1987 Annual Report rQ C) C-11, BAT lHatsmin P.LC. MINNESOTA Dvasffm Copy - PwwcED PUr=ANT To VILD. OF CONSENT JUDGMENT DATED S/M IN SrATE OF UNNEsam, Er AL v. Pmxv Nbaga Er CASE No. CI-94-OUS FIQ C C> 1-4 B.A.T lNousTREs mr. - MmmmA DEposrroRv Copy - PROOLIcED PURSUANT To I VILD. oF CONSENT JUDGMENT DATED 54196 IN STATE OF ANAMSOTA, ET AL v. PHxp Akgmm ET CAsE No. CI-944MS 84 TUS /tic. Financial Highlights %fitt- For the Year lqu 1964 1995 M6 1987 % Chan@, CGR%l sah. from OmmOnvin: 01@rvtim- .414.11413 *417.6 F53*7 14SAW MAU hl, Set Olwrmtioz Inootor fr4an C.Atiouing 4,22 4 676 t 702 9" S Bob 51, 917C Pr@tax lon-me fr--m C@Nlioulft; 01-rati.-n. 4-14 $ 544t I.L 36' Ima-mma, (f.m Continuing Oltermtkon* z .13:1 8 2W S 329 6 364 $ 4" Nq 19% Net Inn.m, .4 239 F 314 S 164 $ 394 $ 466 181, 16% C@nlinuinc (11wratin, ;W-f Nq .1yrr 33% 43cc 30`1, 10% capital EX;Wndilurv, S ISK) f -494 * 294 f 231 8 248 7% QC,omj%suxd Growth Rate Lf Sohn/ft. Ll Opremaillf @4LS COW-W laremeftmm Operations comamebw OP-1-i-l- 3 Sehefrom OPOMMAW t comminviing laftow/rom, coatimulair Openaim. ]LIn S4 MW 4- C) CO BJLT IMJMIES P.LC. MMEWA DOMffORY COPY PWWCrcD PUMWAKT To VILD. OF Comm JuDotam Dan 516M Im SrATE oF Afimmsom ET AL v. Pmxp Atagm, CAsE No. CI-944M5 Chief Executive Officer's Statement While Brown & Williamson B& W had an outil2nding 1987. Tobacco Corporation IM11) hail Although the domestic cigarette an outstanding year with operatin; market continued to decline. 1113`9 income advancing 14f/'e. retail and wai@ able to achieve revord s*lr* an4; paper both regiotrred drelinei for operating income of @2.5 billion and the year. Thi@ performance is S613 million. respecti%ely. A key disappointing. lout it also highliphii; contributor to growth in 1987. we, a key oirrngth of BATUS: diver- the lons-awitited liberalization of sity. BATUS conAists of major import; in the Japancor market. compunir in the tobacro. paper B&IR'wei. prepared for the change and retailing industries. and this sind aggressively marketed its diversity continues to provide hal- brandio. giving M; products a head- ance and strady earnings growth. start. Bv she end of 1987. B&W hail achi eved a 23t/-c share of the uring 1987. BATUS once Riflifights of Operatiom import f egment in Japan. again achieved record In many respects. 1987. was a Total rigarette volume in- financial results while Year of positioning for the future. errs" 1147c. due to increased p sipificant progress in Substantial investments were made international sales. offset by a positioning our existing businesses in each of our businesses and a decline in domestic market share. for future Frowth and develop- renewed emphasit, was placed an C-4PRI. a unique ultro-slim. ment. Investments made during being a leader in terms of quality women's-oriented cigarette. was the your will build on current and service. Along with theme succesisfully introduced with volume strengths. making BATUS compa- progroins. which were designed to in 1987 reaching one billion units. nies more productive. giving them build a competitive edge. we were a competitive edge. also able to improve our capital Quality Issues Consollidated sales from cost- structure. Cash flow, including A@pleton Papers Inc. faced a tinuing operations wen $5.8 dw sale of certain accounts rfteiv- difficult and challenging year. The billion in 1987. rising approxi- able. rose to 8745 million and growth rate of carbonlas paper in mately 6% from 1986. Operating BATVF overall delim"uity the Visited States slowed and coin- income grew by 5% to $886 miJ- ratio was subptantially reduce@. cided with renewed efforo bv coin- %on. anotkwr record. More im- This financial position enables as petitors to expand sales. In ihil -pressively. net income from con. to move forward with the acquisi- extremely competitive environment. tinuing operations rose 28v,-v to tion of a fourth business leg. Appleton*s sales rose 8% above S466 million. benefiting from lower financial services. In that vein. it 1986. but operating income declined income tax rates and higher inter- is important so point out that aince 6%. Mestowhile.Appleton remains est income resulting from Signifi- the beginning of 1988, B.ALTUS he% the world's largest producer of car- cantly higher cash flow. Income been actively engaged in the bonless paper and has adopted from continuing operations hai, proposed acquisition of farmers strategic* addressing quality. grown by 19'o-t per year since 1983. Group. Inc.. one of the largest customer service and low-cost a performance in which we take property and casualty insurance production designed to insure great pride. groupi in the United States. We continued growth and sucens. However. we are not as believe further diversification is an The BATUS Retail Division gratifird with the breadth of important step in our continued wap affected by the poor domestic performance among our various growth. We wiR keep you in. consumer economy. which worsened operating businesses for 1987. formed ai, events unfold. following the Octolwr stock market B.A.T INDUSTRIES P.L.C. MONOWA DEpoUrM Copy pM)M=o Pw=ANT To VILD. OF CommT itioaWNT DATED SIM INSTATE OF ANAMSOTA, ETAL V. FIN@P AkRiM, ETA CAM140-C1'94*M5 BATE S Inc. dreliter. Di"Ivlwiintingpslr@ and marlirt, in which it participate.. Carl J. Hrpr. E%Peuti%e Vice intensified eumlortiti%e preempurri. Briouner-' 198'. retult. %err noot Preeident of Bropun & Willism.,oon particularly during the Christrun- - nil to enpertatiuns. lout u numlorr TiAoscro Corpioratiton us,, alo- mawon. orroulted in increased of otel), hvvr lore" taken to im- pointed April 1. 1988. Senior Vire markdown, and lotoorr marpow. prove proAprorip for thit buAn"s. President and Chief Financial Sak, Fifth Avenue and Thimhlr,* loorrformatirr Wa, Offirer and a member of the Mar-hall Firld'o *al" perform- d6slolmintirt., BATUS Board anti Executive once during 1987. remained in the Committee. topp quartile *of major competitors Economic Outlook Arthur C. Martinez. oo list with sale- rising by. 5"t and 9%. Thr United Stalep economy joined BATU5 in January 1987. mpertively. lvey*s and Brr- continurt to groot in what it, now st@ Senior Vice President and a une"* sales fell otbars of 1986 the longest peacetime expansion in memloorr of the Executive Commit- lerelo. Total BATUS retail sales this century. but the rate of ter unit Board of Directors u as. in inerraved 41% but operating profit growth haf diminished. Thr March of 1988. Oven responsibility fell -.12h million belou 1986 levelo. husin", environment is likely too for all BATUS Re-tail companies. reflecting door generally soft retail hr diffkult in 1998 Wcause con- John MrDunough. Senior Vice market. While 1987 was a disap- sumer #pending it expected to President of BATUS has been painting year for retailing in remain soft and may not be offset named Executive Vice President of general. we have taken strategic by increased industrial activity. Brown & Williamson Tobacco ottepo to improve the position of We have planned each of our Corporation and a member of the our retail companies. businesses on the basis of a slow- Board and Executive Committee. growth economy in 1988. We Donald R. Nlidkiff. President Ro" Expansion believe " is the most prudent of Ivey's. was appointed Cldef Saks Flfth Avenue announced course of action. enabling us to Executive Officer of the 24-itore a plan of strategic development continue our record of strong BATUS unit as port of a manage- including inverunerst. spending of financial performance. ment transition occasioned by the SM million over the next five We plan to further our diver- planned retirement of Joint# H. years for new units and renova- sification by entering the financial Shaw. tionso(exisdrigotom. Marshall services industry through a major Finally. and most impor- Field'# abo announced major acquisition. We see this industry tantly. I would like to thank the irestment plans. focusing on as a major growth vehicle for us 40.000 emplovers, of the BATUS existing store locations. The over the long tem. companies who have contributed Width toftheplanisthe$110 to our succe s. The coming year million State Street flairship store Mansipment Chatip" will be challenging. but I am renovation which urill he the single Barry D. Bromley. Senior confident it can lie rewarding. I largest in the history of U.S. Vice President and a member of am sure I speak for all BAMS retailing. the Executive Committer and employ"s when I say we are up to lvev*t experienced an ex. Board of Directors. was appointed the challenge. trouroely tough year as the convoli- Chairman of British-American dadon of the Florida and Carohno divisionp proved to be a greater Tobarru Cie.. the B.A.T operating group respinisiblor for tobarru disruption to the business than intereso in over 40 countrirz. In planned. The consolidation iii, now connection with that appointment. Henry F. Fr4on completed. and Ivory*o, should lw Mr. Bromley hap relinquished hip Preoncloont & able to take advantage of the BATUS responsibiliti". Chief Executive Officer B.&T INDUMIES P.LC. MINNESOTA DVIOSITORY COPY P"OWCO PU"WAuT To VIIA OF CONSENT JUDOWN'T oaw swu im STATE OF AWKSOTA ET AL V. PmLr AJORRM ET A CASE NO. C14M'M5 BA TL I W;.- Bts,ine.- Rej icir roar" & Williatinson To6wileco Corporation B set" ro@r Sq, to $2.3 billion and operatin; income int-reaswd 14% to a new high of merM00million. 8&-'K-rr- mair"41 in the numlwr three ,Q@K position in the U.S. cipt-t-Ite induan. Domeo,tirmorketAire v fell v* en tenth# of a 1wreentag point to 11%. while total indu*tr% sk. ciprettr volume in the U.S. in 1987 woo dowrl L%. B&11**s internationid volume more than doubled. The join in opersting profit woo due to higher domestic cigarette price# and the silmifi- candy improved international )t contribution. reduced by hither I marketing investments and lower domestic unit volume. Major investments in key components of its business helped Brown & Willismson Tobacco Corporation maintain its profit- able and competitive positions in the domestic and internstionall marketplaces. During 1987. B&I'increased its investmento in technology necessary for the development and introduction of nrw products, and gove particu- ter emphasis to quality in all its A KEATrioaronvo operations. The company bol- .4joy. hie oterrd marketing and sales efforts )ape. h,- 11-ri in support of strategic established & wa--es-M brands. and applied additional So fak.