development by Ajax personnel of N) co co 110 0 C BATCO document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 a modified PCL incorporating sodium carboxymethyl cellulose (SCMC) as a strengthening agent (T-6539). We have proved that this modi- fied PCL is much more resistant to break-up during cigarette manu- facture, isolating the sheet from the tobacco blend by a new flotation technique developed by us (T-6129). Ajax plans to include SCMC in our standard sheet in the near future. 3. Research Related to the Development of Safer Cioarettes. The Research Department is contributing to the development cf safer cigarettes in a number of selected ways, in collaboration with the BAT group and with Government and medical researchers. (a) Objective measurement of the effects on smoking behaviour of usinc modified cigarettes (T-8077). A number of ways have been suggested for designing safer cigarettes, but, to be useful, the products must be acceptable to smokers. Standard smol-.e tar and nicotine yields, as given-on packages, may not necessarily indicate the relative safety of using a parti- cular product. For a product to be truly safer, it should result in the smoker reducing his total daily intake of potentially harmful smoke components while achieving his desired satisfaction. This intake is governed by the actual amount of smoke retained, and the potential harm of a given weight of that smoke. While our other research work is related to the latter factor, we believe that knowledge of the amount of the smoke retained in the system is very important (i.e. tar, nicotine and carbon monoxide intakes). To estimate the total daily smoke intake, we need to know the smoker's daily cigarette consumption, the amount of smoke taken from each cigarette, and the degree of inhalation. Cigarette con- sumption is easily monitored, and we have methods of estimating the amount of smoke drawn from each cigarette. However we have N) 41. L.14 cc c0 _~o _~c 13 ATCO document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 continued to strive for a good way of assessing the degree of inhalation, and to this end we are currently estimating the con- centration of carbon monoxide in the lungs using a simple techni- que involving breathing several times into a plastic bag. When a satisfactory method is established, we will study small groups of smokers to determine the effect on total smoke intake of switching to products with. for example, lower tar and nicotine yields, lower tar but unchanged nicotine, a more alkaline (cigar- like) smoke and ventilation. Meanwhile, we have used existing methods to study the reactions of a small group of smokers to a number of cigarette brands associated with Project Church, and a report is being pre- pared. (b) Studies of Reconstituted tobaccos. There is considerable evidence from mouse skin painting tests that most reconstituted tobacco sheets (eg. PCL) give a potentially less carcinogenic smoke than that from normal tobacco blends. To keep abreast of alternative reconstitution processes, a comparison is now planned of PCL and a reconstituted tobacco made by Schweitzer from the same starting materials, and we will be assisting in the evaluation of these sheets (T-6539). This study will also include a second Schweitzer sheet sample made from our combined waste and stem, to be tested at a blend level equivalent to our combined usage of PCL and CPS. Over a number of years up to last year, the Company has been seeking ways of producing tobacco at reduced cost, using our experimental farm, as a contribution to a major BAT project (PRT-71; T-6430). This was to permit its economic conversion into reconsti- tuted sheet and subsequent use of high sheet levels in blends, to take advantage of the resulting lower biological activity of the CD rQ 4 ::b Q.-4 Co BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 smoke . BAT has been collabcrating in the reconstitution of the ~:)bacco by the paper-making process (similar to Schweitzer) and '..n the evaluation of cigarettes containing 30'; sneet. BAT are -,irrently making comparisons of PRT sheets from bulk flue-curea and modular flue-cured tobaccos. More recently, our farm efforts have concentrated on the -roduction of more mature tobacco and on potential cost reductior -n handling normal tobacco. use of chemical and biochemical sc-eenina tests as monito-s for evaluating the bio'loclcil, activ'tv of stroke. In looking for ways of reducing the potentially harmful effects of a given weight of smoke, we must have ready means of evaluating changes in the biological activity of smoke. We are -.jsing two such tests, which we consider to be meaningful 'screening' rethods. They are being applied to the smokes from several series of cigarette samples, using standards of varied biological activity. 7 he series under test include cigarettes of different kinds of reconstituted tobacco (e.g. the modified PCL and Schweitzer samples) and modified cigarettes in which the blend has been cased with d"_ ~erent burn-control additives (T-7088). One of the tests is the Nitromethane Fraction Index (NMF.-), a mainly chemical test initially developed by BAT Hamburg (T-7092). 