I ' #; - ~I ;I lit; ~sl '' 7~f~,3i~~t%Ar~C~.~F~;Ili~R~YMlili~L7i~S~XI~P~~ LI·~E;~(~ ·Uid6: ·-· E~1"'~. c r, ~I ki R ~~~· rat, ?- i 1.. ~-=1· I:Pi ,· i·S~ rlh D~C Yrz~ : ~~i"pal, ~ a· - ?· IL I'. j~d ~·:· c f~'nii~Mki~lP~~I?PWOil~l~O~P1WillfP~kn~PPld~~~llS;~~~f~~~;~ ~ I~ ~~ i~kl~R~'ZRltPWfi~WlltWY~LY~II~~~H~'1~);RWIPt~UMhllEYl~~lu;t~DRUIW1(W~·Z~~V~.nb~ilI~~t~~l=~l · P" 8c~ " 2~!N Q W W ~ ;~lb;~·i~!~b~.~ai~RC?Ek~~~O~l~!~g~B~FEtq~?~!i~j~'~P4 ~6~i~:I~!~~ 7: 1 BAT Industdsl documant for Lcg~ Sentes : HelRh Clnad~ rl Try 1899 SE%T,BY:~#PER1AL ~OBACCB LID 110· Q·BB 1 8130M t SECRETARIAL, 0181611811112 FRCP( Ropdr a, AclPan ko DLtributfPn List PJ~J~t~ LCanfldlnt41 OPtObl~ 6, 1989 RII C.D1 Th* Tobac~o P~adu~Cr Cont.o~ hot Bupatior Court d QlsbaP Plxr i~L1 PS~P~al, P~i~p R~rta Plw~lk_Lt nt~ahd L R(port Ho, 7, eooldng t~~ hh kdnl~d~, Oetobc~ i, ~hioh Ihld bl ~ttrhd tp m~ hotl at Ootob~r 5, RBAlrb snclPsurl BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 S~#P BY:IMPERIAL TOIACCB LTB ;Itl· Il·BS i 8!3%AC i SECRETIIRI~1~ 019181181;8 5 PJB~n~TIOR_IIBT Pl~ll~l_r ~qP~PrmQI~ ~d?LT~e~L~ katl·t4uit kuef# llilaat kntlyoa Vio ~~~id~nt~ D~P'i~ion Pende R1Pionlt Llw OirnotoM Plant nanapan Hklhsl Otr~tla~ ~arL rort~r I~~P~m~d RYdyCnrierd rogans Ilylfl RoY echrarta Bt~wart QIU~R Hlol( eannar It4ndrisJr b~ B4rae wan ~da Pone Ihcl(ay ke~r fd~lV~H ibu~tpq ~POP Itan I~a~t~R sMnd Tot~hia ~Ylrl I· BMII1 ~imon Potter BAT Industries document for Legal Senrices : Health Canada 21 May 1999 '' '123 $et i";. " ~"r~:· ~q·es~!~ldTUS IK, i: i, , -I·:.· !· i :F~ .*· * \ IA'TUS INel ~'·I·' · ·:i ~. · .,2000 Olfl22nA P~n Iwldil, Ktn*B(O111 ··nr.:;·d:~; . ·li.i.·(dOl) O~dWD I··: '' II·. · ·· ~· '·: : I ···,· · ·r~'. , .· · r· i · :·r . · ~ · ' ~ · ,: JI ~I ·· · ·.'' r~ ·I':~·~ ~": COMPANY NAAII: ··~* ,·· ' · .· om: ~~i~e · ; r~" · ' ~ r · . ~ .. . · Ir av~ehff OF PAGES (Inobdl~ 1~ p~gs): d is · *· ' ·`I ·: · ·~ r. ii · ;-~ ..~ · ' :':,IF~YOU bO NOTRECBIVE A1L OF tHe PAaEB fRANSMITTED :: ..~~EA88. eAIC (8~ IHhleDIAtUY, ·' · ;·; ··! ·; ~11 ·· i : i'' ' ~r?; . · · 1' ·· ·'·1~·5)~:41:'1;: i: 'il ' ,I., ~r~·~·l,· i~ tj~ ·:I .~c· ' · u· /I*5%1~;~:·1G'' ··~·:e .·llsrci;i~;~aE~hl~··I , ·~: ~:~. :'S~iit::lt ··· '' ::'': '· :" ;"·~ ;Ip·~:·:`: ··I' 1"';"' ,,l·Jl;sg·~! ·~\:·. .. i:; ·~·r.. ~;J~li ]t~i~ ·' .1. '' :i: ~· r ·1- e i L*l,*: .: 7.;j* ·I ": ·· I~il ::: i' ';*, I?'" ·~:· · ·~·.t:~ ·! ' · m:1 ~~N~RUM1ONBr·:- L:~:- ··I · " i. : · ·:· *:I· I· ··· : I ~··:~:· · r .: .....II:d r ·;,· ··::· ,i ·:;·~.·- ·I ~~t; ··- gt~r1::j ,I "1 ·I' c· ·· i... ."11 r· ·~ :'C· ~~ I: ·~: ,..