-W-r., W r"Sureft to the expansion of Shp hotog.. ovrrWe&* "Ira. C: 4 B.A.T INDLOWMIES P.LC. MWNUWA DEP=TORY COPY PROD=D PURWMT To VILD. OF CoNsENT Juclatzmr DATEo 5I&W iN STATE oF AfmwsoTA4 Er AL V. PHLP MORRO, ErA CASENO.C14M4=5 V Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corporatio" Established Brands Conpumrr preferenrei, for Tw.,..,. Sustaining the poLitiosn@ of io prioilucto offering hoth quality anti yol" "tabliohed lorand, were among value have created additional 1 U MA"i, top prWritirv in 198 -- oplinrtuniti" fior B& W*s@ eistah- U intenoifird marketing ant] i6airs, lished brando group. pr4agranso %pre introducril its key In 1987. B&W launched a murketsi throughout the vo)tjntrv lbilot program to gouge consumer that rmphaAzrtl the quality and respowe to offeringf of additional value that B&U' lorandi offer. value on the BELAIR. RALEIGH Amon; the ramjwizn@ for and VICEROY brandi. Price e4tublished bran(b wa@ a program discount# at the point of purchaor J4 for KOOL. MU"s flagihip %pre particularly well received by 83 hrand. and the fourth bem-setling purchaservi of BELUR and brand in the U RALEIGH. who also receive park To-- With menthol brand con and carton gift coupons redeem- 3 sumers showing increased prefer- able for quality merchandisse. lot ence for Issuer -tar - product%,. WK, also focused on revital. B&Ill'introduced the -KOOL and izing the internationally popular Mild Toda@ - campaign for its BARCLAY brand and unveiled an KOOL Mild# styles. This high- -ultra-alim- style in the fall of %ifibility campaign. focused in 1987. BARCUY Lights Men regions; with stronF concentra- Thins are available in a ilip-open tions of menthol iunaker*. consists box in both menthol and non- of advertising u4n; a wide menthol styles. variety of media. The campaign 83 is supported by unique promo- tion* designed to communicate robwro directly with consumers at the op"vt-f ussint. a( purchasoe. As Based an consumer rr*ponsr its the IKOOL and Mild Today- campaign. B&Wcontinues to expand the program. along with marketing and sales atupport for the KOOL parent brand. 5 PQ UM r@-j B.A.T IMSTRIES P.LC. MMEWA DEPOSITORY COPY - PMMM NIMANT TO VILD- OF CONSENT JUDQWNT DATED SIM *4 STATE OF A*WZSOTA, ET AL. V. PHLIP MOW& ET CASE No. Cl-944MG BATUS 1987 Business Review New Products WRNE"o commitment ti.4. fering von@umrro quality and in- novative prioducts Ir4l to ex- panded marketing of the ultra. stint CAPRI cigarettes during IM. Consumer troted in Louisiana rarlv in 1987. bv vear- end CAPRI WsA available in KOM @07D@t areas of the countr% containing approximately 45% of cigarette share potential and attained an average market share of .731NY in those markets. Innovative in both design and packaging. and menufac- "u"t tured to the highest degree of i. kiw quality. CAPRI offers H&W a mpp.md.iih - viable entry into growing se;- ments of the market. and re- spondit to the preferences of adult female smokers for box- style and ultra-length products. The slims segment represents about 6% of total retail cigarette sales in the U.S. Es:panded domestic distri- bution or CAPRI is planned for 1988. and B&W is positioning CAPRI in select international markets. V SUL 102 B.A.T IMKWMS P.LC. MWNESOTA DEPOSITORY COPY PRODUCED PURWMT TO V11.1). OF CoNsENT JummPer DATED SINN w SrATE OF Aftwsom Er AL v. Pmxp Akgw, ET CASE NO. C14M-M5 Brown & 1; illiamson Tobacco Corporation Value Brands late in 198'. began test market- B& It' remained strongly pa- ing an extension of RICHL46"ID sitioned in the fast-growing value- as a 20's offering at a generic for-monry segment with a 22.5% price. RICHLO"D 420*j are market share - a category which being marketed in four styles - gained 1.3 percentage points in Kings. Light Kings. 100's and market share in 198T. and repre- Light 1OVS. sented 10.2% of total cigarette in4lu.try sales, Internalional B&A, competes in the B&W*s international busi- generic category through sales of ness grew drams fically in 198 4' MM-branded black and whites - more than doubling in unit and the -GPC-Approved- brand. volume - and produced a The company also markets silmilicant increase in operating FALCON for consumers who income. despite major marketing prefer -branded- products at a investments. generic price. and RICHL ND in Growth in international a 25-for-dw-price-of-20 pack. business was largely the residt of F Levels of product shipments B&W*s efforts to increase remained high in the value cate- market share where the com- gory. although 1987. sales of ge- pony already had a presence. nerics declined slightly. Industry and the seizing of opportunities shipments of 25's indicate that in new markets. particularly in segment may be nearing its peak. ' Asia and the 36ddle East. In contrast. industry shipments The liberalization of to. of braniled products selling at bacco trade policies in Japan generic prices grew by nearly two and Taiwan was smosif those op- percentage points in 198'.. portunifin. MW anticipated With an eve on increasing its participation in the market for branded-valur. products. R&W. Z 4 1b: I C ;17 1 LIO Z B.A.T IMUSM19S P.L.C. MINNEWTA Dposffm Copy pRmcEo Puimmr To VILD. OF CO"Kw iuoQmNr DAYaD SAWN IN SrATE OF &ONNIESOrA, Er AL._V. pHxAp Afogm& Er AL, CAsE No. C14"U5 HAT[ S 198-. Business Re rivir he 1, S, isu- parts to thar cauntrie6 and. after expanding its distribution 17 channels. quickly emshliolied its roducts amon th l adi . r e ng p g imporsed brands. q In the second quarter isf 7 198-.. KENT Milds wa@ intro- need in Japan. jnining the : ]ready familiar KENT brand the". KENT Mildt soon 6-came the fattest-growing U. 1. import in Japan - so popular that B&NI, had to initially airlift site product to Japan in order to meet con- A sumrr demand. B&V* had positioned I---", wosqf, .."i LUCKY STRIKE Charcoal in @Irwp@ionqs,di*v. Japan a year earlier. and that 9'. od@ product continued to show good G-ro.. growth in 1987. P"i-fanar@. Additonall market expansion in Germany. Switzerland. Bel- opportunities in the For East are tium and Holland. World tra%el- expected as trade discussions er, al,s- roulil lju% CAPRI at continue with the government of dut%-frew ehoop, Korea. BAU A-r-r--.-ntinu-l Marketing and inks strate- From Ih its the issl@rujtinnssl Oita paid dividends in other parts mark@i. and hu. tuappoil -trvi- of the world as well. including gir. a) III--- Europe and the Middle East. tuniti- where BARCLkY and VICEROY showed significant volume pins. CAPRI made fts debut in the international marketplace. *riling @A gi.& T IMXWrRMS p.LC. MONOWA DV*8ffORy Copy PWMED ftMANT To VILEL OF CO"Kw Juawamr DATSO MW IN STATE OF A(IMNSOTA, ET AL. V. PHX1P MORROX, Er CASE No. CI-944MB ,4 ffi.,@h -Aw, iW1.6.1FA. .bw.t 8-4 C'Uh-'. H"I.. r_h@j 9-Q, introduction of the uniquely stylet CAPRI brand. At the 7 same time. attention to quality led to investment in a new cold storage facility at the company'i cigarette manufacturing plant in Macon. Georgia. Employ througliout the fts 00-1 company at B&W headquar- ttrs in Louisville. Kentucky. at facilities in Wilson and Winston- Emphasis on Quality Salem. North Carolina. and B&W*s emphasis on quality Macon. Georgia. and in sales as- extended beyond its products to signmento in the United States a 4-1ra-adt include administration and and abroad - remIptize the operation* compeny-wide. From importance of quality to O&W's leaf buying to data proceti,ing. success and p-owth. B&W channeled retources to create rVater employ" Swart- nefi# of the Agnificance nf quality rjl,. to the roviol total consumer wiffeetion with its products. The qualio. improvement pnwroo pia.#41 a key role in the suver-4fid &velopment and c:: Brown Williamson Tobacco Corporation BAT INMOMIE11 P.LC. MINNESOTA DONWITORY COPY PRMCED PUMANT TO V"'D' OF Comm JucamEmr DATEo 54ft IN STATE OF UNAIESOTA, ET AL V. PHLV UORRS IT CAsE No. C14M4M5 BATIS 11OV.- Hit-itse- Rvrwi4 Ppleta" Papers letc. A o-ontinned it4 leadership l,-1tiw3 in ths- rarloonle.- pwjwr market in IU3-. T.. main- d tain the rontloan@ *@ current , po,,ititm and a.,ure it@ future lvadrr4iils. Appleton made @uls. ittantial effoort@ its improve quality at uU Irt el. 4the "ranization. Z;Aa Slorrifiv ottrair-pi" fsecu.-ed on im. pro%ed rctrarrh eifi,rts. #-one- a puter capabilhi". cunnnerr service and manufacturina I '2alro inerra,tA in 1997 for the 1011i consecutive %o-&r to S779 million. Price inert a*@6" and moderate- unit volume growth contributed to the increase in tiales. Appleton'* operating income of Q126 million decLined 6% com- pared to 1986. This decLize Mawed five conetecutive years of AN, increased operating income. whichhad averapd approxi- enstely 20% per year. A number of factors estontributed to lower profito. Pulp coAtt rose substan- tialk anti competitive presoures ineremord. inhilkitine the ability to) 7 1 d,, -i-q-, -4 Voossostolwyaom., lei -4 -J LAJ IMUMES P.LC. MWMWA OMWORY COPY - PRMCED PURSUANT To VILD. OF CONSENT JUOQWNT DATIED 5/8M IN STATE OF MMMSOTA, Er AL v. Pwp MORRIS;, Er CASE NO. C14W4M5 c_ Applefoll rai- jarive-. Its wl,liti.on. 4,ne. ami rplata-d V- Unit . ..... t. a.."vialed %illi vapat.- e-Impnwol %oa- -turil-11 JUHH; V187 rn it.% r%pan.i"n and pf-4,411JI-1 ins- at tit,- Apph,wn. 11 723 insiput-trel i-atinz- plum. Th,- new .-,,jter. -vi 6.39 -urning- bw in 1988. %.ill nmrv than tit tupan!'- ther- inal paper I-r-horti,m cupavit Tit,- qualit% -of tit,- NC R Tit,- equippin; Pip--r brand Ile-eirrh Center %aa. pularr. the vftnsjoan@ % prineur% r-nupleted during 11087. In addi- 1-r-luet. ti-k a 4--nificant iiiep titan t-- the baAv and C.-mard. E-tabli-Iihig applied re-vurrh fttnvti#,n-. the -in-lo higher -tandard, (air raj- renter 11.0111- a #be- air- umter.. Appletton Palwr-* rr- %astral gas pullo anti pulter re-rart-h. -a-wro-bef-A detr6jord metimil, is, Thu.. th, favilit % pnoviole. the 11111111`-V%@ the lormitirt', -hoert rapabili1% it. 111jrur all a,pect. of A 134 aplorarance. v,tjo! inuaspr anti pajorr re-varch in@itrin; that printin; prr@p 1,erformuncr. Appleton rensain, a Thoo-te impni,ormento. combined leader. with enhativral vu,,tonst-r so-g-vi" Further Inviorrin; the anti the rarpooitiussin; of carlion- compan! 'o re-rurrh anti develcap- levao jor(Niurt, through jorowfut- Meng V11116gircring effort,o during differentiati.on otragivi:irii. srv 1987 %a, the adslition of a new Dr- 117 ri orpnigthening the romisony':, avelcipment Scrvif-P4 Center. ThiA U 19 W popAtitan in the marlirtIslare. new tud-ility will vontain pilot sarrv. _ 4 p V Appleton matir airgunisfir it". whivis istrindr- e%javorimental . nrid" in inerruatin; 05- asharr of runterA anti capouir Manufacturing the thermal palser market during equipment: graphjco grvid produri 1987. Growth fear Appleton evoluation: oirvelitioment rigazinerr. 1@ . ....... --i1irrivaul Paper"! wm@ stioursrd Iq ing: anti prmiuct afri%. ,he ri.mjsan@ *p ar,oiPpmrn, or new probtlum.. fnr ugr in favoirfaile muchine- anti InIsarl printerr. To, -ervict- thi. groming market. c-noatruptioln off a thermal pularr 44 N@ Q\ co B.A.T IWUWRIES P.LC- - MMEWA DEIMITORY COPY PWWCED PURWANT To VILD. OF CoNsENT JuoomEwr DATED 5/8W IN STATE OF UIANESOTAis ET AL V. PONLIP AOORRM CASE NO. C14M-MS BATUS 1987 k1winess Review Pulp and paper rr@rarrh activities have alrrad %. 1wen instrumental in improving the base paper fon which man% of A llaprr@ are ppletoa*s specialty made. And. the quality of thu" 71P. base papers directly contributei to the quality of end prtw(urtf. Another important str2tecic Investment in 1987. %a- develop- LA ment of ApIalrinn% compuier AIQ capabilities through an upgraded Information Services Depart- ment. The department is de. voted to supporting the A Appl- P-yw-* company's continuing efforts mpt.- -p--Wd toward enhancing pruduct P-w-w@ le-p- quahty. customer service and .,d, vp-r- production efficiencies. i"kfWf4 in M, m Replacement of outdated and jwri@"q.w, undersized computer equipment was completed during the year. rendi. vwrr than half of all,u,- greatly increasing computing 1omrr,.r4lrr, ar,- 1--m; plo-d speed. reliability and capacity. thr..u;lt -,ne,.( I- -i@,tn@xu. The strengthening of total com- order @wr% -trw. puter capacity boosted the Pr...11, wtom, j:--m- -@rr overall efficiency of the orpni- sicnirwand, uj@z-rd-:-l 'Writt.. dw Itation and. specifica0y. lint- vear. k @= milli.-r. r-lurk-h- proved customer service. Cur- ma,lmw At 0w A arr.