7 ne second, less simple technique (T-7708) was developed by Ames in California, and is receiving a lot of public4ty as a screening technique for identifying chemicals with potential mutagenic and carcinogenic activity. (d) Identification of early indicators of damaae by smoke to the respiratory system of animals (T-7709). - The best current methods of comparing the biological activity of smokes are lengthy and very expensive tests with rodents (skin painting and inhalation). BAT has a extensive commitment to such tests. Nevertheless, their relevance to humans is continually be4ng X:- cuestioned by medical authorities. CZ) c0 _Z CZ) BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 We have been very fortunate in developinc a relationship win two excellent medical researchers in Montreal. As a result, the Canadian Tobacco Manufacturers Council is now sponsoring a joint project between two of our researchers and Dr. Hogg (McGill) and Dr. Witschi (University of Montreal). In the project, a searcm is being made 'or early biochemical indicators of damage by smoke to the respiratory system of rodents. Through other parellel work by Dr. Hogg, light may be shed on the relevence of such effects to humans. Since its inception last April, the project has pro- gressed very well, and already some results of importance to s-o<~no anc iealth resear--n have been fount. The projec: makes an excellen: c:)mplTment to the BAT work on long-term animal smoke inhalation studies at GR & DC. C:D N) CO N~ BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 INDEX Pace Code Title Researcner(s) I T-6128 Measurement of hot collapse R.L.R. 3 T-6129 Separation of a tobacco blend into fractions R.L.P. of different apparent densities 4 T-6130 Study of the possible effect of variations R.L.R. in dryer operations on tar and nicotine deliveries. - T-6aC7_ Modification of cicarette smoke by tobacco R.L.-~.. treatme,it ',heat): : nothing to repor- 6 T-6430 & Tobacco grown forreconszitution (PRT-71C) G.W.B., S.W. T-6534 7 T-6538 Modification of the PCL process R.L.R. 8 T-6539 PCL - Miscellaneous studies R.L.R. 9 T-7088 Modification of smoke yields and composi- M.P.S. tion using chemical burn modifiers applied to tobacco and by using a range of cig- arette papers. i - T-7091 Smoke generation and deliveries of Canadian R.L.R., R.R.S., flue-cured grades: - nothing to report. B.J.S. 11 T-8077 & Studies of human smoking behaviour P.J.D., E.R.F. T-7051 14 T-6810 Flue-cured tobacco flavour enhancers A.F..4. is T-6811 Project Gourmet A.F.N. 16 T-6861 Coated Cigar Tips A.F.N. 17 T-7093 Intercomparison of two low delivery R.L.R. cigarettes. 18 T-7094 Determination of pressure drops dur.ing M.P.S. machine smoking, and puff-by-puff tar yields. 19 T-7095 Development of very low tar cigarettes M.P.S. C:) 00 BATCO document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 INDEX (CDnt'd) Paae Code Title Researcher(s) - T-7336 Miscellaneous filter materials/cons- M.P.S. tructions: - nothing to report 20 T-7338 Coated caroon filte-s A.F.N. 22 T-7,339 Ion exchange resin filters. A.F.N. 23 T-5503 Evaluation of the PROGRAM filter R.L.R., L.B., D.E. -4 Miscellaneous vapour phase analyses: M.P.S. carbon monoxide yields 26 T-7092 The nitrome-~hane fraction index of smoke M.P.S. condensate (NMFI) 27 T-7708 Tests with microbial mutants: studies M.H.B. with Ames' Salmonella mutant TA-98 29 T-7709 Changes in bronchial epithelium induced J.J., M.H.B. by cigarette smoke 1. Analysis of lipid peroxidation in J.J. cells of the tracheobronchial tree II. Biosynthesis of macromolecules within J.J. the tracheal epithelium III. Induction of aryl hydrocarbon hydro- K.H.B. xylase in guinea pig and Sprague- Dawley rat tissues. and mutagenesis in Ames' Salmonella mutant TA-98 - T-6775 Miscellaneous microbiological examina- M.H.B. tions: - nothing to report - T-6820 Creative design of flavours for aromatic A.F.N. tobacco products: - nothing to report - T-6840 Development of ranking method for sub- A.F.N. jective evaluation of tobacco prodticts: - nothing to report - T-6860 Determination of purity of saccharin: M.P.S. nothing to report .Zb. (_,4 c0 BATCO document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 INDEX (cont'd) Page Code Title Researcher(s) - T-6862 Development of sweetening agents as A.F.N. substitutes for saccharin: - nothino to report - L-0250 Evaluation of flavour samples from A.F.N. suppliers: - nothing to report 35 L-0251 Miscellaneous analysis of casings and A.F.N., M.P.S. fl avours U-4 BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 T-6129 Measurement of Hot C0llaDSe Personnel: R.L. Rice Objective: To have available, in our laboratory, equipment for measuring hot collapse. Hot collapse may be defined as the change in cigarette firmness during smoking. It was felt that chances in hot collapse might result from changes in cigarette specifications (e.g. tobaccc weight chances, use of new blend components). Status: As stated in the prev'ous Progress Report, the methoo adopted was that descr'bed by Spivey (B and W Report No. 72-27). The following observations have been made, in which butt length refers to the distance between the coal and the applied weight load. 1. As reported previously, puff number had no effect on hot collapse. The determining factor was butt length. 2. Over a certain range of butt length, a linear relation- ship was observed between hot collapse and butt length. It was therefore decided to report hot collapse as the collapse at a specified butt length. 3. At the standard conditions of smoking (35cc puff of 2 second duration and I puff/minute), collapse was only observed at a maximum butt length of 20 mm. However, when extinguished cigarettes were tested on a cigarette firmness intergrator, softening was observed over a greater length. 4. By changing smoking parameters (incre~asing puff frequency and volume), collapse was observed over a longer butt length. -;Z:. CD c3 BATCO document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 T-6128 (cont'd) It is planned to report the work completed to date, after which a decision will be made as to whether this work should be cont4nued. The following objectives will be considered. 1. Relating test results to subjective evaluation. 2. Considering the use of the cigarette firmness inter- grator as a alternate method, which might prove to be more sensi-~ive, and mo-=- readily related to present measurement of firmnes--- --n inl4t cigarettes. 