LAW OFFICES
    SHOOK,li4RDY&BACON
    ONE KANSAS. CITY PLACE 0-‡no-ES
    icte 2en, S.8 Sc 1200 MAIN STRE=-T -0 CC-OZE ~DS
    OVEFn-ANDPAPK. KANSAS
    PA4rNFffle~ MrLUDING PR0~ESS10NAL KANSAS Crry. MISSOUFII 641C5
    CO--DRATK)NS 19 OUCKIWG.AU GArE
    (816) 474-6550 tON004 ENCL-0
    July 14, 1992 "S. R 0.
    17 JUL 1992
    Stuart Chalfen
    The Solicitor
    B.A.T Industries p.l.c.
    P.O. Box 345
    Windsor House
    50 Victoria Street
    London SWlH ONL
    England
    Re: Cipollone
    Dear Stuart:
    Enclosed is the letter to Senator Danforth, concerning
    amending the Federal Cigarette Labeling Act, which I mentioned t8
    you on the phone today.
    Very truly yours,
    L7"'n g
    Garv R.
    GRL:pp
    Enclosure
    40- 4: :- "-- -, ~ K I +
    a AQzXt'-X
    N)
    C>
    r1_1
    CD
    BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 18 October 1999

    




    JU- -'-% '952 2l"?40P11 IhC
    JE Rr.'Jf~ bri'-i ;;-47Y Gr-~iER~ZL'C- OFFICE
    .- '-k b 7 4~
    rw#l>ortmqor%t ai Law
    120 BroŠdway 'rse State C-e‡litoi
    News from ~4Š%w Y“pk, NY It' .l AlbOAV. Ny 12224
    … rney
    M0
    Robet Abr=
    lin eHon XMU%Rt (212) 416-8060
    1 PQ2 Ttz7.z3ml UtI 71 471my op 1032
    *œ 262'.Oumx-q Qn Eau S2,22 X= Mr 26U
    Att=t,y Gtnrrai Robe Ab=, i and —t. Ae.=cy… Gencr� of 2e -rithcx st~= tc-day
    Ci huisday) released a lwgr =2 to Se=or lohn C. Dmiuth CR-M=uri~, u:zL-ig-him ta intr“duca… bill
    tz repeal a ft4eral I&W du% prcvtnts stairs from p=t0ceng thtit citi=1 trom mijluditit and dt=;tive
    ..Zustu edvertŒting.
    In tha latter, Mr. Ab?ami md oth*Z Attm=ys Gerienl poirmd oW. th%t although Q16 Statu
    *be-lit-ve that the advenia-eMents of &orne  =;ar~*S May aiso vicWe etit law, we …ra
    =- 3biiity to t&k… enforc=emt az~= b=ue ef the pre~.-,nptive  of Chc- txir…nz ied=l la-W.
    A ccpy et the lctex is
    la  1 ,
    P-WAU
    L
    ftef-110 brand fax inknifflitW G1M*76Pfff*fwW-.5
    A.~ 9
    ~C!*3
    (D
    ~-'j
    CO-
    CD
    BAT Industries document for Legal Services: Health Canada 18 October 1999

    