-Li-n. ON- 111ill lor ... ho, i w. : r-lis. 6 1 SUL? B.A.T INDUSTRIES P.LM MMNESOTA DEPOWORY COPY PRODU= PURSUANT TO I VILD. OF CONSENT JUDGMENT DATED MSG IN MATE OF ARNWSOTA, ET AL V. PMLP AIM11110, Er CASE No. CI-944=5 4& Appleton Papers Inc. machin- at that mill have been 7 rreonstrurted sinct- it wam ac- quirril in 1984. and thr mill is nOW t114211% 461fiCtited to the pro- durtion of carbortirso paper. 7 Appleton is aho adding to its ; Coating capacity with the con- .0 Z@@ struction of a fourth high-ipeed custer at 44 Harrisburg, Peemsyl- vanis plant. Completion of the $28 million coater is fchedultd for earl% 1989. De velopment of a new A .4@ A f meibod of packaging paper ralls. which utilixes interleaved foam and *trrtch film. was developed Pm and implemented. The higWy dnvipdb *, Appks@ protective package provides pe product quality assurance and enhane" customer satisfaction. In order to maintain a C*40.4" pop- Appleton*s position as the market pw1wWR rM.,*Y leader. the company continues to W prepare itself for what will be a AA.f 1":, do Ae challenging future. Appleton I"# C.P"A.4 "dt Papers is resolved to maintain its 11w 1k.."A th. A.: market leadership and its highly .0- P.F,, profitable growth. Every aerate- &.4i. Fie move. every capital expm&- ture. is aimed at Improving one or more of what Appleton sces as its kryi for future success: quality. cuptomer service and production efficiency. FAA 1! r_@\ 13.A.T INDUSTRIES P.L.O-' MINNESOTA DEPOSITORY COPY PRODUCED PURSUANT To VILD. OF CoNsEwr JuoGmENT DATED SON IN SrATE OF MINNESOTA, ET AL V. PNLOP MORRIS, IT CASE NO. C1 94 0605 114TE 5 1987 84mirs- Rvvit-u in ill.- L.S. in 191:7 isue difficult. Con-unier -Im-ndin, 1wranor %,-r% Urtail uJr- -,rl,wth s1w."d i-rubli diroughoul the yt-ur. 4.111111inating. ill a 1).H.r fourth quartri- follmAing Ih, -t.wk market vra*h in Ovwb,r. %- a r-ult. rouilwlifi%o, jkrt--.tkr,-- inti-n.ifird and prion.161,1141 A4-- li%iii,- inerva,rol. tirgati%r1i aflrcting profit mar;ill'. Cou-ilurnil.%. 4-on-4slidateJ "It, offlir BATUS rutailing rwit- louni.-P greu onl% 4"Ir Io S2.6 billi.m. and olorraling iumme lim-lins-41 13"@c lei $171 milli,-n. While 1987 wasi disalolowintiou in trrm@ of financial liserformance. rach buoineAs made major inverl- morewtv, that will imisrosve volviloorti- ti% r lKOAtioning and future, profit powerntial. Each company deve-lolwil a ro-novation or expansion plan designed tow capture hi;hrr Ptorr- for-storr ltrowth. Tlw mo,t Agnificant announvemrnt@ mad,- luot year were tlw fivr-% par t3fml million nationwide P%punii-on and A )fvk.("h#m modprnization program loor Folk. i. . Fifth A% enter and thr .11 Ito million Sork. rifih Irvis- rorno,sation of thr Marithall Firld'i. lki, flag,hilo otorr ton Stats- Strtwt in Chiraw.. 1% rk *- romi'let"t elation is( lvrv*,,-CariPlina- &nil inlo mw or;uniza- tion. Although Ili#- -hort-irrin inspavt how, inivrrulsts-4 lvp%'- r rd if lwrq.fit growth. a 14 BAT NXISTRISS P.LC. MOINNOTA, DvvsffoRy CoPY - PmwcED PURNJMT To VILD. OF COMUNT JUDOMPIT DATED SMW IN SrATE OF A*NWSOTA, ET AL. V. PNXV MORK IT CASE NO. C14M-M5 HATUS Retail Group of Companies Ar-olorr cmnpun@ hi. niergrfl. 24 Bro-tairr. -.1-ned a n111111- Ls molli--n oh.1lar rewriliz,d %are- hms@,. % hirli %ill impr-@%r oprrat- 22 ing, effiriem-A and r@dure imen- 10 wri n-quirrowni- -a, oldr-I at .-j,h rt-tail vwnpjn@ and criteria ;V Uidt. %;srirt% n(vu- 97 tonler relation. prorratn@ were r- dek.-II'lortl i., nwniow 1.@rform- BATV4 lus@ made a Acnifi- cant rontmitsurnt w trehniolm:% ft--*-. of with a goal of arhie% in-- a 4-oni- IOR."$F4 1 M JWtitivr advantage in rai'll Jit, retail louAnr,-- -4ak, Fifth fifih A%"nur and Nlar,hAll Field'@ announced program# dr4ped to, enhance management information SakA Fifth Avenue hav grown toolls that will impnive nwrchan- to an extentive network of 44 di4ing drcivionA and productivity. sliecialtv storev in 30 major completrd the purrham of market# in 18 stairt. making it advanced lmint-of-,oale terminal:- more convenient to a larger base W af for it* Florida ottarrs. Rreunrr@ of aMaent. fashitan-minded cuf- at Strengthened itm, data pror"sing. lumem. and Thimble, innalled 4yotem4 Through Folio, catalogs. Sakp designed f1wrifirall for ilsecial1% hao increased it, reach and .4torr olwraticsn*. created a truly national clientele. informint it% rum.mers of mer- 1.8 handiw *r1retiono ovailahle at e 1.6 ak@ Atorr@ scroooo the ro)untr%. S Sakt. Fifth Avenue. the while building a moil order louti- nation's premier high-fsohion at-- that hao Frown in exc"o or 41wrialty retailer. offering suloe- Me a v ar since 1982. riur quathy apparel. aerroourie- To, further enhance W, mail Arrvirr. again had reroord leaderohip loooilit.n during 19117. *air- with an incrrar of -wnw Sak, announced a rtsr.%'#-Mr 43104 5t,-t. Ho%evrr.&-arq-uhofthr millioin nationiA ide r%lsanion and 4-nijoetilb. e retail en% minment. moolernizution program that Sak,* pro-fit- %err lwhn- boil yrar*s record level. 15 BAT INIXIMNS P.LC- UWASOTA DpasffM COPY PWNCED Pw=ANT To VILD. OF CoNuNT JummEwT DATEo 519M im SrATE oF Aemwsom ET AL v. PHxip Akwgm Er At- CASE No. C14M4=5 I BM 5 1987 Busines.@ Reriew - -- -- - 7 - ie- 4 all Im-ation, to, a-ure highl% 4itrresoful at mottil ating i 14@j the% rriore,ent the qualit% image Sak, empl.,%oor- and enhancing anti ihut the .";uk@ ru- rulumer ser% ice. tomer ha, lvarnril tit expect. The The mainAta% a.' !;aks' . . . . . . rip. M Calif,ornia. more soil merchandising nrate--% remain,; the @'-jsrinoqield. Neu JerAr%. unito the -litinc and fore-entaliun of %t-rr renmated in 1937. Similar internationally-rem-u-ned toork -a, startr4lon store, in drPigner rlnth,@ and acer,sories. G2rdrn City. New York. anti Bul In addition. --;ak4 ha@ inerra,ed. Harlu,r. Floirida. In 1988. the the penetration of im.prietam Chrv.% Chase. Maryland. Trny. brands in its merchandise si,,o ort- Michizan. anti Brrwen Camnly. mrnt@ in order to proi, ide custom- am Neu Jrr-r@. unn@ are undergtiing vr@ with e%elusi% h%. quality. style modernization. and value. Real Clothes. a hichl% Plans were slAn announced in surr"iful pri%air label brand of 198-. it- rrhocate anti expand the- ladir, acti%e sportswear and A Sooks A .AA A I on- downtown Chirac. Saki Fifth casual apparel. iA nou in itc third ms@ owfit* hwAti, A%enur unit. The new store will year and has been extended to spot,taks.4 --., th, 21mitiot double existing selling Real Clothn for Men. The F(fih 4-, 6.b qswe and is scheduled it) open in Works. a private brand collection jittikow, tit 1990. of ready-to-wear for executive Meanwhile. construction women. was introduced in 1987. continued on the tower expansion Passport is a collection of Euro- includ" rive new stom. expon- of thr.Nrw York Saks Fifth pean styled nwn** clothing and sison of the New York store and Avenue flaphip store. The first dress furnishings sold at more rrnu%ation of2l other units. nine fluors, of the new 36-floor moderate price levels than de- New 4tore, are hoeing added in tower will connect to the corre. signer merchandise. otsburban Washington. D.C.. at sloonding Rqx)rji of Saks' existing T%-nn@ Corner. Virginia. in Min- landmark louilding and will add nealmli,. Minneo6ota. Denver. Mile more PrIling oltare when Culuradi,. Portland. Oregon. and 4-I)mpleted. Nivroh Palm Beach. Florida. The Saks embarked on a redevel- Marshall Firld*t. the domi- Tyson, Corner mare will open in Opment of ito, business ityAtionts. a nant. full-linr qualiti, department [he fall of 1988 and will lor the two-year investment that %ill add store in Chicago. ha; achieved seriond SAA unit in the Waphinz- it, the remlesny*o productiviity and recard performance in salef each ton. D.C. arra. service capability starting in M9. year Fiore loeramin; a member of The 21 unito selected for Emphasi, ton achieving anti the BATUS Gresult in 1982. niquiernizatii.n are a rrult of a maintainino, a tulorrisor let el of Morin; 1987. Palt-A rqoe 91/-t. ultile ru,timser m-rvivr continued during olorratin.: profilA drerraiwil 6ri. the vrar and will be a krv part dir Firlil't o1wrat" 15 sine" in the Sak@* future lilan@ lose drveloilt. Chicago metropolitan area. six in ment. Thi, effort rontinuro its lir Wi@rtono,in and hour in Texa,. B.A.T INMIMIES P.LC. - MMWWA DEPOSffM COPY PRMCED PURSUAMr TO VIIA OF CONSF?frJUDOWNTOATr;05/8/98INSrATEOFAONNEsoTA,ETA,Lv.Pmxv-Uongs.ErA CmHo.C`114441015 6.1, Tt Remil Grnup c!f Canytinists V 41 .:-.- A.4d sequilsiti-m. B M*-@ ha- in% eol-41 Jar strium tt- be liver i I is' niiHi--n in .-allital P.%- 1,-att-sl in tht- --i-wer 4 the 11--re. pentliture-. in0whilt: ill-- .1.14li- Is %ill 1,,- nankml It% JV@. el@vsi- tiom lif -i% owu t..r- anti ri-twi a- t.w. anti -,-mtrjIiz.-.l -culat-w-. --f -v--r -4-t- unil-, li-si-irswww. i, v%p-iv4 1,@ 1@ Th, highis;;h: w' lslur-haf! 1 1.1% -ill lwrin: 11w mw% ati--n Iw if%-- @iaw -ir--: 11.1;.4111. ill.- Lak.- F-w-t. Illim-6. -t-irs- Anist-ton.-ml iji-- ii-i -or. thi- %ill an-I ili, Ifill,lair in Nid.h. I... th,- I.m.-I ronotmi,m irt ...fk. 'A i-- --n-m. %a- t1w w L .,@ r@ijiliu;.. Th.. Is; Ili;*.':. dw i. pr,-J--t--,i s.. I I it I A;--ria -i-w- mad ill,- v milli--n and -all Ili- -fat- wt-1 M if,-r T,-%,-r -i-we- in -itri-l-t unti t.. it. hwav. %ill I,-- uran.i.-ij, ni. IsLir-iisil i- al- m.skim. a nw-w --mliviinu-n: u- 1 1: Im. .-npI,jrk-I as a sr_w, pr.-_-rjm it. 411 ii- Lr\ B.A.T INKMMS P.LC. - MMESOTA DEPourm COPY - PRODI)CED PWtSUANT TO VILD. OF CONSENT jUDQMKr DATED SM" IN STATE OF AftgwSOTA, ET AL. V. PMLP UORRX. Er CASE No. C14M4=5 B. I T1 S 194.7 Rit,inesx 1serien- Mar-liall Firl.1% al ... . .. Sala. inslor..% r it- 1-r-,grain 4 rit-imurr s,-.- Mar-hall Field% ha@ 1-n a ilvpartuient,i.-rem in N,-rih leader in niarket -gin,nlsitimi. It CarMina. South Can-linu ind lost. e%eral -o,-rr--ful ri..riola. within it. i,,r,- to, rra-,Ii a or two. -ii% is, a pr@vi.e ijr::@l Th.-de- r"ult ofthev..n...liditins: velopnw-ut 41-ri%ute label, loss, vxjwrirnv@d a .1-lin, al... I.evit a Le% element if in -operating prolit@; sno-niati.-o -trate-.,. in jiblitwn. 1% e% ', no,% 6 in a @Ironcvr 1--i. 'ar4iall Fwld'- Ila. eniloha@ized tion it, take ad%antitz- -if ripidly -1irt-ial arrastronient. with -Irct growing marlirt,, in the 44suthraot. %endow. whirli differrnsiatr@ it-elf The ron,--iidution %a- a front itr #-4oniIootit.-r-. major undertaking bezuto in lite Mirohioll Firld'. Expre-rd'. 1986 and e.impIrtrd i3;thr third a mail -rdrr ratahm. %so@ mnvvv@- quarter of 19117. fui in 148'.. growing 211t1r. 1%-e% 'A mission it, to, I)rc.jme a Marshall Firld'e will expand true specialt% .department store into Ohio in 1989 with a new with merchandising sossortmenti@ 200.0011 square-foot store that will emphasixin; upper-moderate anehor thr newly planned Colum- thruough lietter apparel and bus City Center Mall. fashion arcessil,ories for own. wonwn and children. Significant prostre.-ing t4luiliment anil P. changes in lvev*o merchandi-e tsov@ -err ak.i intr-6-1. strAtegy were implemented during A mialti-inillimi -1-41jr ren- consolidation. nwrehand6e vatimi and e%loun.i..n 4 1%et'. as-ortmento, were narrowed. nm-l 1-r-liss-tive imi-, -.ia@ nu-_,.i,il. arhirving a more focused foohion Smithl'irk Mall -t--r- in Char- statement. sonil thr lortio-r4o ir coon. lotle. %a- W-gion in ?";:7 and will tinuing during the current year. IP- NoRkIll.-I-I in Am.1j.: Majoir investments matle Thi- asnit will I- 11w .4 during 1987. should Isegin in earn ille rhain all- I I.- A & return in 1988. The distribu- fosr fillisr-- jw* dwril,ort--dad- tion center in Charb-tte % 94 sownt. expanolrd hi U1.114H, -ijuarr-fret 11141p.l. in order too 4upim-ri the roon-li- ol dated rompan@ and is. lirmitir pr-n-vini in III!!