3. Determining whether hot collapse can be predicted from the firmness of the unlit cigarette. -r~:b C:D 13 ATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 T-61 29 The Seoaration of a Tobacco Blend in'~o Fract4ons of Different ADDarent Densities. Personnel: R.L. Rice Objectives: To determine if differences in aoparent density between tobacco types provide a means of isolating various com- ponents from a tobacco blend, viz-- 1. Tobacco puffed by the Reynolds G-'3 or cormarable ;)rocess. 2. PCL or other tobacco sheet. 3. CRS. 4. W.T.S. 5. Lamina from different parts of the plant. 6. Burley. Status: Little successful development work has been carried out on this project during this period. The method has faci- litated the isolation of PCL from tobacco blends. This has been very helpful, as Canadian PCL is the same color as lamina, and hence is difficult to separate visually. The method has been used successfully to demonstrate, by comparison of strand length, that the SCMC-PCL, developed by Ajax Personnel (T-6539), has greater stability durinq cigarette manufacturing. CD cc cc BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 -6130 Study of the Possible Effec-: of Variations in Drver Operations on Tar and Nicotine Deliveries. Personnel: R.L. Rice Backaround In the drying operation, the apparent volume of tobacco & is modified through puffing. This affects two cigarette CbJective: properties, namely filling power and pressure drop, and the pressure drop, through filtration, can affect smoke deliveries. It is therefore oossible that day -,,) day variation in the drying operal:ion of cut tobacco could affect tar and nicotine deliveries of the cicarette. If this situation does exist, it would obviously be advantageous to be able to determine the apparent volume of tobacco at the end of the coolers,assuming that this information makes possible a more uniform operation of the dryer. If the objective stated above is practical, it-has an additional advantage in that variation in the basic properties of the blend could be compensated for in the drying operation. The measurement in the factory of the apparent volume of tobacco, either by pressure drop measurement over a bed of tobacco or by bulk volume measurement, is considered below: 1. The time required for measurement would have to minimal otherwise the test information could not be employed to aid in the control of the dryer. For this reason, X~. CD C__ I-C BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 T-6130 (cont'd) the measurements would have to be conducted in the factorv under less rigid conditions than are generally demandet in the laboratory. 2. The method should be simple. This follows from item 1 above. 3. The tes, should be reasonably insensitive to tobacco moisture. The moisture content of the tobacco would orobab',., vary under conditions of test. Status: The initia" approach has been to determine if a signific-ant *variation toes occur in cigarette pressure drop. Players Mild blend has been used, since plain end cigarettes eliminated any correction for filter pressure drop. Cig- arette samples have been collected over a two month period on a daily basis and cigarette pressure drop determined at a common weight. The data has not as yet been analyzed but a cursory exami- nation could suggest that the differences were small. C:) rIj 4 :- (_14 CO BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 T-6430, T-6534 Tobacco Grown For Reconstitution (PRT-71C) Personnel. G.W. Boswall, S. Webster, M.P. Scherbak, M.H. Bilimoria. Objective: To produce toDacco by cost cutting procedures and to convert it by means of a paper making process into re- constituted tobacco sheet of suitable quality for its utilization at levels of 30'. in commercial cigarettes. S-!--Us: C~cara':tes c::--!-;ning bulk flue-cured tcbacco and Tiodullar flue-cured toDac:o have been manufactured from both the 1973 and 1974 crops. As well, cigarettes containing 30". PRT from bulk flue- cured and modular flue-cured tobacco, from the second- pass tobacco of a three-pass harvest from the 1973 Canadian crop, have also been made. Chemical analysis indicates that the modular flue-cured tobacco andthe subsequent PRT contailed more starch than the bulk flue-cured tobacco, as well as slightly more total alkaloids. SubJective smoking tests, on cigarettes containing only tobacco from the 1973 crop, indicate significantly more impact and irritation from the modular cured tobacco. However the smoking tests on similar samples from the 1974 crop rated the two types of tobacco curing as being almost identical, and the modular flue-cured tobacco showed only a trend toward being more irritating. The cigarettes containing PRT have yet to be tested. C:) BATCO document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 T-6538 Modification of the PCL Process Personnel: R.L. Rice Objective: To modify the effluent from the PCL process so that it could be incorporated into PCL. Incorporation of the effluent into the sheet without modification produces a darker colored, sticky sheet with less strength. The purpose of this stuCy was -.wo-fold: to determine if part of the waste c-,-..ild be util~:ed, and to determine if it could be used as an humectant. Status: As described in our previous report, our initial approach was very simple. We found that the solids from the effluent can be fractionated into methanol -soluble and- insoluble fractions. These fractions, along with an unfractionated control, were incorporated in samples of PCL. A regular PCL was also included. Unfortunately due to malfunctioning of the pilot plant dryer-, all samples including the regular PCL were of very poor quality and no valid comparisons could be made. A policy decision was made to abandon this project. C) N) c0 %Z N; BATCO document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 T-6539 PCL - Miscellaneous Studies Personnel: R.L. Ricc- Objective: 1. To