~ .,. , ·· . .' . I, 1(411i. - ·· i r-· ·[.;'·:~ ; '~:'·' ' 1 ·~:~:· ..·. a ~·· ·'~ ~f~·'' I ' ·~"·!·;r:~· · ; :: ,F :.I* · :I :~k·: t - r~·'··~·I·;6~1; l·· L'~GI ·:I :" ,, ·'`:'i, .·· ··i!·c~ ,:: :·, ~~·tll·L~~K:I~1:l ."h .·:-(i_i I:"~!;)·:rti;l ~m~~N~~· ·J '· ~''·' i" `·· 1 · :3~L; -· ~"& ~a;·:;a;le;i ~r~z'l . 1 ~ ~~·· 4' :1,,,,1~ :r I·-. ,~ · '' *~ ~'.*1Y4 · It 09ibEE20ii BAT Industries document for Legal SeFlices : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:II~P~RIAL TOBACEO 1TD ;10· I·Bg ;111051N t SECR~TARIAL·I 019181111;0 1 DIg~R~BPTTONLI8T ~RrP~ C #I~OO~T~At ~p~ridl Tobuco I~i~pif~d JMn·toli~ Lrd,r lilmat nnnyaon Vicl OnliQnt~ DivLion Hldl Rspiod BPr aiwton Plant Ilullprn Ilichbl Dl~c~tsaux Li~ Port5lr ~pld~ea Lj~t~d Purdy e~awiard Terranu nylil RoyBshwarts 9tlwart Qllfia #iak eannar PalldFloir 9alla B~BB Btsn Buba Roll IlaoXa~ ewe Illllium H, Wnrilll Jaqe ~i~iln Ha4ltOlLQ~OUD Bta rrwttoa An~nd Torchia L, BdM11 Bbn Pottlr BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 ; ~ll~,F?~8~9~F~~~n~,'~ 151~"' laEburi nnnPIJ ,.:F:" I s~~, i, . ~~ILDYI~. P noM! __ 4~S AI ~lllcopllr No,~ 1111) 932 6910 Tel,phDnr No,l~ (511) 912 I1I1 Ert,l I·ll.bl. Il~d _ j R"e: S. C bc~tical~ blo QII·~~I~~ r~l~fbpjlr Ip, Pbtb,, 4R LG ~~ Mrr~ipt; 8916EE101 BAT industries document fcr legal Senices : Health Canada 21 Hay 1999 Sl~eR~RAIIL~ 011111111;11 "" ~~'l~i Drs~e~pn~ PRll~e_s~ ~aAr~ ~l~hecp blmi~sd Jean-loull Lelsr #f~t TennXlan Yiea In~~d~ntl a~visfon Lad~ Rogionrl 9a~w Dircctprl Plant Wana~an · aichd Dd~c~taaur HatL Fartiu ~~Cp ti~Di~d hudl CrawfPrd Tarraaa p~lil Roy sehwartr Stewart Challo NICk CMII~ KaFldric~ WoUI _BATbS stan Buda Raal WacXly nuua~a a, gwilb Jaeetsn t~ari~ias Houston CI~ stan goPlten Ilna~d Terehia ~a_rll ~, Bannba SLran Pottq BA~T Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SEDIT BY:IIIPERIAL TOBACCO Lm r10· 4·89 1 9:40AM : SECRETARIG14 01918118116 i ~lenlLaol.in.g E~ '"0": - AS ·R~ICMAh, Tele copi rr Na.: till) 932 6980 Telephonr No,~ (511) 932 6161 Ert,: NUMBER OF PACES linclud~ng cover plgc) "Im' :--LI~L: . i: nl~cB~~iL?. S .cH I~cntiua:_~ ~ _el , b i I - ~ ~1- 22 2 - 5 1 Te j ~cclp ~ c!r Ho, 1 : 't9! -- __~ Tine: : iagp:_~~ ---~ShE~-~L~~ S-~C. ~~---·3CI ·II -~-C-3I~L1 IS _.