    WIS A-'y -'ENERALIS
    SMA.== OW )411-1
    DzPA.x-~xx-.r-x o-r LAw
    A~469-1 ABOA.A AM2.A." 1222,0*
    Alftsmdw Gt-*"%
    Tuly 8 ~ 1992
    johft rAnf0rLh
    SCMIS Ru"61 Of!= Br,~Lng 249
    Vr~ted State3 Sarwe
    WuhinSton, D,C, .20510
    0-1 1)eaz Sarx---. D=fc-.z.
    am wrninz m you on b4balf of My"If jr.6 11~m Ametn
    &V1 Gd=21 Of ths
    SrAx--z o'Alaskz, Azrizorm, Ark=sts, Z)alawara' connoctivu-, Florwa, Guj~.-" FAW21i, !dlhc,
    ='10* I-Owl, LL-lisiJOUL, MAIM, MiaxylAnd, WeMjan. Nfl"2pi, N&W 1:
    ;":SOY, 1"1'2WMC'-icZi Oh'O, OkLohonnlly 0902on, Rhode "nd, I  VeT-""'r.
    ex" T
    Wisaonsin to Seek yo,-,- &as-A3U6-jc* in r"ang IS U.S.C. I 1334(b), #?It  C! L~4
    Cigiretze LAbeling and AdY$r:isLn& Act, which Wrniu the st=s' ability to
    dec.4;tivt &QU ard st-tas ag-aiUt tobacco c=panift t~,,jt c.-igago In faJsa,
    -24ing cigazem- ldvaitisim Althooth ft gugeme  in Q;;c1it
    decavtLye Gf alb~
    v Llvyett Crew:. :Itcagnilad that J1334(b) do*3 not Feavrot P-hallAnto4 to L-nintioraLly
    4raudulant advw-:~iirj clai:=, actions rej=~dfng =p1144
    clai=, sucl.1 is imalt
    advar:Lssments which W1 to inform canaur=s ibo%.,t, ar pl2y down, thA haaith ~=zmji
    Lr;--d to =o~-zns, = gnar.Vmad.
    I a,--- 04 cofts:== frorr. unfaL- =d L-audulant b=i:A&s is
    z.n ir= t~hztt his haan traditiorilly rvgubftd by t4e atz= w%dax their polic: power.
    stat"' auzhad is concurrent with du~ Fvdvml T~vA* Com"tission's authoriry to :atullia
    adverdsin
    unY*r s&ation s a ft Yedeni -rral c=mlition kv. (is t:,s.!:.  4s), - pis
    dual stiLta-laderal liw safarmmem has a lang and very p=tive history,
    'Aawevef, b=UA& of 15 U.S.C. j 1334(b) tb4 tobaccz industzy dt~oys a privilestd sta=s
    whartir. it mn t~p mtee within our statet Iiinifimtly insulLtad from tomplIanza with state
    Wt baUevv that the tobacco induatry AhcAlld not be afttdid such prate-c-4d
    f-taws. Tus: Eka other indusaiss QW are subisat to tho dtceptiva M2" ;r%cdtb jur-Isdicdon
    of the Fedeal Trade CarnmIssion, tha tobacco badusm-y shoidd &Lw be requktA to comply
    with state laws pra~Ablcizg %U ty1we Of de=ption. Ad-iardting bythe tzb=-'* Ladm=7 41
    a dix*ct im. Pact on the NAWth And welfixg of our cidlew Wd on atta budtais t&ough
    inctijaud state litalth aze costa. When, in roapo=4 to adverdsins, lbs ftwkst Of dacde who
    amok* expazuU, thia rel*ud health can cosu to tritat Zo 1t!O-Uu=tsr~n8 and long-tarm
    Ukwases Uhat am Unk-ad to =Oldng 140 AU.
    CD
    r\j
    CD
    CD
    BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 18 October 1999

    




