2
AVIA71ON SAFETY
and
THE NON-SMOKERS HEALTH ACT
AN ANALYSIS
by
Captain T.W. Monk
Captain J.K. Haywk
Captain J. J. Nake
PRESENTED TO THE AIR CANADA Mac
TORONTO
AUGUST 26i 1991
Ln
CD
CD
co
co
BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 14 April 1999

II.C27. in Act to &MOM tt Non SMOkM'H4W AOL wo sugnM to juns 2g# Iggg.
'he sa is snbnmd ftwh regLUJh% 'The folkwog is a synopses of ft ragulokm &a
WY now 9= --.Ip. - "Yt-
SmoWng It not sibwed m d filgNA o"wed by a Caftdjn Wr CWW
Smddng Li tkwed omhemdonW Oghts pvvb6&
(a) IN Wd. w SQMWA VWSC4 W bMww a poW in Canaft wW g pgk
uodl Ca" I% ha & IMqdM dwtw of * ham or Mong
(b) my &Win of a bgIt w" auW& Cvw* or
(a) soy sWW da ftft whagywfth CavxW. pwyld6d ft tIgM
MOO Cwaft am w pum"m are boards ut C4n&dL
1"a regUaft" am In affed urd ArA 34 1 04 d *4M tMS UM wS be a c=ptets
w an =Wdng Owd 00 %ft OpMAW by Ovidan M"
hist are to hodm*= for M prdoexbrw Pft W4 bm tme emoscw The t" 40*
SUMAMFLOff 8AFMIMOOMMANDAUTdOP17Yftftst*b"byfaft
3S WO&WV
Ion II=
19 d=MM"& W*6&IW ruff qbM $=Wm d a wim MMM - - P w -- - --I --4
I h a Ak CAf wft m- WAMM'do-J. M- k rm 4 &W &=DWd by ft VW MW &* aft
=vj*. br. DaMm Wo.O. MD, win in in ad* pkwad V@ tu cLww
90010i A990dISOO Jwr*4 TV rA 'S*W* =NOW, **4-mW am JW 10
*1 Wder SbnMwMwj6 Wd4 hndid@ m"hwy dktawo O"
*Mm,$, Mmtrolw . 1 NWFMPMWQWWA-4 Rq-
SW. We we d nu% In am" or Jn otafar ft
bw la OMM*Ift, When jbIwkft *= dpmftk or k"MW in a w,O&V
adon PMwM
*OM
no wmlft NW*ft*& MdMw HO d ths Fwww i4c z
kVWdOnModok*xbioe,rfflar4tbSM=WoftkKftNftliWML
II M Wu sham km WA*v In ta =km beam ft www"M age= we
re ddotsr$m ton ts OM* bt pwift &MOM an ft mn smakw. ffl A
'ESTON OF LV-M%,A.
Ln
CD
CD
co
co
--4
BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 14 April 1999

2
The CA1?A Oomfenft IM saw it to man tam.,ha Paw mow itm la
Sutualon 9 - SW* GVWU SMOft in the Cadpt- 81noe ami9ft =Uftu a
hwxd to h6ft W effidovy, ft Is C.ALPA poPq that smddrq r* be -gowed in ft
C060 (C&W&-&M lose).
The Poky M&nLW sW*, ft ShoWd Wm be noted V* In the #y#nt of a COMU OgWggn
the C4nIft:dM W)d Pofty MMUNA to IbrMw WM'W"C
The CWA OwtstMAGn cWY FLU $941 68 " ft Pft*. Afte 1 SwVan 3 (t$
Stilt6c To OMOW at MAWWA the MOW dW4= of Vgft jdaly in the VAmWft
Uxb1try.
The CALPA Oode of EN= sMw AA akft p1lot wV k"p uppermoa tm tds "nd fW
tft "Isty, mnbt to WNF-" of ft pmengers who Gnu= thak DM to hbn are h*
&.A mWabft.
,'$CHEM *Wl SAMMI
The smoft two. spOdk*IY Mddq In them, F4:pk, Is a sd* Wm. 7he mgWaddrw
a Ihey mw SW4 jarbWng Iwan the a=jdmW dprar* is dw@ a carnpromM to
AW
is SnOdw MP In gm wvwng WOUSS.
The A&=Ax AeA dwgu W pW In c=mvA wfth Me rsqxrsbW fair ta age
Down d his GghL As fted by Caplah N. L fik*n ki tb x6ftsfori to the Hwas
Of XNWM SWdm Ommft* on TmwpoM. Vft PW am UAW w4w ft
A&.mWa Act vM the UNmde at&* Ow. &W. 'im ftm "W.
I's
In his argue on
WVW%WMkM# IA 040 $Wfti. W" %@Wfbft
A Cnw Pawas Mw4Qwff* MV*w, PAZ" in, Opwey MAOI&I, CNINVII4
Aaciftt WM= wft-mwdor* ftm hmw famrs as a kAdN mark, figew
Swids to opW* aftity cA* nd be undem*wd.
Ln
00
00
'IO
ja '14 April '1999
BATCo document for Province of British Columb