_ in, - 'A in: for future gn.wth. Ault-onated Q15 "%4 B.A.T IMLMTMS P-LC. MMESMA DOWIDIFrif COPY PMWCED PURSUAW TO VILD. OF CoNsEwtiluoGwiscr DATED SAM IN SrATE oFAlimsiEsom ErAL v. PwrAkmar. ErA CmNo.C1444=5 A H I Tt Ro,iil winrc -rrvivr and surr,-handimn.: V infownisitimi thrau;h rxsrnPi%r ralittare ioF tran@urih,n daia. ....... I%e% *, alpto rimitilett-cl a snaj.ir rll@loioinrr relaticir. lim- grant its 19K. r4inthining wro, i, r. ash-ri-ii-ing unit nianup-Ine"I It Awu.r@ fill iliiulit@. @rrvir,-. training. and ha, a fursual ferillissek oyotrin that nvra,ure@ -tosittlards. giving Ivr%'t nit im1wriant -Irategy to, 41iolin- gu6h it,rlf trims rtimlsortitiiin. 1%r% *- viontirsu" to) luq)k f4or %olilmriussitieA too r%joand in With tmi,itiug unit new murket#. -N, Breuners Breunerso. the W"t C.iot'j, largeot home furniture retailer %ith 57 units - 17 retail and 40 the Fallery rionvelit di#ruptrd the rental - throughout California. lsimin"- lout the Fallerief give Arizoinot and Nevada. underwent Bretint-r- new -plmrtunitir- fur oulittantiall rhangr during 1987. *step gn)wtli lov further fioru,,ing I The Aotsijeii were designed to the lou,inrm- a n qualit, heimi, fur- so- fk. improve isalro, and profits. The ni'lling'. Is-'. N.:%P4,L hisAn"s, e%perienced some dip- The gullerie- I.rt,% idir it tirar- .. (.*h.,i"::. ..4 ruption, and combined sale.- fro-sn th e A..% ruAtir. a I- level of in- retail and rental were dnwn (rcsm %"tawni. ivsunisfarsiir@r-' quirk- a @ ear ago. The total huxin- obil. pi,mrant- an-1 nutit-nut1% we. unI% .marginalli- proofitaldr in ktu-wn ad1%,-orti-ifou. Thr looolitilar I. ..i F.-,dao. 1987. Thisma-vitir gulirriep ha%#- lwrn TaIdelop and dormorotir mrr- in-tallml in 15 ro-tail -t-rr, and ovr-o--n to. is.-% harolkan- an-? chandi" eliminated during 1986 %ill he in nil 17 -i--rp, I, mid- pur.-ha.-A j-int-f-sl- wraiiiial- t all retail storw has loren re- a %ear P11W.- th-sir--d-al th.- li, Fl.-ri,la iinji- emispil- mared with furniture manufar- ar,. I.-ing all.64 it tu., if 16 1W.. %.1111 u.-A in th'. 14 iurr"* gallerief.. rrintiorring larcer isnil-- i.ar..hnu -im-- Tlw 1,-rininal. HrruneW lorimary orrnph a- a AWu u. olualit%. uprair furniture- rr- iii.- -t--it% that sailer. 11w changeover fripm talolo-14)p and Jum"tiv Ft"od. Us -4 ANT TO VII.D. OF B.A.T JNDuSTRIES P.LC. MINNEWA DEPOWORY Copy PROG=D PWtSU CASE NO, C11-94-MIS Col,=Nr JUDGMENr DATrco S/SM IN STATE OF A"NEIRTAI IT AL V, PH&P MORRAL ET AL_ BAR S 1987 Business Re"iPIC 44 P-.. P.A. No. j... y. Th-hi., ..", Breunert* up% central distri- ThImbLes To nisnaze thif traneition. bution center. containing a The financial performance of new merchandising Wderthip miHion 6quare-foot computerized Thimbles. the BATUS entrv in was installed and the implemen- rack storage system. was coal- the women** apparel spircia*itv tation of the more upscale pleted in September. This center store seltment. was below expect&- concept began in 1937. Thimbles consoLidatef 11 reFiatial ware- tiont in 1987. and the company developed & store prototype with hou*" and wiU allo- Oreunerp to operated at a loss. a new interior design and layout. improve customer service vis a Sales incres"d due to the and two stores were adapted to company-wide. centralized addition of 11 new starts. but the design during the fourth inventorv control and distribu- customer acceptance of the mer- quarter. During IM. Thimbles tion system. chandising concept in the I,'.-unit W-01 direct its energ:irs to refining The 4ts-unit rental business chain wait disappointing. The its new concept and improving adopted a more agMisive mar- company is in a transitional existing slope sales. keting effort during 1987. The period as management is refocus- .al" f4rep ws.4 restructured an4l in, the Thimbles concept. The @hr lmk and qualit% of the priml- new theme involv" a higher uct wap up;raded. fashion profile. with merchandise designed for the more fashion- orientril carper woman with higher quality wardrolw needs. B.A.T INMTRIM P.LC. MWESOTA ClEposffORY COPY - PROIXIMD PURWMT To VIIA OF CoNsENT Juow*NT DATEo 5/$W iN STArE oF Aftwsom ET AL v. Pimup MoRm ET CAsE No. CI-944M5 BATUS Inc. 1987 Financial Revietc Alanagement's Responsibilitv for Financial Reportingg A-."W AMW The following consolidated financial statements of BATUS Inc. were CQwd Fi .. rWS@,: prepared by management which is responsible for their integrity and slas__g.#fIWOW objectivity. The financial statements have been prepared in conformity W Itnei"d with generally accepted accounting principles and necessarily include MdA@ SAW$ amounts which represent the best estimates and judgment* of manage- SISSO.OMS of Cho" ment. i. fl@iw 0-06W" 26 Manatement is further responale for maintaining a system of Me-410"MIS Oanwsies& ArAiYM; internal accounting controls. designed to provide reasonable assurance SeSSOM.Mu ff 1"MW :3 that assets are safeguarded. established policies and procedures are Futamist ConAWes :S followed and transactions are properly executed and reported. The S--- q/A--AV P4e- -tem is continuallv reviewed for its effectiveness and is augmented by V.M to CAVOW&W wntten policies and guidelines. the careful selection and training of FISOM" sesIMMUO qualified personnel. and a strong program of internal audit. re Deloitte Haskins & Sells. eertified public accountants. a engaged AqW14 34 to exantine the consolidated financial statements of BATUS Inc. and issue a report thereon. Their examination is conducted in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards and includes an objective review and evaluation of internal accounting controls to the extent deemed necessary by them. The Board of Directors. through the Audit Comnsitt" of the Board, is responsible for- (1) assurinj that management fulfills its responsibili- ties in the preparation of the financial statments; and (2) engaging; the certified public accountants with whom the Coaunittee reviews the mope of the audit& and the accounting principles to be applied in finaneW reParting. The Audit Continittee meas replarly (separately and jointly) with the certified! public accountants. representatives of usanageasent. and their internal auditon to review the activities of each . A to emure that each is properly discharging its responsibilities. To ftdure complete independence. Deloitte Haskins & Sdh has full and five access to meet with the Audit Contmittee, without management representatives present. to diwuss the results of their examination and their opinions on the adequacy of internal accounting controls and the quality of financial reporting. /147 4e-.j 4,1 - IZ Henry F. Fripa Leonard W. Arentsen President & Executive Vice President Chief Executive Officer 21 C__ B.A.T Musmas P.1-C. - MMSEMA DUKOTORY COPY - PRMCEO PUMUANT To VILD. oF CoNsEw Juoomw DATEo 5AM iN SrArE OF UNNESOTA, Er AL V. PMLP MOROW Er CASE NO. CI-944US BA TUS Inc. Consolidated Statements of Income and Retained Earnings go" 0-4- 31. it. rA..*" qff).U.., i"T 1986 Net SAO# ............................................. SS.834.501 S 5.499AS2 SS.086.902 Comb and expraocs: Cost of.ale .......................................... 3.17.1.475 2.901-394 2.69-4.671 Federal exci@ tz%es ................................... 494.668 S36.750 561.44S Selling. general and administrative e%penoes ................. 1.263.701 1.11-.80S Interest expv*@. net at interest income: 1987- SMSP: 19M - $14.5M. 1983 - $8.900 .............. 88.194 132.468 147.666 Total costs and expenses ........................... 5.018.038 4.7%.8113 4.519.58M, iome from continuinp operadons before provision for income tax" ....................... 816.463 -.02-569 S67.31S provision for income taxes ............................... 350.260 339.906 2M.400 Income from continuim operations ......................... 4".203 363.663 328.915 Income (lo") from discontinued operations. not of income taxes .................................. - - f. 15.393 1 Provision (credit) for retail restructuring, net of bwomw taxes .................................. - (30.0001 150.000 Not' .. . ........................................... 4".203 393.663 1L63M2 Retained, earalop. beplaning e(year ....................... 1,525.829 IJ2.J66 1.313AS4 Dividends declared ..................................... (220.000) (19S.Ml f160.800i Retained earnings. end of year ............................ 9 1.77.2.032 8 1.52SM9 $ 1.32' .166 See accompanying sumnar@ ofaccountbW policies and notes to consaWatadjimancial statemonu. 1LA.T INDUMIES P.LQ - Mamou DeKwm Copy - PWWCED PUMWMT To VILD. oF CoNuNT JuDowNT DATEo MW iN SrATE oF AftwEsou, Er AL V. PMLV UORRIS, ET AL. CAsE No. C14M4=5 BA TVS Inc. Management 's Discussion and Analysis Statemenfs of I.Co'. The Compso@ maintained its record of increased comparable year ba*6. excluding the extra telling week in profitability as strategies at its continuing operations were 1986. net sales increased 10%. Net sales for t98. of IT 79 refined to asset changing market conditions. The million benefited from the impact of price increases and Company's continuous refinement of busissest strategy led higher volume within the carbonless product lines. Car. ta the decision. announced in 1986. to restructure its retail bonless sales increaped '..'% in 198' . an a volume increase operations. As a result of that decision. the statements of of 3%. This follows a carbonless sales increase of 16% in Income segregate discontinued operations from those that 1986. The increase in carLounless sales for 1987. was limited are part of the ongoing business activities of the Company. somewhat by market pressures which forced prier dis- Net "Its from continuing operations increased 6rr in counting. Appleton** operating income declined 6% in 1987. following increase# of $47c in 1986 and 4% in 1985. 198' . following increases of 20% in 1966 and 6% in 1985. Excluding the impact of the extra week of pale# in 1986. for Operating results for 1987. were negatively impacted by the Company's retail and paper segments which had a 53 price discounting. changes in product mix. higher pulp week year in 1986. art salco from continuing operations prices and costs associated with improving customer ineresped 7rx in 198',. Operating income increased 317,r in service. '4W million in 1987 compared to increases of 20% in 1986 The Company*s retail operations achieved modest sales __sd 4% in 1985. Operating gains at the Company's growth in 1987 in the face of uncertain market conditions. tobacco segment during 198' %erv partially offset by lower Not salts Frew to $2.6 billion. an increase of 4% for 19117. performances at the Company*s retail and paper Mqmtnts. following increases of 14% in 1986 and 7% in IM. On a which operated in difficult markets for most of the year. comparable year basis. excluding the extra selling week in Net income from continuing operations rose 28% to 1986. met sales increased 617c. Saks at Saks Fdth Avenue $466 millicas in 1987. following increases of 11% in 19M increased 5% in 1987. while Wes at Marshall Firld's and 10% in IM. The improvement in 1987s income from incressed 9%. Sales at lvey*s and Brenner* declined as a continuing operations resulted from higher operating result of restructuring. Operating income of like retail income. lower not interest expense and a lower effective tax segatent declined 13% in 1987. as competitive pressures re- rate due to slat provision of the 1966 Tax Reform Act. Set strained mar& rates. income was SW million in 1987. $394 million in 1966 and The Company's cost of asks percentage was 54.41M in III&I million in IM. Not income for IM included a 1907, compared with 52.8% in 1956 and 52.9% in 1985. charge o($156 million for the retail restructudq. Net The increase in the cast of ud" percentage is due primarily income for 19116 inchicled a credit of'1130 million due to the to higher pulp prim at Appleton and increased mareban- favorable mahs of the retail mtracturing. dim cuts In mug operations. due in port to higher Import Not sales of the Company's tobacco segment. Brown & prim. The Company's LIFO provision was Sm mill"M in Williamson (111M. increased 8% to 02.3 billion in IW. 1907 compared to LIFO credits of $20 million in 19116 and compared to an increase of 1% in 1996 and nominal $3 million in 19111S. The 155 xaMoss increase Ja the UFO pvwth in IM. The grow-th In 198". sales if attributable to provision (IN7 vs. 1986) resulted primarily from higher in- dr . tcantly Moor international sales. which increased fiction. particularly in the retail segment where the "a of T22M in 1987. primarily as a result of the elimination of imported pods was she affected by currency fluctuations. the Import duty In Japan. B&W achieved a 23% share of Selling. general and administrative (SG&A) expenses the Japanese import market. which now commands 8.4* were 21.7% of min in 1"'. compared to 22.2% in 1966 of the total Japanese market. B&W*s domestic volume and 2!