-··~·C1· BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:IMPERIAL TOBACCO LTU SECRETARIAL' 0191611811P 5 ODTI~BUTI;ON LTST rm~v~HFIaENTIRL ~perisl Tobaeco L~ILEd Jlan·~wie Mercier Nilma~ reon!eon Yiee Proeidbnta bivioioo Heads R69iPnal Sats ~ir,ctorp Plant hnagoFs Hichel. DeaeBtsavx Mario ~Ottler hseo tin\lted Purdy Cranford Torranee Wylil Poy Schwartz BRT Stewatt Chalisn Mick Cannar B~W Kendrick Welln HATEIS Stan Dude Rces YncKby WI11.IQOI H. ~~vi!r(l Jaoqcse tarividre Roulton Group Stan tfouston Rrtnend Torchia LBWgcn L, Dunes 91mdn Patter BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 stnr ~·BL IYO 31 *- HI : nr : r·an· nAa I I Impedal~ecco Umaedllim PnMI Iicopisr No,i (514) 932 1980 Telephone Nali 1514) J321111 Ext,: NUMBER OP PAGES (inclPdiPg eootr pegs) TOI .,~i~?iiW~z~is~lLCf~~b ii~'' i ioc~~i~nl I ~el~capilr Po, ___ _ Datit _ __ kcsr~gt I UKbE~ , -- -- -- - --- -- -- -- ~Nj BAT Indust~es document kr legal Services : Heath Canada 21 May 1999 IiU1 n:LIIUIII ma~cco~m :lo- ns: I:lw: ie"l" DIBTRIBUTI~W WET PRrlATB& ~ONFTDE~F~WI In~pe~lal Tobacco Lfac~c~l 30M.14Uil McrC19r Wi~bt ronnyoon Vice Presidents Division Heeds Regional 9alu DinEtora Plant Nanagsd MichP1 Ovc~tesw Marie FPrtier 1 mascotlitcd e~rdy Crswford Torrmco WylSI RoY Sehwartz BR~ Btowatt Chalfon Wlek CaMar Kondrick ~opl1l 9tllll Buds Rest ~acKay eBe willisn 8. Hevills JaePu8s lariviers Houstpn Grwp stan BeuetPn Rnnand ~otchia t~WYsn 1. BaenW S~n~on Potter BAT Industries document for Legal Senrices : Health Canada 21 May 1499 SET 81:IYPERIIL TOBIICCO i~ ; I-PI-BP ;IOI(IZIY ; SIWIEilllL~ 018181161;11 bSSTR~U~ION I~6T ~B~nTE r ~I~~HT~P~ ~pleial Tobac~imltpd Jean·in~il detclar Nikat Tenben Piee Ptelidents Dlvi~ian Hsadl Rs9fonal galel DkeetofB Plant Hanagcn MlcL1 DeseBteaw Haria rortier Imaaca L1Plitsd h~d! e~awfosd ~arra0Co ih~lie Rcy Gchwartz Btswart ChalfPa Nick Cannar Kondricle lelll gtan Buds R091 HRCKaY eTMC ~J~lliam H, povillo Jacpuos Larivisrs Houston O~UP Stan Hauaton Rrmand Ta~chia ~irqRlnault Simon Paltlr BAT Industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SINT BY:~1PERIIL TOBACC3 LTO ; e18-89 1 SIIBR; SICREIIRIAL~ 11916116111! E DIBTRTBOT~ON L~T PRI\rRTE a COQID~pTIAt ~w~ Tobacco limited Jeen-Lwis Msrcler Wilnut Tlnnylan Via Prssidsntl Dlvidon Hlldl RPqional Snloe Oirectore Plant ~map8rb Hichel DacBtoauX Mar~l Fortisr ~maeco Limited ~rdy Crawf6rd Torrancs P~lip Ray 9dlwarta Btlwsrt ChsllBn Nick Cannar Kondrick Yllle aAns Stan Nude Rode MeQy CTHe nilliM H, Nw!lla jaeques larivisn Houston Q~iP Stan nwatpn Rr;nand Torehia ~pi~l~ Rsnault SJman Patter BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 sEn BYIIYPERIAL TOBACCO 1T0 ; 9·26·89 ;I1:O1AY I SECRETARIAL, '01916'1181;a a ornR_IevTroa LIST PRIVATE 1 CONFID~NTIAI~ TMPERIA_L TOBACCO ~IMITEI) Jean-loufa Mercier Wilhat Tennyecn