if, Uwar tne roquawn of ft Nm StnWtW H"M ACL ft Pdak"MMSM VAO It a
a safe mamm ff he &VA smamo, mm PoOk 14gal adon for *%waft hit bw
For the =flj&ww pM to mVV#iy "=ft Zs d@wgld him by ths
UPWIWM*
AffoMud= A4 he n* hM MA &Uft:fty tO dO 94.
THE P1=0MM
Meni don ft tam 200 Air Canal& Dods ft an SmOkL al d
whom havo gredy moMed ftr ux&q in Me wwk O&W MM We tW lo q4
on* option is to go cm GMIP' In Ma* a nOrreptim
ArgMw 13 to ccm* waTts rqJon W not wTu*A an ft tight dat It owed be At
$--Jed that ft 00on 13 bY V MS WMAO =VMML" tO SW".
The tdrd W most Bk* opdm is, ths pM gm to were hwxtn not to smoks WV at
Oa Io time In ft EVK wAkft
TWO of Ow pow d=*V rA M a9ft hm Wmady bftn dwgod undw the Nw
$nick= Hegm A4 658MMId in amt were tund adly and rwdvsd an Abwhft
a=Ufg& ng nog a-dWri4 rd fm can be no daft Wn wN bit mm, r&y
Al ft OW of MA WO *06 ft Cm" &*ad, ft delendarike *" be WwW an a
psetod of X*Xdm Fad MM mqAt bun WWsd wW ft pW raw i MM nd In ft
rMr'OCFM'twCwjdbeChwWVft"I' 61410f!"PW I EMMff4MVWkW%WWft)JdP
drw.sd ft ddwxiut rat oo wricl a in Ihe cocko VW he dd K he MA now be
ctwood Vft =tww d =at 7M MPIOSW4 of AM a 00"Wkft in awba VW
IV MMM power* Am ANN Umm am In PopM. Fa*gn 9"mm wild
dt to a PVwn Wm such II rowd
TM or*" d waft wKw ftu =,dftw Is %7 to& Vdumu ton bun wMen an
tw dwqars d *#V WWK Sb"L Wheft the shm Is awAed by fw* PWOM *r
fewneW pvUen or ww" wxw =dbm WPOW by ms NC@ $=km Holm
PAwd&-jS' ft Wm to MW &V ft =W=" to $W* ft mm
Ln
C)
co
co
__j
U-4
CD
of British Columbia 14 April '1999
BATCo document for province
-------------