% in IM. The drop in the *Wnw rate is due pri- declined in 19117. resulting in a domestic market share of marily to the absence of charges related to the early exdn- IM compared toll.'* in 1986. R&-W*s operating guishment of slebt which inflated SG&A expenses in 1986. income increased 14% to $613 millilon in 198' following Iss- Not interest espesme dectined $44 million in 19117 as lower cream of 21* in 1966 and 4% in 1985. ffigher selling debt levels and sWicantly higher cash flow combined to prim mid Increased internations! volume were the main reduce overall financing costs. contributors to the improvement in 1987*t results. The Company's effective tax role was 42.9% in 1987 The Compauy*p paper segment. Appleton Papers (Ap- compared to 49.2% in 1986 and 42% in 1985. The drop in pletan). experienced 0 salep increase of 8ve in 1987. com- the effective tax rate is primarily attributable to the rate pared to isscream of 13% in 1986 and IM r in 1985. On a reduction enacted as part of the 1936 Tax Reform Act. B.A.T INUMMIES P.LQ - MMEMA DEPOSITM COPY - PMMCED PURWANT TO I VILD- OF COMENT JUMVENT DATED SAM M SrATE OF AMM8016, ET AL K PHLIP MORMAT CAsE No. Cl-94-MS 1 8.4 TL'S Inc. Consolidated Balance Sheets Pecomb- 31. 1 M 7h*.on& o,'Dodisno 1987 1996 Assets Current sooew Cash ........................................................ 8 15.985 Shan-term investments .......................................... 1.188,538 43S.071 Accounts receivable. less allowance: 1987 - 8.09.' .89. 1986 - S37.001 ................................... 323,975 M" .096 Inventories ................................................... 787.571 J94XW Other ....................................................... 111.811 71.413 Current asset& ............................................. 2.419.021 2.138.415 Propenty. plant and equipment. at costs Land and improvements ......................................... 53.664 53.72S Buddinp and improvements ...................................... 701,126 684.404 Store fixtures. machiner-! and equipment ............................. 1.3".021 1.246.016 Construction in propvso ......................................... 124.27.3 58.479 Ieased property under capital team ................................ 42.409 42.362 2.281.492 2.084."6 Less accumulated depreciation and amortization ........................ T71.841 654.911. 1,309.631 1.430.069 Insamplbik unto ................................................. 239.0" 234.9.2 Other SNOW .................................................... 470.498 43B.C.2 $4.638,176 14.24.0.128 Uabilitles a" Sharebalsfer's EqWty Currom 11,111111111214103 Sbormerm borrosefalls ........................................... 3 - 3 5.000 Lamg,term debt duewithist one year ................................. 6,577 liju Accounts payable ............................................... S47,701 3221.1195 Accrued liabilities .............................................. 41".6" SSS.40'. Due to offiliated companies ....................................... "1035 14-W Income taxes payable ............................................ 269.2% 11.5.9S2 Current liabilities .......................................... 1,136,"-. 1.154.068 -la"no debt: Affiliated company. subordinated ................................... 7", 1 -4 4 Other ....................................................... 126.3$5 133.117 910.3" 910.224 Other 10084ents litibilld" .......................................... 745.4-15 548,134 SharebadWe equity: Comments shares. $1 par value; 1.000 shares authorized. kwacl and outstanding ...................... I I Paid-in c*W ................................................ 73,252 3 -U2" Retain" earninp .............................................. 1. -17 2.032 I-9-95M9 1.6".286 1.5".08: I 4,63L 1 '76 8 42422. 128 Sea accompanying summary ofaceoustsing policies end som to costsolidatedfmancial wasentents. 24 BAT INDusmas P.LC, - MmEwrA Dotoslrony Copy - Pnmao PuRsuur To I VILD. oF CoNsENT JuDamm DATED 54M iN SrATE oF MNNEsou, Er AL V. PNXP UDRRM, ET A CASE NO. CI-94-MS BATUS Inc. Monagemeng *s Discussion and Analysis Financial Condition The Compw *s financial condition at year-end 1987 funding of certain employer benefits. Current liabilities reflects the successful implementation of strategies to decreased $17 million due to a decline in accrued fiabili. impro%r liquidity and financial flexibility by optinasing ties and the current portion of long-term debt. offset the intestment in and return on net operating assets. partially by an increase in taxes psychic. The Company's return on net assets (operstin; income Th; Compan@ * I investment in fixed assets increased as a percentaire of act operating assets) was 43% in 1987 6% to $1.5 billion. Fixed asset additions were V248 compared to 33q in 1986 and 219% in 1985. The signihs. million in 1987. compared to $231 million in 1986 and JIM cant increase in return on net assets is due primariJ! to s"on in 1985. Capital spending for the retail segment improved preferment* at B&W and a decrease in net totaled 1103 million in 1987. and was primarily used to operating "#cu primarily resulting from the sole of fund the custoruction of new stures and the renovation of certain accounts receivable. Accounts receivable have existing atom. Capital spending at the paper and tobacco been sold to certain financial institutions under agree. segments totaled 890 million and $55 million. respectively. -cuts whereby the Company may sell. with limited and focused primarily an increasing operating efficiencies - -ourte. certain designated accounts receivable on an and capacity. ongoing basis. At December 31. 1987. and 1986. accounts Total capitalization (equitv Flu$ debt) increased to receivable *old pursuant to these agreements totaled $714 82.8 billion at year-end 198' , compared to $2.6 billion at million and$ 160 million. respectively. Not operating year-*ad 1986. Equity increased $246 volition reflecting assets were $2.1 billion in 1987. compared to $2.6 billion in net Income of M" million less divisloods paid of SM 1986 and $2.5 billion in 19115. million. Dividends paid in 1986 and 19U were 8195 Working capital increased 30% to $1.3 billion as the million and 1160 million. respectively. ToW debt as a ratio of current assets to cu. a t liabilities Improved to 2.1 percentage of capitalization was 33% at yea"aid 1961 to I at year-end I"T. compared to 1.9 to I at year-end compared to 38% at vear-said 1986 and 4' . % at year-ond 1986. The improvet in working capital and the IM. Total debt outstanding at year4ond 1987 was $91" , current ratio is due paiissarilly to an Increase in the million compared to 11997. millien at year-end 1986. Total Company's short-4cron investments which graw to 11.2 debt includes 11134 million of subordinated debt payable to hiWou at year-end 1987. compared to 111W million at year. B.A.T Issfustries. Excluding subordinated debt. %be dobat- and 1986. The Company's strong cash flow was aug. to-capitalization percentage was 5% at year-end 1W. mented by the sale of accounts receivable which generated compared to 9% at year-and 1966. an additional $554 saillian of cash in 198'. compared to To supplement its financial position and cash flow $160 atiMov, in 1986. from "Mrsuo". the Company hats bank liness of ersolit The Company*# Investment in inventories mood at and agreements with B.A.T Industries and affillates - A million at year-end 1967, compared to $795 million at whereby additional borrowings way be secured iffe year-cad 1986. The slot decline in inventories primarily footnote to financial statements). The Company also has reflects efforts to minimize inventories. particulairk at the agreements with financial Institutions slust &Uo% the Company's retail operations. and the impact or higher Company to oil. with Waited recourse. accounts ecolo- inflation which increased the UFO reserve. Other current able Isest footnote to financial staternents). assets increased SW mOon primarily due to the pre. 25 -4 rQ B.A.T INDumiss P.Lc. - MwavwA DEpoeffoRy COPY - PR=cED PuMANT To VILD. OF COMENTJUDGWNT DATED 51$1981N SrATE0FA*NMSOrA, ETAL V. PHXPAkRRI& ETA CASE No. CI-94-6565 BATUS Inc. Consolidated Statements of Changes in Financial Position 1"n Th--g..f Dona- 198- 1996 1995 Cash provided by operations.- Income from condnaing operations ....................... 8 466.203 S 363."3 S 328.915 Itemp not offftning working capisal2 Depreciation and amortization ........................ I T .5.622 161.919 14S.579 Deferred income taxes .............................. 95.422 125.633 123.381 Other .......................................... 1-..441 12.613 19.446 Working: capital provided by continuing operations ....... 754.698 663.8218 61-..321- Income (19991 from discontinued operations including provision for retail restructuri4 ............... - 30.000 1 16S.393) Items not affectingworking capitol: Depreciation and smortizotion ........................ - - 31.492 Deferred income taxes .............................. - (926) Other .......................................... - - r 50.067) Retail restructuring reserve. net of income taxes ........... - 430.0001 IU.1100 - - 3.916 Changes in components of operating working capital: Accounts receivable ................................ 497.121 37.6911 1,27.6U) Inventories on first-in. first-out basis ................... (27.866) (51-2481 (ILS38) Lost-in. first-out inventory reserve ..................... 35.145 (20,168) (2.964) Other current "sets ............................... (40.398) (35.812) (Imu) Accounts payable. accrued liabilities and due to affiliated companies ......................... (30.618) PS-11") 87.662 Income tam pay able ............................... 93.342 U.S-40 39.9W S06.726 (69,' MO) (202.748) CALsh provided by operations ....................... 1.261.414 594,078 3".4" Cub =" for bw I Additions to propomr. plant and equipmeni ................ (248.420) (230AS) (421114.21S) Acquisitiom of leveraged lesses. net ...................... (34.905) Investment in lamace Limited ........................... (3.816) (132.149) Other ............................................ 57.205 (14.155) (193.031) (37.139) (37.4.11M), --%;mob provided by a" of businesses ....................... 6".049 Cook provided by suJim or invootmenas ...................... - Cash mead for dirldlesuls ................................ (220.000) 4195A00) 4160.000) Cook provided (and) by fistanclaig eadvitleas Addidow to long-term debt ............................ 2.319 SJI2 34.7.84 Payment ciflow-astrus debt ............................. (83.8$6) (21#81 "s) (39.60) payment of obligations under tratilemork and trade name acquisitioss apTements ..................... (113=111) (14=3) (18.0?9) loscrease (decrease) in short-term borrowissigiv ............... (S.000) (".7W) (297.8%) 1 W A") Increase, (docrease) in cash and shormerns invesursemas ........ 8 744.608 S 3711.07.2 8 31.619 See occa""ing summary of accounting polliciet; and mom to comeaUdacedfln--Ci-l statements. fSj Z 26 B.A.T IHMSMES P.I-C. - MINNEWTA DuawORY COPY - PRMcEo PuRmAmr To VILD. oF CoNsEw JuoGmEw DATED WN IN SrATE OF A*MVEWTA, Er AL. V. PNXV NORM ET A CASE NO. C1 94 6 5 8.4 TUS Inc. Summary ofAccounting Policies Basis OflOmsentation IntanobleAssets BATUS tote.. through atiether company. is a wholly- Intangible assets are being amortited art a straight-line owned subsidiary ofB.A.T Industries p.l.c. iR.A.T basis as follows: trademarks end trade names. aver 2S Industriest. a company incorporated in England. The years: patents. over their remaining useful lives %vith a accompanying consolidated financial statements include maximum lift of 13 vears: excess of cost ever fair value of the accounts of BATUS Inc. and all significant subsidiar- not assets of acquired businesses. a% er periods ranging ies. the total of which is defined as the -Company- for from IT to 40 years. purposes of these statements, B.A.T Industries holds a 40% interest in Imatco Income Taxes Limited. including the Contpany*& interest. As a result. Investment tax credits reduce the provision for income the Company's investment in Imesco is accounted for taxes in the year the related ans"s are placed into service. using the equk method. Paserr"mens R#naftta on-term Istrosomenst Effective January 1. 1986. the Company adopted Short-orminvitstmeats consist primarily ofcommer. Financial Accounting Standards Board Statement No. 87. cisl paper. back term deposits. money market preferred -Employers' Accounting for Pensions- (FAS 87). The stocks and tax exempt bonds. The invaunents are stated provisions were adopted prospectively. and accordinoy. at cost which approximates market. income for 1985 has not been restated. Substantially all employees are covered by pension Accounts Xecokable plans. The Company funds the plans based an the Retail deferred payment accounts due after one year requirements of the Employee Retirement Income Soon- are classified as current assets in accordance with trade rity Act (ERISA) plus additional amounts which may be practice. Sales and related can of saki for customer approved by the Company as data" appropriate. purchases made an deferred payment amounts are The Cosopany provides health and lift insurance recorded in fall at the doe of the sale. benefits (;er certain retired employees. During 1986, the Finance charges on customer accounts arr recorded as Company began to seem* the actuatially, determined income when tamed and reported as, a reduction of liability for redrea' health and life insurance costs. seRiW guarral and administrative expenses. Current annual payments toward redraft* health and life insurance costs will continue to be expensed when paid IMMM,Wks until the actuarial liability has bects fully seemed. Inventories are stated at the lower of cost or market .b con. for substantially all inventories. determined by Follerld Eirciff 74=8 'Me last4u. first-out (UFO) method. [As( tobacco Excise taxes billed to customers on tobacco products inventories which are not used within me year. due to the are included in not mks and deducted separately as part duration of the aging presses, am classified as current of total costs and expenses. assets in accordance with trade practice. Buying and Occupancy Costs Depreciation and Amordsotion Boying and occupancy costs incurred by retall . . plant and equipment is poorally The cam of property operations are classified as cam of val", depreciated on a straight-line basis over the estimated useful lim of the aftets. Property rights under capital Sao" P'"Possisw Costs keen and improvements to lefted property arc amortized Expenses associated with the opening of new meres, am On a susion-liae basis ever the term of the lease or useful deferred and charged to income in the year of the store lift of the amt. whichever Is shoner. opening. C: 27 %_j -4 X, BAT IMXMTM P-LC. - MM40MA 00,=ffORY COPY - PROMMD PURSUAW TO I VILO. OF comsEmT JuDowNr DATEi) &ON IN STATE OF MMmsOTA, IT AL V- PFKV MORIL IT AL CAsfi "0' Cl-944M I BA TUS Inc. Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements Rvind RestraesurueIr (Discontinued Operations) Transactions wids ABiliesed Companies In January 1996. the Compsn@ announced a plan to In I"t) the Company entered into agreements with an restructure its retail operations and provided affiliate to acquire certain trademarks and trade names E273.000.M (S 150.000.000 after income taxes i in its related to cigarettes sold outside the United Rates. 1985 financial statements to cover the estimated costs of Ile agreements provide for psymenti through 1988. implementing the plan. The restructuring included the which ore contingent upon the sales volume of cigarettes sale of certain of the Company** retail units. bearin; the trademarks and trade names. It is estimated The restructuring was completed in 1986 and at a that the final contingent payment. which is included in result of favorable settlements. the prot ision for rettruc. -Current liabilities.- will be 834.766.000. turial us* reduced by 130.000.000 1 after income taxtm I in B.A.T. International Finance p.l.c. (HATIFi. a finance 1986. The results of operations, of the businesses that subsidimr% of B.A.T Industries. is the principal source of .ere sold. which have beta classified as discontinued short-ttrm financing for the Company. As discussed in operations in the accompanying consolidated financial the long-term debt note. the Company also hat long-term statements. are as follows: borro-ingo due to BATIF. 4. thmo..&, M During 1986. the Company entered into a definitive . .................... agreement with an affiliate whereliv the affiliate assumed. in exchange for payment. certain of the Company's locout rietot We" actoir ta@ .................. I 31.65M obligation# under a letter of credit agreement which arose ... ...................... , W-1691 in connection with the purchase of a paper mill in 1984. Net owsawdim ............................... . @ -15-us, Although a subsidiary of the Company remains obligated under the debt agreement which wasturn in MO. by virtue of this assumption. the Company is contingently The Company also #old its 50% equity interest in the liable for the ultimate liquidation of the debt: manage I- Water Tower Place real estate joint venture in 1983 as went believes that the risk of default is remote and so ad. part of the restructuring. Water Tower Place is an urban ditional Liabilities will secrue. center in Chicago. Minois consisting of rated facilities. The Company Incurred interest axpew of offices and coodontiniumt. The sale resulted in an after- $102.66 7-000. 8104.AM.OOD and 3107.7. 80.000 in IM. rais pin of 832.00D.000. which was included in the 1986 and 199S. respectively. an shon-seran end long-term MtSuct ringprovision. borrowings from affilisited .companies. Investment in Inessece, Limited Sol* OfAcces"M Aactio"It The Company has an equity interest in losses Lian. The Company has agreements with finsocial imdtu- ised. a Canadian company with operations in the tobacco. tiom whereby the Company has the right to sell. with restounat. retailing and fissasselial services industries. limited recount. certain designated accounts receivable Due* 1987, and 1966. the Company bought additional an an ongoing basis. At Dam 1 31. 198' and 1966. sham of Inseam which isicreased its equity interest by accounts receivable, as reflected in the accompanying 13.816.ODDuWS13-".149.000.reopmiwely. The consolidated balesice sheitts. were net of$' . ISAM.006 Company's investment in Imascii at December 31. 1987. and $160.000.000. respectively. reprimmit* interest in was $285.103.000: the Company now holds a 10.3rre receivables sold to the financial institutions. Under the interest in Imasco. The isivestment in Imseco is included term of the agreement. the Company Is contingently in 'Other assets." hable. subject to certain limitations, for the ultimate The sham are not registered under Canadian enuti- collection of these receivables. 'This ap at eat maybe 6" laws. as a result. the Company is restricted as to the terminated by either party upon appropriate notice. way is which it may sell the *hat". NJ B.A.T INDUSTRIn P.LC_ - FARMESOTA DEPOSITORY COPY - PRl)DUMO PURSUANT To I VILO. OF CoNsEw JuDomEwr DATED SAM IN STATE oF Aftmasom ET AL. v. Pmxp MoRow Er CASE NO. C11-9441565 BA TUS Inc. Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements Inventories Intat*ble Assets Inventories at December 31 consist of the follouing: Intangible asseu at December 31 consist of the fol- 46.6' 19117 IV" lowing: Rrtlil UMM%dw .................. 6 312.439 8 492.1" 6. ih.@ftsk' 199, Ila stsods"."d Ps WM .. Trarlevark..W 2*4.402 1356,064 WOW"$ @ew to% . ...... ....... 347.213 109.815 Psiquip ........... ................ 113.363 H2.5-3 I.artebseft ............... ....... 32.- ...33 5".039 0." -t- d Manalstowtax wat,nai. f 6- 42.364 37.7" and "Ptsair ............. .. JW97 119.341 430.13" 4%.403 T*W e FIFO -t ...... ....... 1.333.900 1XS.9U Lo- wtuvdatd -nintmA ........... 191.063 M.431 E@ f FIFO mi -r - 8239.006 1:54.972 M.958 Short-term Borrosciap Short-term borrowinp consist of borrowinp from - The efleft on income of utinF the LIFO method is banks and an affiliated company (see transactiom with sominarized as follows: affiliated companies note). A summary of certain data (i. 199-1 046 Ins related to short-term litirrowinp f*Uows-. iWMW late"WI: riftsh4w"s6s 1111117 19611 Referefipidssine(mrian A,nato d6fily bstrowmps ................ 8 :.641 1 &W Efls@4 of bqWdatiis d wnw;o Maxisewe is-r-top "I.M06"m LEFOix"ats""nWis IS.76,11 UJIM in my wAmth -d Auring %6 "or .......... S t6.9% I It."t Wviottssl overop iswevo we goal as isesw Ifts ds dapy bonvings 0"ussedin; sooda"We 0 " slodsw use ?. ..................... 7 ra 7.11% I ; astowsaw ........ (U.443) 30.161 .In Was so * fross rJamsed LL", of crea &MOM"ved op"Wis" At December 31. 19r.. the Company bas 11139.000-000 tow ........ - of unused lisms of credit for Shen-low financial with 36.161 1 banks. Fee sted eampausatinS balance requirements at* not &*nificaut and balances are not restricted as to withdrawal. In addition. the Company IM an informal agreement with B.A.T Industries under which It way borrow up to 8350.000.000 from RATIF: all of Ws amount is unund and avagAlst at Devember 31. 