viee-lresldenb Oivieion Beads Regional gales oireetors Plant Managers Richel ae~ebteaux Marie Forticr I_MRSCO ft~MI~TED Purdy Crawlbrd Totrasca Wylie Roy Sehwartx BAT Stewart Chelfdn Nick Cannar 8&W Rendric Wells BATES Stan Buds Rose MecKag BOUSTON GROUP Stan BOUdt0n Ar~and To~chla BAT Industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 JUN, 6'91 11:111 8AnrS INC, 1MJ, KY P, 4/ d a4TI~~ June a, 1991 To~ H1 B, eannar t, nit J, Dreyex b, johnson II, J, scerav cc~ 8, P, Chllien R, 8, lel~aan 8, Potter R, Sebllta FPtet P, A, Bch~ehter June aO ~lss~P.Ihcaa~a~Lad ns have juat Zenmtd that the judgment in the Cuwdfan eon~titutfonal case an sill e,sl vSlr be rendered "on or about July 10," aecordingly, the PIMtfnq Idcduled ~or June 20 has been ~llnnlod end will be reeohesuled at a rater date, DIA18, IJo BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 IAW OFne~l SBOOI/HARWlrBACON ~1I*I~ sUWWIMMIR OnIII mcrur~Mueo~a~wwp ~~ ~E · ~I 11~I *IIY ~P~t m~P1 ~ 10111~ ICOrmMIII OU~WL~ ~P~St 9, 1991 Inn Johnson B~I.T. Coqany ~d, Millbaak movie Green Staines Middlesex nls 1DP Dear ann: Enclosed please find the authorized English translation of the Canadian ad ban decision, if you have any questions, please give me a call, Best Regards. Yours sincerely, G Gene Peck Enelosare ~1 ~2yoa~ '*II~C~IP*WIIIIDrlll~p~~~UPWlrHrWn* PI~T~O~m rl~ ~ ·IO 1·1~ 111*~~ 11 I I*KtI I·III~~I·*YR* O h' O BM industries docuaent for Legal 86netr : Health Canada 21 May 1991 P,e~ "7. Ici''~L~·j/ L~ a4h O ru O 0\ BAT industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 O IV CO \O BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 P, J/li 10: Sd ~aT L~GC1ISEC,/CIIS 0784 148390 ,inr sri !yp~illli ilBbCeO 113 i I·11:11 ;1ZIZBX I SECREIIRIAI~ 0111615500~;111 azaTat~Pld Wa prl~~b~~ wa~~d~ati~l rmoa!~ablwa f·'ll.a~d Jl~p·~autr Y#okr #llmat ~IIR~iyloa j~P&s~ad~PPsr VLI ~~id~p~~ Id~a Jadab D~ob~oa PHdl n~o''ul(JH OL~d~l IlbeL$l~jn Pordoo $~th )L., YLRIPVI lllthti Mloa~w~w lulk rortl(r ~lx, ~uu~ fmuaa2lmlll~d ~td~ a~otdlllll )SIO ,,p~~ okcur~tl to ,~raau~~ 1~0 ,,S~o~ lakvCFtll ,rl·~ .----- P~~ 33 ~~O~ 0000 ~I royio 1PI1 andrlc~ VIUI i 101 Wg mi P117' Ifk, ~Jd~ lloaa ld~y 0~19 ptew otroul~tl to Wp~W br~L~ ttlP bulten ~Lm~nd To~o~ E~U ~~ 1~011 Ibabk, Ilud~ ~huel #111 trvilod 01103,10 BAT Industries document for legal SeNices : Health Canada 21 May 1999 51 3~T !Zi~b, ZEC, IE i'3 lj 741 i~~390 2, ~liS iEN~ BYI~MPE~IAL ibBAC~3 LIO ; 5·12·92 ;12r19P4 t S~CR~iARIR1~ 1110055000io 1 ludge'igoredbealt8dsk~'dsmo~og I~ - - ~ Kevin Doughut~ TbP QM~kt eaat