t xfi@u6'ajgo -be acted MC. the SVeld CM06d by 'a xaVmPaxod abstinence Li qufte
fifferant and I= more rM the WOW =134d by R MgWltlbry UA In fact r"barch
Amid %QQM region la cWMdf-pMdVCtM ft& ad to the
lazira to amoK& ProhlbOan did not wo&
HH-Y 1-H11 Peg UL&M 7
'ha govemmem, uncor V"St" gpocw and
j from Interm 9taum hum a9OO6G4Ons,-
,*m Non Smoketz Flights Aaocid&4 raspax*d wfth iha Om rVMwgL Whoe #w=
7mups are well ftwea and wd orgmtod. that am af &VGrVU Is W flobt story.
14.LPA wen Invned to c=rneri on the pmpo3ed bgtlktk)n W4 mqmded ftrauo the
@nssidsftfz Offkx- Captain SVWW WOW ft 11hM Pdw ManurA shlemak. "Ameft
at be &Bowed In ft OOdW. (tft ctatsm*M wa rwwjod at Omwandan 1990). N,*
==art at anttlysis was made of the story hpilodow mid the ardy ==wt was Me
rdfl-, chwwrz be tested the same as cMU filgtft
;a a. ramitt of ria ==unk;dqn from CALF,% ft Wow of Tratoport badwool as
widencea by the zm=rwd later. VW CALPA aq= S OW bdn all smafft &based
TECOMMENDED ACTM
-no A1rQumftMECb"Id Me &t9nWdthGCALFA8d8rd CiMrod=fte ==a=
Y Vght $wary wassed in du rqmn No ft ft ftswat wim ft foftft ox
Inimm ft aid-dotm of U =IM C"A P0150y regerft unalcing In ft codgut
Thgm in ft @taraal af wAsdon an". Me Non Smdkem HAWM Regumm" be
mended, gh" Me pid In ownmid ft auftW to dodwa, ft ;ft a
amddng or rawmWg ow; &W
Tral CALPA is ff*x*A of 1he txxm to= coutponent In evition sakW, Ovd *Ift
a tmoke fro* vockpi Is a dasuftle gaa4 &L*y must Whe fix* pdayfly.
'HE PROBAB11M OR RMSILAMgy CHANGE
I VW Gvemmit mporm to tie M nod Of ft ftAdho Cminua an rmrapwt
is Gvemmard pwldon J& aod = rft GovwmrAft Sh&W the Cot=glools bfttd
I avoi&q reguman , 'nice VW r4ollawy, and IB MU d ft suo:ose of ad cdon
mgm= developed w-o@@ In ft WO(k OWAI.
Ln
C)
CD
cc,
BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 14 April 1999

ThO 169W"On ghms th& GM= In COUncd the I(AhOrftY to amend in@ reguistionglt
in Decwbw et 1989 &W agaln W Juno of 1M. Odal 000"10m, the reGul"Ons were
raWW Y1 rospaus to ===W Don0vagmL 9 It f"MonsWe to Wave The W-6ter
wouid r=mmr4 an amanciment on tha Stoma at &won segly.
MIR 008011RAMm-
WOO tham W be no doLd VW dpmb mddtV Is a hoalth W= and 3tx2as have
ft" V* plW4 MM Is somewhat of a heft hoard. rwa is rA dgtp, dIMIM at
OW084 to Ww ft pamW make pm&csd by im =jWwW ft&mft in a 05ftg
.vhg:s ft * Is dwvsd gym we mwek in a stregmt hose j4=&-MjLQMft
I 0 dagvwW to the MWN iM
Cabin WOW ft be affeeW W
ab" prgadm-
Mr, Is IKW opinlM OM BM C27 =M be xjmwU@ djowigeig in. ew =OU Undw
ft twJr Of %ft On a Mx9W of ftOg O" aNIN Willer the IaWt OU41 And
AU*L* N*Nn= rg the tKubdm nKpIrament VW ft employer, and to MM
Owd the w0rm' bW=G " POIN ftm The in" I& in Ckwauk" cancept I am
we rm d La wt%
2Vrot MkIent kmwdpft UdIftwe &Wft rawaft MM= Umm a a
MaNd ak" ahftk W km4pft ab Woodfia W""W-ft a wnbbu" is=,
NO oovwrA&t raspor= VA be tw" Wm &dWW by III CArAdo AIMW PAM
Wocidw to mide VI did* in ft MM" bm
Us" UNA ft MEG response to ft aftsee belaw.
*PL T. W. Mar*
= HadmOns CreL
*ML Onkft
OM Ixe
LrI
C:)
CD
OD
co
BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 14 April 1999