carry out non-routine testing of PCL; 2. To participate with Ajax in the modification of PCL. Status: Currently, an evEluation of a 7rodified PCL sheet developed by Ajax, cnnta4ntnq 3. sociur. :arloxyrethyl cellulose (SCMC) as extra binder, is being conducted, comparing it with regular PCIL 'In 2 brands (Players Filter Regular and Matinee K.S.). A separate comparison is now being planned of this SCK-PCL and a reconstituted tobacco made by Schweitzer from the sam starting materials. This study will also in- clude a second Schweitzer sheet sample made from our combined waste and stem, to be tested in a blend at a level equal to that of the normal combined level ofTCL and CRS. c0 L~4 BATCO document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 T-7088 Modification of Smoke Yields and Comoosition usinq Chemical Burn Modifiers aciolied to tobacco and b,/ usino a Ranae of Cigarette PaDers. Personnel: M.P. Scherbak Main Objective: To quantify ways of controlling smoke yields of tar, nicotine and important vapour phase components, and also to reduce the biologicEl activizy of the smoke by modifying its com- posit4on. The factors studied include the effects of aoplying chemical burn modifiers to the tobacco and the porosity and burning properties of the cigarette paper. Status: This work has been completed and two reports on it are in preparation. The most significant outcome was establish- ment of a possible means of maintaining the puff number of cigarettes of lower tobacco weight. ~Addition of 3. diammonium phosphate (DAP) was shown to achieve this in a subjectively acceptable way, as judged by internal panel tests. Subsiduary Objective: To determine the effect on smoke yields and chemistry achieved when the burn rate of cigarettes is reduced by the maximum amount consistant with the cigarettes remaining lit. At this limit we will also establish the extent of change of the smoke's biological activity as measured by chemical and biochemical indicators. Status: After screening tests using granulated tobacco and different levels of burn-retarding additives, a series of cigarettes, X~_ L,4 co 110 X~_ BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /10 T-7088 (cont'd) containing a flue-cured tobacco blen-- treated with 5.5~, to 6.5% DAP, were manufactured. Cigarettes were wrapped in two types of cigarette paper ("pnosphate" and "citrate") each with four porosities (11, 22, 2:, and 45 Greiner seconds). These cigarettes have mirimum burn rates that sustain combustion, with the exact additive level being deDendent on the paper used. Although the work is not completed, the preliminary results s-iggest considerable changes in smcke chemistry, as com;a-ed to tne controt cigarettes, when smoked under standard smokinc conditions to a 30 mm tobacco butt length. ThE maximum gain of about two puffs per cigarette may be obtained by maximum decrease of burn rate which still maintains smouldering. Comparison of smoke TPM and nicotine yields are probably best made on a per puff basis, since the experiment has resulted in changes in puff number. TPM yields were decreased by from 10 to 20'., while nicotine yields dropped by no more than 7.. The HCN deliveries showed a signi- ficant increase (20-50. range) while TAA deliveries decreased (30-50'. range). These effects on smoke vapour phase will be rechecked. The chanae in smoke prooerties remains to be checked usino the nit-omethane fraction index (T-7092) and the mutagenesis test (T-7708), as indicators of the biological activity of the smoke. CZ) CO \0 Un BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 T-8077, T-7051 Studies of Human Smoking Behaviour Personnel: P. Dunn, E.R. Freiesleben Objev:ive: To study the real effects on smokers of modifying smoking products in order to reduce intake of harmful substances.- Status: The most difficult and yet perhaps the most important task in assessing human smoking, is the measurement of the depth of inhalation. It was felt that maanetometer results as well as carbon monoxide studiES would prov'ce a suitable means for making this assessment. Report No. 149,describing the modification and utilization of magnetometer techniques for measuring resoiratory patterns relative to smoking behaviour,has been completed. However it was found that the application of this tech- nique during human smoking has been hindered by excessive body movemants and thus further study to overcome this difficulty is required. The procedure for the quantitative determination of very low carbon monoxide levels,as found in alveolar atmosphere, has been successfully implemented with our instrumentation. An investigation has been initiated into the correlation of depth of inhalation, estimated from alveolar carbon monoxide concentrations, with puff-taking position and also cigarette brand smoked. A cursory analysis of alveolar carbon monoxide and human smoking patterns of a large group of cigarette makers smoking their-preferred brand BATCO document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 112 T-8077, T-7051 (cont'd) has proven interesting but rather inconclusive. In- consistent changes in alveolar carbon monoxide concen- trations before and after cigarettes smoking, as well as through the day, have been observed, but with a large overlap of results from different brand smokers. Because of problems with the magnetometers however, the evaluation of carbon monoxide results relative to puff-taking position has been delayed. Thus it was decided that an intense study of a small grou-, of specific brand smokers (celaying magnetometer scudies) would be more beneficial. Having monitored 8 smokers of a specific brand, each trirough the day for 2 days, the alveolar carbon monoxide differences before and after cigarette smoking have been correlated with smoking patterns. However, due to ins- trumental problems of the Freiri