198'.. The Company also, has a U0.800.000 revolviar credit Wessment with an affiliate for long-term financial. ';%a borrowinp won outstanding under this agreement at December 31, 198'.. N I - 4t> 29 LA.'T IHMMMIES RLCL MllMMESOTA Domffm Copy pWWCED PuFmAxT To VILD. OF CONSENT JUDGMENT DATED SAW IN STATE OF AbMSOTA, IT AL V. PMtP_AkRPM CASE NO. CI-94-MS I BATUS Inc. Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements "V40sm Debt The approximate amounts of payments on long-term Long-term debt at December 3 1. exclusive of amounts debt. excludin; obligations under capital leases and due within one year. consists or the following: affiliated debt. for the next rove years are at follows: (i.thows&P 19117 ins fin rhoweastal Afr&.wd vmipsay@ low ........................... .......... 1 4-M Solm,dussord mor. 16%. doe IW2 isi ... 8 31SJ40 8318.240 IM9 ...................................... $5.135. So6wAi-ted sow. 13%. do, 1"' it.. . . 200.000 W0.0110 1990 ...................................... S 4AN Sabo-dis.W4 soo. dw IW. I&, 1h4 .... 1-20.000 t2QAOO I"I s L-411 SWWWd"saw mse. 9 114%. IW ................ ....... ............. 13.03. dw IV" 401 ............ P...... 25A00 25.000 SolsortiisaW sets. d- IW- ir ........ 120AU 113JV Approximately S$84.1'.4.000 of the subordinated .414.17.4 77 7.10". affiliated company debt is scheduled to mature in 1992. Otter. MsMsV terso lox. Ao, IWS - d ....... 30-000 38.01W Income Taxes Xwtpv mw joysbu. Income taxes payable. included in current liabilities at .Owd M."W sparest. 12.1% December 31. consist of the following: 4eas L by * ith a 6. dwspoods, 110117 1106 am 6A volov of "3414,000 at Dreimber $1. M I ........... 32.93S S5469 Cormt ........................... It 2b-1.131 S 1612JID O"Poom MAW Capitol Correst de(rrrvd .................... *.163- 1-3.63: kom wrwlbw 2 2&9-"4 $ 175.95.1 interest. IG.S46 .... ........ -- 28437 slim 06". Primipay mdustrial rrvmw beawks. W The components of the provision for income taxes on &.4"r IMWML M* ............ 34j" SGAIG continuing operations are as follows: L26JU ULUT I (to shomande) 1967 1016 INS 0 1110j" J1 910JU Carom .................. $300.818 1163."t 1113409 Ddersed .................. 49.442 I.-3NI 143.911 113SOJO 4 338."S S ZIL400 (a) These now are subordinate in payment to all external ask up to a madmum of $1 billion. (b) Is' Is okerpd at Uld% over aftUigtt*s The table below monciles the provision for income interest raw 11.119b at December 31. 198'. - taxes computed at the U.S. statutory income tax rate to (a) Internet is charged at variable rat"; 7.8% at the Company's provision for ineom; taxes: December 31. W. Tblo note is subordinate in payment -0 all existing and future external debt haw* a WAted fin &snoods 1 1*17 11416 IM maturity is extent of 000 Year. provioloo at Out"Ory Us rote: (d) Interest is charged at the London Interbank lor. .40% offered rate plus 0.65% as determined annually at the ION not IOU - 46% ...... 8326JU 1 MM 126MU begimainj of each interest period; 8.8* at December 31, laves"W" "A edw as I.M. Tbe ken is collateralized by assets with a net book (esedits) ""nue ........ 996 14JW t15.7961 value of $31.703.000. so* md Isol I fisms (M offederld to booliel ... 32.142 :32" &W 04M.Im ................. 194") (5.0411 118.1.40) 0 33*J" 13111.111106 12111, zRoad" WA raw ............ 4L9% 48.2% 4140% 30 N: B.A.T INDWMIES P.LC. MMMWA DEPOSffM COPY - PRMCED PURUJANT TO I VILO- OF CoNsEw juDemEwr oATED sma iN SrATE oF UNNEsom, Er AL v. PmLP AfmRAL ET CASE NO. Cl-94-GM BA TUS Inc. Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements Components of the provision for cipferred income taxes Future minimum lease payments at December 3L. 199' . are as Wows: under leases that have initial or remaining noncancel.lable terms in excess of one year are as follows: 6. dwoo*.&) I"T 11166 I"s U. dia"Mumotal stribW for Capitol oper" dff.,.d 9@1 .01#@ .... - 64SOJIll 1 6SA31 1 84% L#*@ EA%- Ewm of to. @ I"t .............................. s 3.4" 1 2S."I ots'INW0641, , U" 10 . .............................. CIS., 29.311 &ad soo-mast . .......... 31.331 S%111 41.151. IV . .............................. 4.130 17.093 E ... o of sax - finamnal I"I .......................... ... 3.9" 14.971 Kstv@t MIA IW-.. I ..... ---- ... -- ... 3.1116 ISAR tvitt"nonso: Provision ..... 21.879 L.61. - Ijt- @vsrv ......................... .3.- 112.113" E-. ofetterm 4as avata- 1 60.381 12DS.266 .-vAs4MtW.tMw@t t(Im of Los troad" Future capital lease payments include executery costs sol Irverstird Ies . ........ 47-424 S1.639 0.3.19 of IIA56.000. Interest of 112..541.000 and princip'sl pay. --sionsaw Advered estepro"Li oa ...... 112.7.63) 416.7ab- 41.779. agents o($31.191.000. including 32.JS4,000 due In 1988. Some and Inca waft .......... q9.1107 1 4.01 @ 6.Wh, Rent expense was 350.1101.000 in 1987. LL41.325.000 in % Wswory Emple? - 1996 and 337.647.000 in 1985. including contingent rental DaWk psymems *16CW.000, $6.0SL000 and 35.17.0.000, Otitor. mot .................. (AJ241 :.-$6 8.3" respectively. Contingent rental payments art based 49.442 8 13.241 s 103. 9ti primarily upon sales at various retail store locations. Other LoV4*rm LJobitides Other long-term lishiLitles at Decemober 11 consist of the The Company lemon land. retail atoms. store fixtures foliowing: :nd other fedWas and aqWpt. Kany of the looses b*se the Company to pay real estate taxes. insurance (is Avassmlet 1997 19" and asaintansaft cow and contain multiple renewal befirrod insist tamos, a. .............. $ 44%AW options. whieb cover periods rought from out to eighty- pitanses mod Amirr"d sompos"d so ....... ST.2111 UAGI "won Years. Up-stepom I pd . ............ 19.924 12.01-2 Leand property under capital loans at December 3 1. OW4alsomandettradt rkand 1987. smad 19116 consists primmoogy of Isati. badlings and troils Now agqmw*m appoestams ...... - r, ASO improvements. Accumulated capW low amortization Other ............................. 76.199 14ASI was 81" J31,000 and $14.90-9.000 at December 31. 198- 0 ?43=11 I M-154 and 1986. rempee"y. Obligations under trademark and trade name acqulai- Uon agreements are payable to an aftUated company. r"i C: if M: C-- B.A.T Immmmas MLCL - MINNESOTA Mpowm CoPY - PRMcED PURSUANT To I V11.1). OF CoNsENT.JuDamENr 0ATEo5/8MiN SrArgoicAftowsom, ETAL. V. PMXPUORMM ETA CAsENo.041441565 BA TUS Inc. Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements postretirrene"I Bestoftes The Compan@ adopted the provisions of Financial A--t. E%mJ 4,uauWd Accounting Standards Statement 'No. 11'.. -Employers* Arevoulso.1 Bmwat' Accounting for Ptnsilens- il'Af 8% during 1966. pen. 0-d-seh. brortits E%m@d A#@. ition tspense for 1985 of F33.' MAN was determined in Ms. ..M. .. fair -11. ............. 1 mg.731 813.343 0 ecardance with Accounting Principles Board Opinion Actuarislpmow.sluea - Z. S. bruent -64.@; The component* of net periodic pension expenoe for V.AM ................... 639.7,4 33.n: 19S' and IM are as follows: Nso-ird ................. S.M (i. thamissub, 1991. IM Armowlaird brorni oblicau . ...... "I IY.b69 39.44' Servire mat ....... ................. 111 3 I-M I ' .1.6" Effm of pft)"Ind In torm voo so pftjm@f insAi oblipiwo 64.1162 60.659 (Sturesdan increaft . .......... W.&" 11.168 Return - plan .u ................. 1".9241 MASS, Pftjmrd b-to .1ttiptine ......... 56.1.033 MAIS Not swertissues sun Merest ........... -j,40.2131-9-.69 plan ".40 in "to% of.k" than, t r "'k P"nue ... -'-- 5 13.031 3 Mr.3 bliqx1i The significant assumptions used to develop act Varreogou" ort ow.t. Uabilit@ ..... ITS.". I M193 perio&e pension expinme for 1"T and l"6 were; t:omvWuxM art 1paint lovs ......... 91.9.16 5=4 199.1 ... 1 29.7" 1M_ LU i Dousent ewe ........................ &.%% "AM Loosp-wrox row (muro so earts ......... 8.10% 8.17* In addition to providing pension benefit*. the Compsiostiou FM.Lh no . .............. 6.90% 6.24% Company provides himith and Life insurance benefits for certain retired emplovers. The Company maintains funded and unfunded During 1986. the Company began to accrue the plam. Assets of the funded plan primarily consist of actuarially determined Holdlity for r*drm* health and markst" equirr and fixed income socurides, insurance life insurance cats over a ten vow period. The cost of annuity coatraet;. and real mate. The following tables redrims' health and life istsuraner benefits was detail the funded status of the plans and amounts recog. $16.M.000. $14.911.000 and SM4.000 for 1987. 1906 mined in this flonsocial statements at December 31: and IM, respectively. Health and life insurance costs 11117 shown above for 198' and 1986 include. in each year. AnintiLowed Accumulated SOA66.000 related to dur accrual of a portion of the actuarial babilitv. Aagwwalwd awmeau (in shOMMI&O ISMIVAS 1110red Alma Finance Ckew Income Plan earn at . . . ............ S 111111.3go S14.10' . Finance charge income an retall customer accounts. NWW Proven -ak* of which reduced sellisig. gonstral and administrative bards obusad-0: expenses in the accompanying consolidated staterments, of vow ed ................... SMI" "J" income. was $67.928.000. $69.%5.000 and S62."S.0DO WM"NW ................ "1"1 6.600 in 1987, 1986 and 1985. respectively. Armoodead ba"t obligation ...... "6A97 4IJ60 gairaterprow" him salary kinors"s .......... 132.400 9.3" rmionw bomwk emwtim ......... SOJ24 rim assess Looses" d4m; deal prooned km& obwed se ...... L%resopened set isim. K"iy ..... (76.139t join ussampniord prine, Win" row ...... 1006 so Ummoopwwdattlpw.lw ......... 7.7" (468) 34.7 .33 04164441 B.A.T IMMMIES p.I_C. - mm"=A opourm Copy - PRMCED PURSUANT To I VILD. oF coNsENT JummEper DATEo SMW iN SrAyE OF Alkwason, Er AL v. PNxiP NORM Er CASE No. C14M41565 BATE'S Inc. Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements Industry Sf#Wftf Information (is rhouse.A., I", Ism IM The Company hat operations in three principal N.t.86r.: industry segments; Tobacco. Retail and Paper. Tobacco T.4@ ............. 92.406-M n-*T:Jff operatiorti consist of the production and marketinj of MetaJ ............... 2.5"AM .1X1.280 2.1'4.934 cigarettes and other tobacco product* and the processing NP ............... ' -.9.312 7.3.:Il 619.139 le f tobacco. Retail operations consist of department , : : CwmalWateil ........ 83.934.501 $3.4-0.4321 IS-06.902- pecialt*% store retail merchandising. As discussed in ad the retail rettructuring note. the Company said certain 01watial wsruar: retail businesses in 1986. Accordingly. the discontinued Tob@ .............. 8 613.3S6 1&U.4M 14U.-.OO operations have been excluded from the Retail segment. Frt U 371 213 1% 5 165 101 Paper operations, consist primarily of the manufacture s ................ . . 43 . 7 and tale of carbortles s and other specialty papers. Pop . ............... 126.31 , 134.34- 112.144 . Net sales hy industr% segment include sales to B.A.T Tout rpw&u ....... 910.11414 36730 Industries affiliate, and interiegment tales. both of which Goveral-porso,-pease,... (24.5971 119.0381 are immaterial. Opradaii i . . .......... 111116.2117 11".= -.01.90, Operating income is defined as met sales less operating 1111.37.0 1434, 13.014 -pentes. General corporate expanses. act interest NN untren vapam ........ (88.194) 0MAW 114'.6"'o expense. nonoperating expenses and income taxes have lacsou, frow cossinvial not been deducted in determining operating income by operadvas ber- industry segment. proAimseforistonstuize, S $16.463 S '0230 S ULM Total assets are those asset* used in the operations of the respective industry sepainsts. Total assets as of vear- Tsud sswu: end 198. have been reduced to reflect the tale of Taber" .............. a 981.109 $1.0:1.4" S1.051-102 Tobacco. Paper and Retail accounts receivable of It . ................ 