L~dpl nll*l Ik Iw rslsl rbPrdu~i~(bollab~d~'''' ,... ....' "CL~$Qd~,OUSlpdBrihb~II~~, tncW~at ~e~binnIpdolha tb~oad ~rwrub~drpt~"~ul~mo~F; ~Gmotk~y~ ued~rfmlpre~d~o~ ~ buud ud a~ 0 "64 ~I aau ~RB~ - a Ir~ar~mstrtEs~ rbe IIYl, so#A?DUVOO, U'U~RR~*lg·l~wCuudlm pn~QI~)~V#d~b" I Rnraaru ~u~d plludrl t Prbr Qut~Ol~s~3lud Rrksv, Mel Adr( .8lrs~4~~ktrabhu b~ *kbatjdlewu~o~lnlpx~u ~~Wj~gpPobled]sdu#uiRyl !~l~~~ualuQ~h~bqpldOlb~UQ3 hlul riQI a ~mol~hl nbao h~lb~eE B~ Jb "bbl YU c ~bd~ PI QIKl,ru 1~M3 pla crrm ol Ibt a a I~r b~P9 b&cfo ~t~p~ npQ~p~, ~oP~acsPus Pr~d~oqb~jk2~C n'eauwkntbauarClaatt~ DPlddu~b~ddi~atam~b~hao ~,Sandhu~$rhepn~~lp,mo~~ WPwud rdcml c ~Wd~ cmnmka Rdd?C,aaOt~al ud P~n," ~q~ k IOpd bats drWs ~tc;la~aal Put~ ~mt~ ~Ybse Cwld~wco~, A thaP, ~sP~Udln~ctl$Ib'wllteuopla~ bR d$ Ibs rssua d s ~b~ Ip~b sbYbnulllb#~UO~t~n'l~WWll~d~ ~tmh oo 1100 ipcaeb u 4Pnl urdu tbs ~Od4dP~PnUapc~dlr~wJygk ~eru ~ ~U thtlb'lW~eEo Roluctr cbmp~ "lk tbrs It~tls~ltl bta h"o ~9~0~ tbe Wkl"~b~dmJ IL~r~~~~PPp~bl~bl~np~dl ap~t b~ap~f~e lOLdtaP ~ncl&l ?p? ~tdb~' B~rPd ~d B atul ~d t 1 ap~a!ed · . i ~c~~~n~ ~ji" ·-- -- - · _. _ UddaTRBhl - A awt ~eWonI ~dml Irw b~aa~ C'ban ontohaceo a, coartarge~ a dmddas wu kwdd be; ~ iyP~nd ~ukh p~f~e~o~ A ~p~ drklOR~hu~trurlb,cWaallnu . 'rli~h~ iKlau~ lrums(ioi" ~r ewl 1L~BgalsJabu~Pld . i P~P]nj~10~50 ~4blPIYpl~Ouvalhrl, IrWaM.lbpu~(blbolri~dacnt , tlutv,u~bb:Co~tO(j~i# liipJpd~ I~A~DW~ : I IR"~ pubnb~n,sRn~~r~a~wp~~ucd In tn M~rg~nfwy a~L;d~~ldmtoi~t~ce~~buh~ ~Q~weCPi~ MpRdlY, i0uitd( Suprla~ eP;m ~od yw IbNI·b O try to convlnei)o~ U a s. '~JO~O d(uhs! yd~k. Csslds, pww a r dcn] Ilw uREolutfrsao~ul, ~ ~bjhn~hU4Ij(q#B~er~dd idhhopmiol~uoi~d~r y Ilnotcd bulb iauss, tulio~ to0a APPa] C#m~ud~ m on lo~emrd~ vip~te~ th~ :T;n~ luttlo,Irdud~Chbold b~br' ':' 'fbb~hlPlkllIt~llIlfbtulOn\raR#wl ddtuaeePmPM .~p~,, ~~n~lDp~tb0rRI~ Ibd~nllrycldk~ to~i~du~~R~PljrpmdptrWhCllthep#II~K ~~j~h~thi~ ~il uPcon~irudanlCd~lba~_lU1~11#ni~ i~dHUlil i molQI .t~b#Fq~omWkskaxnpOoj w3Ubcmd ~f~ad~bu U uadap~0~D~ b Ikadnlb~c~ Ild plRad h4 cl Qn~d~ll~ nl ra~ula w! bdunir~a~dlnlC tpp# ~b~doo~palcdenl, :/ ~~~O~eeDcan~nls~plnn~l# Ibkrdlalid~ \vhld~wAll[~c~y~o~g~~kn~CCuh P d4nrsd only we f~l;hj Iton whetba d~tf~aa iwwa CbrbOtmbd~nlbsknsn mbteea . ' 1(00 I(y~ uomcW ~ltt~ Lb~ 6n~CMa IQvtPIuP Sobs~ It II# hc~hc~hc~nF ~b~~ht tob~oe6 let a ~nudold~' b~ Brat eao· " ~n:~(~ik';bi~i~"mdcn~ Plb Mdll~LI&lui~p~(g I~di~nCo ~~bOV'dY~dF~ PPd0~(~dlit~bChllk'~I(l'lii~~drrP~amr lo~d~ir~Ju~#lp~)nC~L ~urr ~dlpla~ k #Iml "O ~e~N~ IM tidenl Ew#nm~t oli~fnlik~ ol'well ·· flrJdluu ~PoNYn~P~i~b~ftbbii;ana, to ~h.