Slave Smoking machine these analyses are incompleted and/or need verification. A comparative brand study involving a small group of Matinde and du Maurier smokers is presently being completed, to help in Project Church. This study includes the smoking of various competitive brands of similar tar and nicotine delivery, as well as similar physical characteristics (i.e. length, pressure drop). The changes in human smoking patterns and reactions with these different products may be useful in product development and for marketing depart- ment, in designing and evaluating new products. A detailed study of the alveolar carbon monoxide concen- tration of 2 smokers through the day, over the period of one week, is in progress, including cigarettes of _r~-b U4 E3 ATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /13 T-8077, 7-7051 (cont'd) different carbon monoxide to nicotine ratio (from standard machine results). The method for blood nicotine determination of Feyerbend et al. (J. Pharm. Pharmac., 1975, 27, 434-436.) is presently being applied to our instrumentation with the hope that equivalent response limits may be reached. Alterations in this technique as well as extraction procedures will soon be completed. -r--b CD cc BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /14 T-6810 Flue-cured Tobacco Flavour Enhancers Personnel: A.F. El Naggar Objective: To identify flavour-enhancing agents which will improve the taste quality and level of low tar flue-cured cig- arettes, without changing their character. Status: Experimental work on this project has been terminated, after an extensive study of candidate enhancing formulations developed internally or from flavour supply houses, using the ~atin6e cigarette as a model. The additives were sprayed onto the tobacco blend. Samples were first screened for basic acceptance by a small panel of 8 to 10 smckers, with those of potential being further evaluated by both a paired-comparison package test (80-100 smokers) and a ranking technique based on the Duncan Multiple Rancie test (20-25 smokers). It is recommended that the best 2 en- hancers be submitted for consumer research, either in a separate test or in conjunction with a product development project. A report is being prepared. CD NJ cc BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 T-6811 Project Gour1ret Personnel: A.F. El Naggar Objective: To develop a cigaret-e with a novel, recognisable flavour. which will appeal strongly to a small but significant segment of Canadian smokers. Status: Experimental work on --nis proJect has been temporarily susuended, :sndinq (-z' analyses of the results of a consumer test series using a --angle cicarette technique in shopping centre booths, and (:~' the scnedulinq of a further test series, dependent on aevelopment priorities. A report on the current s-,atus is in preparation. C:) cc 13 ATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 /16 T-6861 Coated Ciqar Tips Personnel: A.F. El Naggar Objective: To develop an alternative technique for producing sweetened cigar tips, so as to reduce the costly extensive usage of saccharin. Status: Comparative consumer testing of Colts anc Old Port Tipped Cigarillos, carrying either coated cigar-tips or normal cigar tips with incorporated sweetener, has been completed. The test showed that the coated tip products were at least equally acceptable to the conventional products, and in some respects were marginally preferred. However a dramatic fall in the price of saccharin in recent months has con- siderably reduced the potential cost saving of the coating technique, and no decision has yet been made on its use in production. CD NJ -1 t;. U_J c0 13 ATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /17 T-7093 Intercomoarison of 7wo Low Delivery Cioarettes Personnel: R.L. Rice Objective: To find why Craven A Regular cigarettes consis t ly 'Pt yield less tar than Matin6e Regular, and hence to modify our brand so as to give a lower tar yield than its competitor in a subtle, subjectively acceptable way. Status: This comparison has started recently, to see initially whether the small difference in tar yield results from differences in deliveries from the tobacco sections or from differences in the filtration efficiencies. CZ) NJ cc BATCO document for Province of BritiSh ColuMbia 23 April 1999 /18 T-7094 Determination of Pressure Drops durino Machine Smokinc. and Puff-by-Puff Tar Yields Personnel: M.P. Scherbak ObJective: To see if significant differences exist, between ctheriise comparable cigarette brands, in pressure drop during machine smoking and in puff-by-puff tar yields. These oroperties may have an important relationship to some aspects cf subjective acceptabillty, and may provide useful pointers for product development. Status: While such measurements have been made recently for some specific product development projects, a more thorough study is being undertaken of the extent of variation of their 'pattern' down cigarettes for some ITL and Opposition Brands. _C:. C) F\-) IN CC -Z r,_, Ql~ 13 ATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 /19 T-7095 Development of a Verv Low Tar Cioarette Personnel: M.P. Scherbak Objective: To develop very low tar king-size cigarettes havinq the highest possible subjective acceptability. Status: A survey is being rnade of the means of achieving very low smoke yields of tar in cigarettes around the world. To help identi,.'y the most subjectively acceptable design of such a product, attention will be centred initially on the effect of different degrees of tip ventilation, because it is trils design feature which will have by far the greatest influence in reaching the required low tar levels. CD N) Co N) ZN. BATCO document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 /20 T-7338 Coated Carbon Filters Personnel: A.F. El Naggar Object've: To develop a subjectively acceptable carbon filter cio- arette by using coated carbon. The filter should be as effective as possible in reducing the concentration of some components of smoke vapour phase (of biological significance and/or implicated in subjective irritation), while contributing none of the so-called carbon off-taste to tne smoke. Status: We wish to evaluate.the possible use of coated carbon, as suggested by GR & DC, and to collaborate in its practical development. We have adapted some of the techniques of Professor Chang of McGill in attempting to coat suitably activated charcoal granules with different polymeric materials, including polyHEMA, nitrocellulose, hydroxy- propylcellulose, sodium carboxymethyl cellulose, and nylon (Poly 610). For comparative evaluations, cigarettes having triple filters, containing a granular bed between 2 acetate pieces, were prepared by hand after removing the cigarette's original filter plug. In preliminary trials we found that coating with the nylon polymer gave a sample of potential. A small group of expert smokers found a filter containing 70 mg of this sample to give smoke with no charcoal taste, whereas in our hands, filters containing the other samples were less acceptable. At the same time, the nylon-coated carbon bed had an HO filtration efficiency of 39%, and an aldehyde efficiency of 26%, compared to those of a similar bed of uncoated carbon of 49. for each. In this preliminary trial, the nylon coatina was applied by a C:D N) CO 1 J__ N) BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 /21 T-7338 (CDnt'd) modification of Chang's emulsion technique (Science, 146, 524 (1964)). This now has to be checked, refined and its reproducibility determined. BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 /22 T-7339 Ion Exchanoe Resin Filters Personnel: A.F. El Naggar Objective: To develop a subjectively acceptable cigarette having a filter containing an ion exchance resin, so as to speci- fically reduce the irritation of the smoke without causing smoke taste to deteriorate. Status: Filters, sup:ilied by Brown and Williamson and containina pockets of the ion-exchange resin Duolite, have been subjectively tested on J.P.S. tobacco rods. The filters caused a poor off-taste to develop during the last few puffs of the cigarette. We are now evaluating some FACT cigarettes from Brown & Williamson to see if our smokers observe a taste-change near the butt, using the US blended tobacco cigarette. If the Duolite filter has this specific disadvantage when used on flue-cured cigarettes, we will study ways of modifying this and similar resins to over- come the problem. C:) BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /23 T-5503 Evaluation of the PROGRAM Filter Personnel: R.L. Rice, L. Bouchard, 0. English Objective: To see whether a PROGRAM filter will work for flue-cured cigarettes, to identify optimum dimensions for it, and to develop a method of making it semi-automatically. The idea behind this filter, from Brown & Williamson, was to achieve an increase in filter pressure drop for the strong last puffs.of a cigarette, and hence to reduce the tar content of these puffs to achieve a more uniform puff-by-puff tar availability. Status: A novel means of constructing a PROGRAM filter has been found by the Technical Service group, using a narrow plastic tube insert. A joint project with them is now starting to see whether it works with flue-cured smoke, and to pin-point the optimum conficuratio'n for it. Z~' CD co __0 NJ cc E3 ATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /24 T-7275 Miscellaneous Vapour Phase Analyses: Car',,on Monoxide Yields. Personnel: M.P. Scherbak Objective: To compare smoke yields of carbon monoxide from our own and competitive brands. Status: Carbon monoxide levels in smoke were determined for selected I.T.L. and opposition brands. The table shows a comparison of cigarette yields of tar, nicotine, and carbon monoxide, and puff numbers, for the top Canadian brands sampled on June 1975. Type/ Brand Puff Smoke Yields mq/ciqarette I Number Tar Nicotine I CO Filter Regular du Maurier 7.8 14.5 1.03 21.2- Belvedere 7.7 14'. 1 1.10 19.5 Players 7.4 19.1 1.35 19.1 Export A 7.8 15.7 1.25 18.4 Matinee 6.8 8.6 0.52 16.4 Craven A 7.4 8.1 0.57 15.5 Filter Kino Size du Maurier 9.0 18.3 1.32 20.5 Peter Jackson 9.1 19.0 1.32 21.S Number Seven 9.9 18.6 1.2B 21.9 Rothmans 10.1 17.5 1.25 23.9 Mark Ten 10.3 20.2 1.36 25.7 Matinde 9.0 12.7 0.83 17.3 Craven A 9.6 14.3 1.23 17.2 Menthol Filter King Size Cameo 8.0 17.3 1.16 23.0 Craven M 8.8 11.2 0.87 17.3 Plain PTa-yers Regular 8.0 19.3 1.13 18.9 Export Regular 7.5 15.9 1.18 17.1 Mark Ten K.S. 10.2 18.5 1.38 17.4 CD cc BATCO document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 /25 T-7275 (cont'd) A comparison of these yields of carbon monoxide of our brands relative to the opposition brands looks more favourable than last year. The decreased number of puffs with the change to higher porosity cigarette paper for du Maurier KS, Peter Jackson KS, Cameo and Players Plain cigarettes resulted in lower yields of carbon monoxide in our brands. Only one of our brands, du Maurier Filter Regular, showed a significant increase (from 18.1 to 21.2 mg/cigt) in delivery of carbon monoxide. Two opposition brands, Mark Ten KS Filter and Export Plain,showed a significant increase of yield of carbon monoxide. Carbon monoxide deliveries of 20 major Canadian cigarette brands have recently been published in a scientific journal (Robinson and Forbes, Archives of Environmental Health, 30, 425 (September 1975)). CD N.) (44 00 I'D LI-4 C-- BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /26 T-7092 The Nitromethane Fraction Index of Smoke Condensate (NMFI) Personnel: M.P. Scherbak Objective; To determine the Nitromethane Fraction Index for smokes from a number of series of cigarettes related to both our R & D programme and to external work. Status: Work has commenced on the determination of NMFI for smokes from cigarette samples from the following projects-.