    -;j~7 ; U 1 ;~m 1:11  -;;17:1:n_1%f-
    7 ZT-gLS~
    ~Iyi; A" -? M4ER~ S .-. ~4-- - - I "G.
    ;irda--0ax c::rc---.n to ths Stat= lire the rtc=t e6orj by cigwer-m
    c.-rnpazues to inorease the nurnbcr of smokers b tLr  chUran, in jdvt-.dSinjj, ".0ugh
    the uga of cartoon ch=cters such as Jcc C&r.ef ffTh,r==cn panguin ujad to pr=ot&
    T
    X-col cig-arertes. Three studies trepomd in the Jo=jjj of the or-=n N ki Asso,.jA
    Am fA J=j . dOn
    provided si-nificint avidence that thess catoon-Um- adv*-.dsem=ts lead Qhij&cn to
    smoke, W.'We R~ states have be-en free to enact laws probibiring the %-grL ol cigazaturs to
    minors, our buids = tLad wid~ im-Apect to imposing requ=sme.-ju of prohibitions cia the
    ,tdvaj:~sirr of d"m to minors, Such advardsing, indeed, his undtrznjr~d L~e abluty
    of Lhc mtss to eabres their ]awl apinst sale to minors. Ac.-*r-JJnj to one sw~y of tht
    '1111asal shUdreu's cis=rm marka: with d%* inizzdaction of dw 'SMOoth cht--==-
    dpicted in Carftel adveftising, R. 1. keynoW3 Toba=a Company boosad Ju 6=0 of the
    ;~asiggl -uukrt in sales of diSax-mmas ic childrmn trom .0591 before tha ~ampjd;r, W 11.3,0
    of that markmt today. Another. study Shows Ehac 6 ysxj-oids ;-aQQ;rAu jh&T Ice Cam,
    reprewnu cisarefts &Z a mm nearly equal to that- recoplition t~jj Micicay.M.--uss ZW=nts
    t.he Dismy chs=el-
    The Stites hive bemn voy effective in stopping affom by othex
    mirkot h=dous rod ma to cli-tildrom and to-miko unsubamatiated jasal :!L=s to the
    'public in janeral. 7 Our YL-dous decleptiYa actl anti Prutcas Statutes, ta States haye
    U-k--n- WS& advardsing,  enfcrearnent actorl Against 1,11a fccd ijjdUs=7 (,,Or rnj~dnx
    u=ubitantiated claims abou: the hesRh benefits. of carmin ~rodu.-* inc!L4-inj qujka~
    O&CMW, Mxtola Corn OU, X&IlogSs Special K careal, And Sa.-A Lae Chemr2b), the toy
    indus=y (fer fa-aurs to adtguately wam of ths choking, str=jul&don or other h=%r-41 posed
    by aermLa toys L-itandad lot u4s by &mall childran includinz Fithar Limle "Poople,
    Avon's ?2e. ch-a MaSit Drag= iLftd L~c Cermtry Sztoller)  asdei-da com;Wies (such U
    - hernLLWn 1" 1 ;~ P
    or rusrspresentins tha safety of pesizides QaZd fbr honu uu), ejec:rc,:uo
    ap-Plianes com;iams ~such as BeUnzhi, Shatfina and Walbilt for advan-Wng 3;aca hatiors
    -az Ute ur=--ndid in chilt-L-w-s' roarns), vid the rn&nuALa=r---i of over-t~.e-ccu,-,--g- 4-.jg3
    (:*o, oversta-ing the health hanefits usociamd with the use of ~roducu such ss L-aderle
    Lai=tar-~-T SM633 Tabs, Rartr's Aic:iptin, and Stkriinz Drvg x MISal),
    AlthouB.h, we beave thit ija adyardserrumnts of 1C.-ne toba-c-co'con, pin:=
    may also violsta tam lawl we = Umilad in our abilily to taJa =forcement iedofj ~e=jsa
    of the pre-s.-rydva effaco. of 15 UZ(:. f 1324(~). If && sacz'4z keft,mpollAd, the &=I
    etuld :agultt: cigueno idvensint in the more mas=r dutt: ti~ cw-midy :ejullcs ft
    advardsiu;-Z of vivu&Uy eva.-_v odier industry that dws bu:d=ss In uxeLr sutes. In sdtjitian,
    with r"al, itates would be enccumpd w ad.-: 119ill-i =Irl, r*siLrd--'.-4 the ;1acarnetr of
    d4girette ads to ansure dl,= th=a ikdvcz-d3an=nt3 1; not AVpea In the Emmedle, vicir-Iry oi-
    SChOO13 of 0!h47 AMU Where ChWf= WOUW be thair ra= MrZtt
    In light of the rtc*nt Supreme Cour. dodsion, the cljxrw *14forts of some
    tebzc-.* =n-Pluuts to to chil&gn, the Inaztivity of the Federzi jovernment
    to stop this ff=kadng rac=&, and ft diract. impact that an Lvxem ir the number of
    smokers hu on &= hasEth cars costs in our stitts %* urS,* you to Ww staps to rer-peal 15
    U.S.C. I 13424~o) so that the mtos will hive Kfi concurreat iutho:4.:y,vA*-1% the ~eder:tj
    Tmde Carr-mission cc reZutits deceptive or mslexding aigiaxams adverniml.
    .2-
    IN,;
    U-4
    co
    NJ
    BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 18 October 1999