~tdmlR9wldlr) dr, pmdlnlmr Ippl rhkh buss woluetipl rsol~ PE~blfiiS1,~·bl~aa wm· 'cEa~h~o;~ba~~bo uhl ~m#li~nO h(h unda ptovb;n~Y~n~,~IbrlbiQabm# ~S~olomtSupmuCant dlj UmI ~~kb~Ym~fi~l~u~ ) 1:I(I ddm~ p~ WI 8t~8t0ll tuu: whabt~ .wuov~rm.~ : (duyo~~iP~rm~nlbuc Igm~d~bm Bllm Pttd #ne~na Ca~b a KI,#D dra~ laub la CLP Ell~ll K)P eCIII 01 aaea d L~d B~ Pa can elluel dl, deuhs, O~m uys it~~ .II I .. ''"' ".' I II·,I·(·· I · . 1··~. · I, I nru o# rnl to Rlt ~DO~Od aldpl hat~ co~ Itcn Ilb I Clpd]u~ C~nm SPdy li]d r~coP~ndl~t~ctPt~ob~H entsd d# dsd~J~ nff dtol ,~aw~apdoPiPCwd~ BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 0:jT Bi~i l~li!iSE;.ill~S C7SI ;IEj?O ?, gi i ifNi~ BYI1MBCBIAI TDSACCOITD ; 5.13-911 1:ISPM I SEeREGRIAI· 1181155oC019 1 .r? $erial~obaccolimUedl~mll~e 51t0, rut Sc~n~olol Ilnll Uonulll, R 9, Hle 1 P~4 osl~n~~ P,O,Box~WOCR hA~nl~kl, RP, HSC SU I A.X ~ R AYB M1 TT )IL 4P R.M hbllbbgllmd Uxm~m OSW01S B1X )(su) 911·6980 AGH: 8~· RcYHdd NuwacR bF P~Ge81 g (ncZ CoveR PAG&) '00; NbFIE _. Pe7eR C~/H~K ZOBT~ON _8 A.T FAX t oll· 34-183. S~ss-dab aAT~ 'PIME 1104 YEBB~G~: ......,...,.. _ BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 MP,?, la '92 IO:5T 31; LE~1ISEC, IGiPS ~16J 1J83a0 P, 10116 3P1 yl~llypl~l IVUA~W ~ y , 111t·13 1 IIIYYI I 'an~lml?~ ~ ~ U101131UYyll 1 LY $m~lP~tn~~i~.yl ' 31110, nn S~~AnlPlnl SlrmJ MnncCal, P,p, li(c lab P,O, Lx OIW C,P, ·· Mba!rfll, P,P, n3Clze cn~l~lClbb IUlmp' PQla Oil·Wa~ ra~gd~rp~wemu, hr IIIIAIWI r0; I)ISTI~UTI~N· PROMI RO(iER S, ACI~UV MAY 13, 1992 A~tlahed ii I copy of tba remd D~y aapPrt a l~d hppcdl Court Ro1e1dln31 to Kmwctlon wfth the Aaotrey Owo~l Appal ~O'P L J~dgn~blt dldr, 3111:11 Clubol, enclosure BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 MAY, 1l '92 10:57 slr~vlcai;ia~,ml INI BYIIMBe'RIAL IOlk;CO1TO I I·ls·JZ I II1lSy SERBADIII' DlilllllP;;li~P, i 1/16 Ilt~TR1Bf~6N tIST n~Tab~Naco~3o~abl DIPERU~168ACM~aTbn ~bmllotlll M#cla DOrt BhlWP Vlc~RwtdeDlts Dlvidoa Hwdo Rsgto~ul SJw Ditccten Pbnt ~dr~uCws ~ehalDa~cblp~ux Marie Fartlq ~s~o IIMITeD ycnam~ ~sbtoc~~D1#nn~fba$lf~lb~, Bd~ RruClut inaclodrc~~bS,C6~~kl.lbl~) sRn~N &.