- a) The Delhi Tobacco and Health Bioassay Programme (T-0439) b) The BAT Janus Cigarette Series; c) The Chemical Burn Modification project (T-7088); d) The Schweitzer-PCL comparison (T-6539); e) The Studies of the Effects of Reconstitution by the PCL and AJIOO Processes (T-6533 and T-6530). (c.f. RL Report numbers 132 and 133), All cigarette samples have been divided into ni-ne sets of no more than seven samples per set. Each set includes a standard cigarette as reference, containing 74.6% flue- cured blend, 7.4. PCL and 18% CRS- 4 :1 CD c0 13 ATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 23 April 1999 /27 T-7708 Tests with Microbial Mutants Personnel: M.H. Bilimoria Objective: To use microbial mutants for the detection of potential mutagens and carcinogens in smoke and for comparing tobacco products. Status: Studies with Ames' Salmonella mutant TA-98 Whole cigarette smoke, collected in glass spirals at -700C and dissolved out using acetone, is able to revert strain TA-98 in presence of a liver activation system prepared from 3-methylcholanthrene-treated guinea pigs. No increase in back mutation was noted in the absence of the activation system when condensate upto 250 pg. per plate was employed. VaDour phase of cigarette smoke, obtained after removal of the TPM on Cambridge filter pads, does not increase the number of revertants using TA-99, but will have to be re-examined using another strain (TA-100). On the other hand, TPM collected an Cambridge filter pads shows high activity with respect to ability to revert TA-98 in presence of the guinea pig liver preparation. TPM collected on Cambridge filter pads also appears to increase the number of revertants with TA-98 above 50 pg per plate, even in the absence of the activation system, although the number of recorded revertants is about a tenth of the number obtained with the latter. In studies designed to find if we could use these microbial procedures to differentiate between tobacco products,we have found that NJ c0 BATCO dOCUrnent for Province of British COIUMbia 23 April 1999 /28 T-7708 (cont'd) cigarettes containing the new smoking material, Cytrel gives smoke with a distinctly lower specific mutagenic activity (i.e. on a per mg basis), than that from regular flue-cured cigarettes. This lower specific activity was observed using both the Rosenkranz E.coli and Ames' Salmonella procedures. It was observed that, when Cytrel was blended with flue-cured tobacco, there was none of the expected lowering of specific activity of the resulting smoke. It is planned to apply this test to a number of samples from our own and external research programmes. C:) N) 00 BATCO document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /29 T-7709 Changes in Bronchial EDithelium induced by Cigarette Smoke. Personnel: J. Johnson, M.H. Bilimoria, H.P. Witschi, J.C. Hogg. Objective: To establish biochemical parameters of tobacco-smoke induced lesions in the bronchial tree and pulmonary parenchyma. It is hoped that one or several parameters can be defined which may then serve as a short-term screening test for the evaluation of product improvement. To maximise the relevance of such a test to the effects of smoking on humans, priority was given to studies of the tracheobronchial tree, over those involving lung tissues. Status: 1. Analysis of Lipid Peroxidation in Cells of the Tracheobronchial Tree (J. Johnson) Experiments have been completed on lipid peroxidation of tracheal epithelial cells of smoke-exposed guinea- pigs. Guinea-pigs (300-400g) were exposed to smoke produced by 5 standard flue-cured cigarettes. At various time intervals (immediately after exposure, 6-8 hours, 18-22 hours, and 48 hours after exposure), the animals were sacrificed and the trachea slit open longitudinally. The epithelial cells were gently scraped off into isotonic saline and then incubated in vitro for 2 hours in thle presence of MADPH, Fe___ and ADP. At the end of the incubation, the thiobarbituric acid (TBA) test. which measures the amount of malon- dialdehyde and hence indicates that peroxidation has occurred, was performed on the incubation mixture. Z~. BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /30 T-7709 (cont'd) It wad found that cells from smoke-exposed animals consistently underwent less lipid peroxidation than did cells from c ontrol(sham-smoked) guinea-pigs. This inhibition of lipid peroxidation was observed in cells isolated immediately after smoke exposure and persisted for up to 18-22 hours later (see Table ). At 48 hours, the lipid peroxidising activity returned to that of the controls. LIPID PEROXIDATION ACTIVITY (00/ma. Prot./Hr.) of TRACHEAL CELLS OF GUINEA-PIG Expt. Description Controls Smoke-Treated Sacrificed immediately 0.087 - .039 0.022 - .015 after exposure Sacrificed 6-8 hours 0.054 - .022 0.026 - .013 after exposure Sacrificed 18-22 hours 0.07 - .013 0.029 - .016 after exposure Sacrificed 48 hours 0.047 - .02 0.040 - .014 after exposure Experiments were also carried out, in which tracheal cells were exposed in vitro to tobacco smoke condensate. Cells were isolated from control guinea-pigs, and sus- pended in saline before being incubated for 2 hours with different amounts of the water-soluble phase of smoke condensate in the incubation mixture. In the presence of the smoke condensate, lipid peroxidation C:) (J-4 BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /31 T-7709 (cont'd) was inhibited in a dose-dependent way. Thus a bio- chemical effect of a system observed when animals are exposed to smoke in vivo could be duplicated by exposing the same system to smoke condensate in vitro. As a result of these findings it was decided that no further work need be carried out on the analyses of lipid peroxidation on tracheal cells. 