1.311441111 1.1.79.M. IA10.775 M41.5M.000. $36.900.000. and 1145.400,001). retpec- Paper ................ OW301 MASS SUA16 dweiv. Tool assets for the Tobacco and Paper seinsenu. Total ostionsto ....... 2."9.7" 3.Ul.131 SJUJ" " oi year-end 1986. have been reduced to reflect the sale Diessadwoodepration - - 11412.1" of amounts receivable of 11100.000.000 and $60.000.000, Ceeperaw ............ 1.70"78 respectively. Corporate assets consist primarily of cash. short-term investmots. equity investments and invest. Ces"Milawd ........ "AMI-76 0424-2t3l 04.317.4st issents in tax transfer and leveraged lasses. The Company has me alipme"t foreign Opel doms. C&OW -p-dk-: Financial information for the Company's continuing Tobsew .............. 8 ".594 852A1.2 S SJ."', operatioas by industry segment for 19r. 1986 and 1985 RMB ................ 203.1" 11GA" 161.430 fouttwo: p. Or ............... ".1." 60.678 IZA" ToWaviessaw ...... 247-M 237.760 Dissandswed I. . - - ".1216 CGCF . ............ 538 3.456 M Comselidsted ........ 0 249.420 82141.855 S2114=3 Dspinciad" sad i Telisew .............. 6AL9112 I SOA16 A SUN a. ................ Mill U.721. 1123" pop ", ............... 46.1" 41.181 Towasianiss" ...... 10.40 MASS Dwmmdmwopwaoau IIA" Calmrsut ............ 901. late W. Caswelidand ........ 6 1 TL622 S 161.919 S MX t NJ is CD BAT INDUSTRWS P.LC. MmawA Doiosffm COPY - PmwmD ftmmT TO I VILD. OF CONSENT JUDWANT DATSO "M IN SrATE OF MkNWSOTA, ET AL V. PNLJP UORRM ET CASE No. CI-944US I BA TE'S Inc. Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements "figration Subsequent Event Or,,wn & Williamson Tobacco Corporation. a On March 3.19M. the Company made a tender subsidiary of the Company. and the other trading cip- offer. at $63 per share. for sit or the outstanding common refit manufacturers are defendants in actions seeking sham of Farmers Group. Inc., an insurance company damages for cancer and other diseases claimed to have headquartered in lAn Angeles. California. The cost of resulted from ciprette smoking. All similar litigation in the acquisition. based on the $63 per share tender offer. the post had been successfully defended by the cigarette would be approximately 64.5 billion and would be fi- manufacturers. and no payment. in settlement have v%er nanced from internally generated funds and a $3.2 billion been made. While it is not postibb, to predict the outcome Imr-ro-ing from B.A.T Industries and affiliates. The of the pending litigation. management does not believe the proposed acquisition is subject to regulatory approvals pending actions will ha@r a materially adverse effect upon and other conditions as contained in the Company.s the financial condition of the Company. -4,11 such costs -Offer to Purchase.- %-it be vigorously defended. Report of Certified Public Accountants The Board of Directors and Sharoholder B,LTVS Inc. We have examined the consolidated balance sheet of BATUS Inc. and subsidiaries as of December 31,11"T and the related consolidated ou enu of income and retained earnings and of changes in financial position for the . car then ended. Our examination was mode in accordance with generally v accepted auditing standards and. accordingly. included such tests of the ac- counting records and such other auditing procedures as we considered necessary in the circumstances. The consolidated financial statements of BATUS Inc. and subsidiaries as of December 31. 1986 and for each of the two years in the period then ended were examined by other auditors whose report doted %larch 16. 1987, expressed an unquallfied opinion on these financial statements. In our opinion. the 1"" financial statements refiarred to above appear- ing herein on pages 20- 24, 26 and 2. -34 present fairly the financial position of BATLIS Inc. and subsidiaries at December 31. 1"', and the results of their operations and the changes in their financial position for the year then ended. in conformity with generally accepted accounting principles applied on a basis consistent with that of the preceding year. Louisville. Kentucky March 14. 1988 34 NJ BAT INDUSTRIES P.LC. - MINNESOTA DEPOSITORY COPY - PRODUCED PURSUANT TO I VILD. OF CONSENT JUDOWNT DATED $/&I* IN STATE OF UAINESOTA, ET AL V. PNXV "1110. ET CASE NO. C14M-MS The BA TUS Group of Companies: Senior Management Brown & ItIffinnison Roy-mead J, Pritchard Jerr@ R. Axuier@ John A. 11,101owulth Robert H. Sachs Tobacco CopporatioA Chaim%ri & John H. Built- Michatij.McGraw Can-a H. Tropic. Jr. Chief Exrrufi%e Officer Lanny W. Butler Ernest C. Peppin Chark. D. White Thomso E. Sandellow. Jr. J"h S. Hele-jes Harry A. Roeder Thons- E.'Whitelsair. Jr. Prnideat & William 8. Knsble Chief 4.4@roiinj Ofrk,,r 4pplelon poison Im. John W. Turner Lawrence J. Cat-j- Danivi'g*. Mclatomh Paul G. Mner Chairman & Rirb&M Cur-en E. Frank McKinn- John L. Tucker Chief Exerutnt Offirer Romalif C. Jeterr Dole H. Schumaker President & Chieroperiiiin; Omerr -eks FOAArrutur Nelvin J-ob* W"" M. Brrta jivansw T. Jacks.n Sidowl A. Mayer Chairman & James R. Clifford Paul Liblang Joseph E. McEvoy Chief Executs-P Officer Jack G. DeLer;%- Charlie, J. Ue,n Home. A. Rosenbloom Urion M. Tanok@ J"h R. Grarack BUt L. Lucas Ellin i. Saltzman Prnidont Also N. Grominon Anne H. Maddott Timothy J. Tobin Marpret C. Haves Gerald J.Mathe.t, Naro J. Urshol Lawrence C. B. HiU morshou riou'r Phillip B. Miller Walter G. Brown Michael A. MacDonald Sanford T. Sacks Chairman & Robert R. Cappem Tedford 0. Made- Kathy E. WIckstrow ChW Executive Officer Siltrid Dywk Kmuw& I. Monroe Gar, M. I-fthin Burness W. Domoloss Christina Johnson-Weliff Melanins E. Rom"a Michael B. Zeman President d; Phillip K. Johnson W111111mot W. Rush Chief operating Orr"r Ivey-* Jan" H. Show John A. Foripiton Unda McFarland John E. Wavelets. Jr. chairman J. NgvW Fl"urkk John H. Patio" Alan E. Wiley Domild L XWW Ronald J. McE@oy Richard L. Schwab President & Chief Executive Offieer -krnrj Them" G. Grim" Gone L Simpson lack S. Vinton Arembew C. muclaumn Chairman & Vicaris IF. Bradshaw Laurence H. Gnal Thomas W. Seoti CbW Executive Otrwair Return A. Bunors Thixw" jeo"It S. Comatilly Carolyn L Suestrinatidin Rielsord J. Mascara Grqer7i T. Moothim Clashmon, & President Child Eitreati'v Officer C, 35 t_r - X . - r1j LA.'T INDUSmES P.L.C. - U111111141EMA DEPOSITIM COPY PWWCED PURSUmT To I VILD. OF COMEW JUDOMENT DATED 500 IN STATE OF AMMSOTA, ET AL V. PNLIP WROW, ET CASE 140. C14M-MS BATUS Board of Directors and Corporate Officers B4"vd of Dievelor, Corpownte offli-em Patrick shroh. Renr.% r. Fripon* Chairman Proidrni & Chief Executive Officer B.A.T Indavirie, p Le. Leonard W. A"attem BATUS Inc. Excruti, r Vice Presidrim Hoary F. Friton" Carl J. Herr- President & Chief E%wmtiit Officer coniur Vier President & L*onwd W. Arootten chier Finstimal Officer Executive Vice President Arthur C. Martinez Carl J. Moves* Senior Vier President Senior Vive President Ton@ G. Holl Chief Financial Officer Vire President of Human Resource& Arthur C. Mwdwz Earl E. Koludiont S.niw Vim Pretwent Vice President of Planninit Raymmand J. Pritchard Unused L Lylve chitirms a Cider Executive Officer of Vice President of Minority Affairs Brinva, & Wigismon Tobacco Corpmetion Not! H. Roe John W. Tomm Vice President & Treasurer Chairman & Chief Executh r Officer of David A. Sthethaor Applown Papers Inc. Vice President & Gem a] Counsel Richmed W. Ty6r Vice President A Comitraller WWOR W. Wyatt. Jr. Vi" President of Corporate Affairs Goveromment Relations F. Anthony Burke Sntkw Counsel 5 P-."- -dCli-f ";. IM W. Few" -appomoduslivaA.riodsome, 9 tfoweris- - -fakmor 4rd 1. 1"1 30 B.A.T INDumms P.Lc. Mmmum Dwosffm Copy - PRMCED PURSUMT To VII.D. oF CoNsEw JuDomm DATEa SWN im SrATE oF Aftwsorx Er AL v. Pwr MoRgm ET CAsE No. C14M4=5 The SATUS Group of Companies Corporate Headquarter* BA RSO 204MCItis".pla. Lmisvilk. Keniurky 4"W2 (SU2 @ S8 149M Brown & Williamson Th3rd larp"t tobamo vosapany to V.S. Tolsorto Corporation am sibor P.O. Box 33M '- 1500 Brown & Withanksen Toor I.mi- WeC&Urria " Loun.9 le. Kentucky 40202 Appleton Papers Inc. World*s leading producer of carbou" P.O. Box 3$9 paper and colored ensearl.. and the leading 82S East Wisconsin Avenue U.S. producer of thermal paper Appleton. Wisconsin $491: APPLETON PAPERS INC. Bass Flfth Avenue 44 fashion specialty seer" in Arisana. 611 Fifth Avenue cavarnix. coattectieut. nsews. cftvrw. Ne- York. N" York 100= Illinolb. Louisiana. Maryland. Xmacbu. setts. Michigan. Missouri, Nevada. New Jersey. New York. Ok1*. Oklaboses. Pennsylvania assd Texas NNW" Flow'* :5 department seem in 111hossis. Texas I I I North State Street and Wisconsin ch"P.11irmip 60M 24 departstarat stores a North Cara". 12' . North Trvea Stem sooth carolias saw norids Charlotte. North Carolina 211202 1'. base* flarainh* Kom and U01 Fostoria Way 40 furaduarr rental Mean in kriaossa. Brouners Son Reason. California 941111113 CaMinge and Nevada I%kauw V. stem he Co"Fewst. Georght. 1001 Avenue of else Ajorricas Illinois. Kamm. Maryland. Massesebu. New York. New York 10018 sob. Michip". Ximwma. Missouri. Tbinibles New Jersey. New Tork. Ohio. pentstylva. 0". Virginia a" Wisconsin r'@j 'NCO roperofted".A.Mcs r 0 hr-d a 4pplr@ V.P@ W. .-APPIM-Pap-C W. --Iaw5b-CbPowWC..1-. -.4 -_j BAT INMISTRIES P.LC- - MINNESOTA DEPOSITORY COPY - PRIMCED MWANT TO I V11-0- OF CONSENT JuDwmNT DATED SIM IN STATE OF ywasom 11 AL v. PH&P Alongm ET CASE NO. CI-94-MS s, Priampall Dowwou Branth: st International Brands: e ManufaeturmF Faciliars: BARCL&Y. BELkIR. C,%PRI. rUCON, BARCLAY. BEILUR. CAPRI. KENT. M.run. Cearlis and K00L. RALEIGH. RIC4L%ND. KOUL. LUCKY STRIKE. NE11 PoRT. 191noisn -Sidem. North Carolina VICER01. -Pn, aw Lai-,; Brand---- PAILLMALL. ILALEWH. VICERUI * "f Tsebarro Prisev,soing Farility: IL il,nn. Nstrth Carolina Product Arsut@ C;srb-@nies- C-r@ Paper Manufarturing Far&ws&@ C-atin; and Fintking Plants, in Harrisburg. (N'CR Pal,,rl brands; Gr4plu,- Arti, st Polls and Palwr MiUr In R"nnp P@nn,% Ivanut. Appkt.n. It isconssus. Prodocts, ipalser and nvnp&Fwr% SFaring. Pennsyl,aniss. Combined Lsis,L.. and Peirrbsrssulth. Ontario. Canada--- Nuninspart Printing Patter, , Applewn"' 711,6cunain. an@ S "t Carrollton. Ohio- - Cap-sidar Plants in Portage. It itransin. Aermal Papers: Con,tri-ter Gradft and Harrisburg. PennsAssmia fasprewty Mated Patters and n..npslwb I C"irad Plant in Musketon. Morkipan."", The BATUS Group of Companies Locations WA OR an In' I" K VVY a PA aff a ON UT I L as Co 000 VA CA 0 Its 1 KV 0 'Can. fic of T" p 0 *2 0 OK AM se o AL A TIC LA On A Brown & Widliamson Tobacco Corporation a Appleton Pape-, Inc. 4D Acton companies G.JILT INIXISTRIES P.L@@ MWIESOTA DEpOSIToRy COPY PRODUCED PURSUAWTO I VILD. OF CONSENT JUDGWNT WED 5/81W IN STATE OF ARAIMSOM Er AL V. PMXV MORRIS- ET CASENO. C14M41M L#k,Flap evf M B.A.T INMWTRIES P.LC. MmEsoTA DuosffoRy Copy - PWMCED PURWANT To VII.D. OF CoNsEwr JuDomw DATEo WSW iN STATE oF Aftesom ET AL v. PNxip Afongn, rr CAsa No. C14M-M5 aATUS(O ;,OuO Citizens Pkma Lauist-iffir. KY 40202 502-531-81m) 71 -6z M 4-1., ll-, !3 B.A.T INDusmas P.LC. - MMMOTA DEpo9ffoRy COPY - PmwcEo PuRsuAPIT To VILD. oF CONKMr JUDGMEW DATEo 5/8/98 w SrATE oF MmwsorA. Er AL V. PHXIP AlbRR6, ET A CAsE No. C144-MS