~L~I~bMSQ KcnMclr Wcl~ BBTE9 Stan ~uda RosJ Maegay Rob P~ ~e tPcbculo~~lpl~cpJalariYi~p) ~IIIUS~S~BQUE St~n Howtaa Ar~Mnd Twehla OStB& HQSXIN t, BMlas ~ao~L xdxau Chuc~ W111 ~coa, MBDI~D~B Bdwin ~ocob g~g~a ~SPAt~D~d [iordan Smith P,K, Rym (dltlt~ BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:IMPERIAl TOBACCO LTO : 1-30·91 110:29AN 1 SECAEIARIAL· Oft 233 1C3B;; 2 FROtI: Roger S, Aclown TO: Management Committee M, Descbfeaux S, Qtapin P, Cillies A, Johnson K, Walls hasco July 30thl 1991 Re: ..1251. Judaenent: I have been advised that the English translation of the judgement will onl~ be available late in the afternoon of July 30th, 1991, I will distribute a coW to you as soon as possible, The delay is occasioned by ~he need to be accurate, Yours truly, A~Y~I~L~ Roger 9, Adcplan RSA/ am dictated but not read BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:IHPERIAl TOBACCO LIV ; I-'1S-Y1 ; I:UYAR ; S~tWtlAnlAl' U1II~'I1SZZOZDY;lt Z .. ~ : ··~- ~ C~CC~~4 L~Lt/ July 14, 1Psl IIZiE WaAccO EBODUdS ~PL~TROL R~ · JUI1GEIBtP We have been informed that jud~ment uill be Eendated on ~rfday, July za, at approxi~ately 3 P,M. bntreal time, We undetta)re to inform you as to the eeeence of the juagment as loon PP pooeible thereafter, a. 1CI~AN BA~ Industries document for Legal Senrices : Health Canada 21 May 1999 t t t iB~B~iSjlrl# F.ESU!T il~~O~i i Ji[i,36'91 1?:53 ) ~ t t B, A, I INOUSTIIES 1ECdl ~EPT, TIME SiSE~: 12:jl Fllf 03P:. TOTAL Pb~3S i~iO, LABEL ibSEl M01E PACES REZ1'17 BC~SE~iT ~~"~~"-"'~~~-~~~~~"~~~~~~~~~~~'~~~~~~`~~~~~~""--.'*"'"""""""""~............---- ;5J8 01jlj1l43269e0 TX 2 GS ~""'~~""""""`~"""""~""'~~'*~`~"""................""""..."""""`......------··--· d B~diTmWSIRIES Wb6sor House 50 ViEIPrja Street london SW1H DNL Telephone011·222 7979 Fax 071· 333 1138 ~w~a~l '[1EERL DE~ART~MT] io:··· ···~~·~.~14~~~ ~P~SeF~. CT·nY~L~ ~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~ a~N: ..........~~kP~~~,a~?~~~~ ~~ ~~~~~~ ~~ ~ ~~~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~ FAX NO: .,,.,131sr~b:,15~1~ ,,q~ ~ta ~~~~·~~~·~~~~~~~~ """"'" ..,..,,,..,,,,,,, ,.,,, "''"" 11(1·1111111))111111 11111111·1111111 (tlllllllllllllllll I1I1IIIIII11IIII FAx NO: 11 1~11~1~1111..,....,,,.·II 1(11·111111 11111I(()IIII11 11(111·11 1111(1111111 ---~-~ FROM; 4JJl ~j~whlfc3~ 111(((1)111(11111 )(((111111111111(1 I1III1(1I1I1III1I11 11(·1111111111 )111111( ~ACIES SENT: ,... .~3.. (Including cbwr rhoe~) Message: BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 B~ INDUSTRIES $Idpr Hp de 50 Yq~e g~~ ~rQn ~IH 0~1 hipbns 0; ~222 7979 Fax Oil-233 1438 a~ Pd legal d SecreBnd Department a'9d Cg~/Cg ae boae S P thin 30th July, 1991, bger S Ichan Ist,, IP and General counsel ~mperial Tobaccp Limited, 3810 St. btoin Street WeJt, Montreal, $ebsc, I(C 1BS, B_Y_E~ 0l01 511 )31 6911 Dear Boger, ~'ny thanks for iattinq to have a copy o~ Ih( pralilinaq translation, I