2. Biosynthesis of macromolecules within the tracheal epithelium (J. Johnson) Preliminary work has begun on this project which entails measuring (a) the rate of glycoprotein syn- thesis and (b) the rate of release of formed macro- molecules into the medium. a) Rate of glycoprotein synthesis. Labelled sugars (glucosamine -C 14 and fucose -H 3 are incubated for varying lengths of time with minced trachea from healthy guinea-pigs and rats. After given time intervals, the incubated tissue is homogenised in trichloracetic acid and the acid- soluble protein (containing the glycoprotein) is precipitated and dried. The dried material is solubilized for scintillation counting, so that the amount of incorporation of the labelled sugar can be estimated. So far, both the guinea-pig and the rat show a linear rate of uptake. Rate of uptake has so far been shown to be dependent on length of time of incubation, and amount of -CZ:. CD BATCO document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /32 T-7709 (cont'd) metabolism tissue. Further preliminary studies are required, such as effect of uptake of sugars on animals pre-treated with protein inhibitors, etc., before actual experiments can be started with smoke-treated animals. 3. Induction of aryl hydrocarbon hydroxylase in ouinea piq and Spraaue-Dawley rat tissues, and mutagenesis in Ames' Salmonella typhimurium strain TA-98. (M.H. Bilimoria). Exposure of various species of laboratory animals such as mice, rats and hamsters to tobacco smoke, generally results in increased activity of the enzyme aryl hydrocarbon hydroxylase (AHH) in the lung. In an ongoing study on tobacco smoke toxicity in guinea pigs, a considerable amount of morphological and Physiological data is being accumulated, and conse- quantly, we decided to determine pulmonary levels of AHH in these same animals. Random-bred guinea pigs were exposed to smoke from 5 cigarettes in the Hogg smoking machine, and an equal number were sham- smoked. Levels of the enzyme were measured immediately after, and 1,3,6,12,24,48 and 72 hours after smoke exposure. No increased activity of AHH was observed in the lung and liver of smoke-exposed animals. In fact, there was a marked depression of enzyme activity immediately after, and up to 12 hours after smoke exposure. At longer time intervals after smoking, CO _~C U4 13 ATCO document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /33 T-7709 (cont'd) no differences were found in enzyme levels in the lung of both control and smoke-exposed animals. However Sprague-Dawley rats,exposed to smoke from the same kind of cigarettes in the same smoking machine, showed a marked induction of AHM in the lung but not in the liver. The effect of treatment with 2 known carcinogens has also been studied. 3-Methylcholanthrene, injected intraperitoneally at a dose of 50 mg/Kg, also did not induce AHH in the lung of guinea pigs 18-24 hours later, while Arachlor 1254, injected by the same route at 500 mg/Kg, resulted in a marked depression of enzyme activity in the lunc. Both 3-methylcho- lanthrene-and Arachlor 1254-treated guinea-pigs resulted in a significant increase in the level of AHH in the liver. In contrast, similar 3-methylcho- lanthrene-and Arachlor 1254-treatments of Sprague- Dawley rats showed marked induction of this enzyme in both the lung and the liver. Our results suggest that species differences in the inducibility of pulmonary AHH will have to be taken into account in future studies on acute and chronic toxicity of tobacco smoke. These results will be presented at the Annual Meeting of the Society of Toxicology at Atlanta, Georgia, in March. Mutagenesis in Salmonella and specificities of lunq and liver preparations. All lung preparations, both control and induced, have c0 I-ID U-4 c0 BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /34 T-7709 (cont'd) thus far failed to activate 3,4-benzo(a)pyrene and tobacco smoke condensate to mutagens for S. typhimurium strain TA-98. It is planned to try other substrates such as 2-aminoanthracene and nicotine in conjunction with lung preparations from guinea pigs, rats and rabbits, as well as from humans. In contrast to the lung, suitable inducing agents result not only in increases in levels of AHH in the liver, but also in increased mutation rates in the Salmonella test. Thus, pretreatment of Sprague-Dawley rats with Arachlor 1254 results in enhanced hepatic AHH activity as well as enhanced transformation of 3,4-benzo(a) pyrene into mutagenic compounds for S. Thyphimurium TA-98. If, however, tobacco smoke instead of 3,4-benzo(a) pyrene is employed with the above rat hepatic AHH pre- parations, no enhanced mutation rate is obtained with the Salmonella strain, even though there is much more AHH activity in the hepatic preparation from Arachlor- treated animals. A similar pretreatment of these rats with 3-methylcholanthrene results in enhanced hepatic AHH activity as well as enhanced transformation of both 3,4-benzo(a)pyrene and cigarette smoke condensate into mutagenic compounds for this Salmonella strain. Similar studies, involving differences in specificities from control and differently treated guinea pigs, are in progress. X~. CD BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 /35 T-0251 Miscellaneous analysis of casinqs and flavours Personnel: A.F. El Naggar, M.P. Scherbak Objective: Analysis of menthol on fine-cut tobacco, as a service to Manufacturing Department in adjusting spraying equipment. Status: 50 samples of mentholated fine cut tobacco have been analysed. This work has since been transferred to the Quality Testing Laboratory. CD Co CD BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999 QD %0 4 th. BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 23 April 1999