    




    -p7-'L17
    jkjL 13 '9'~ 'H O~P'Cr"Rf~--
    Gal 14'rS ATr( MIERALS CIFF?:2 TIS
    availablb to YOT4,. JU Y=
    We will miks ourselves =d our salf-A convtMeMC4,
    to di&c..Iss d2ii istue And provide fbv%har A3111ftnet to y0u.
    VC-7 ly yourS I
    ROBERT ABRAMS
    A=rnty GentrAl Of the SLIM of Mew York
    CIURLES E. COLE
    .A==ay Gen=4 of Alaska
    GRANT WOODS
    Atome~ Gafteml of Ar!2=
    WLNST024 BRYANT
    Atj=ay Uener2l of Azkftn&U
    C.MMES M. OBERLY, M
    Anorney General of Dtlaws=
    ,k=.-noy can" of corzaa--4cm
    ROBERT A. BUTTERWOILTH
    A=may Genwal of Mozi-da
    I
    1LIZARIT11-1- RARRF=-AN7)F340N
    AVD='Y GllrltrZ Of (3"=
    WARRSN PRICE, U1
    Anorney Gemaml of F.AwxU
    LAI-URY F-CROF-AWX
    A=Vily Genar&L o" Idaho
    ROLAND W. BUPIM
    Am=ty Cenaaa of Mads
    30N'~= 7. C-Awlkwl -1
    AdofwY Cvea*Ml of .16WIL
    RICRA= P. 12YOVE
    A=rnsy 00=16L d.1AUw=
    NaCHARL 2. CAR22NMiR
    A=-My GMMXL Of MaL-A
    -3-
    rQ
    CD
    rQ
    L^j
    BAT Industries document for Legal Services Health Canada 18 October 1999

    




    JUL 13 '92 e7:42AF1
    j-.9V- Q2',12 FRCM NYS A-ire SENEAr-L'S CFFICZ
    .'I. JOSEPH CL73.Ali, JR.
    Amamay GenerZ of Marylanzi
    _L3 Y
    A=rney (3durg of M1:hjp.-,
    M= MOORE
    A=may General of,Wnissip~
    .1011V P, ARNOLD
    An=pPy General of W&W HAMpshiTe
    ROREXT 1, DEL TWO
    Ar,-d-,tey Ctneral of New .14ruy
    TOM UDALL
    Atorney Getzr3a Of 144W 14-ttcO
    0, LES F=am
    Ar=uy Gvla%l of Ohio.
    STJ,I,kN B. LOVD43
    ,A=rn.ey OfterAl of CW2~0:=
    S, CROO)C-Z.A.M
    A".rnzy Goneral df Orelon
    ;AMES S. OWEM
    Gefta:sl of
    DAN MOP-Al.
    Artomby Gqlamd
    PAUL VAN DAM
    An=ay Gamral of yJt1h
    JF.Fr-?,vy L. ANMTOY
    A=r.'Ay C*9,.I'-'d d Ve=00=
    1ANW E. DOYLE
    AtUMBY (3enefilpf
    I
    N
    cz>
    BAT Industries document for Legal Services Health Canada 18 October 1999