iully appraeflte IOPC onnoerns about translations and centin that I will use this docoment Solely for ny om purpo6es internally, we will await the final trana~ation betore laking any external use of it, O"CB again - congratulations, Years sincerely, L ~J~sor I~~~~*ule ~.pPla~(n·*~n2 ~~I~~Y1~13y~PI I~kPI N BAT industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BV:!MPERIAl TOBACCO LTD r 1-26-91 111:32AI SECREiARIAL~ 011 233 ld38;C 2 MPIORRNDVM TO MR, NTCX CANNAR AND MRS, ANN JOHNSON July 15, 1991 Fu;rt~er to your letter of today's date concerning the i~ninent judgement, ~ am enclosing herewith a few draft materials including a press release proposed to be issued tomorrow fellowing release of the judgementl I am sure you understand the degree of speculation which thess questions and press releases contemplate and I trust you will treat them accordingly~ we have learned that the judgem~nt will be in French, the only orrieial copy, We understand it is long judgement and we will attempt to t~anslate it over Friday night, A copy of the c:fginal French version and the English translation will be made available to you, caution ehpuld be taken when relerr!ng to the English translation, No doubt there will be several nEngl~sb" versions, it not, interpretations , I\gPin I will do my bese to keep you infonned, Regards, Aoger S, I\ckman Vice-President, Cen;ral counsel ~eexathFy :Q 'N BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 grhB ~eCII~IRMAN ~I~~ ~O~HTDN L1~GP~ ~IIlIEAUI ~Ni~ ~1CP ~I~~~OWb Please lind ancloa~d copies oi press rslesses isJPtd by Ilparial, W~acdonald ~nd tha Ministry oi aealth and Lliars, t~tthlr vi~ edditicnel press clippings, 1~ ~Z ~~g 2e~h ~~ ~1 BAT industries document br legal Senices : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:IHPEAIAL TOBACCO LTO ;10-18-89'; 9:31Rll ; SECRETeRIAL~ 0111112124269;C 1 LLI . ~eAlLrm~~liLH t~ I;~;; tROnl ~ttrJ Tlleeeplcr Hp,r (II() D11 (900 hllL.tlil·l illii(l1ilil sl·I_ H1 IER pr )MilS llaLlu41og cove p140r Nbnel CCIAi bca t i on 1 hl,F~PI(T W01 g(j ~jj I ~Z bate: neleage: lld~ 13AT Industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 ii '8~ 10138 1 KANSAS CITI' PLACE P, ii 2 ~*olr III S, RC, SHOOIIHARWEnBACON ill OeT 1989 III Illlm·Pn raaft~lurne OIIIIKU~C~IUC~ ~naaa~n IOWMVI~W rco~onnrd# 'H"M~Un#IPn~O~a~u olu#~ururu PEn~O~fltw X~Hb~dem,vavRlnos [Ill)llldWP Il~j~l~w~ Telecepy Number lor Tobacco 2aattsre: (816j 411·2168 TEProPn ~RILblSM59910H t9e ~Lre Banding ~2· rages A~ J, (Ineluding T~i~ cover Page) 18 OCT lutr~ Delivery To: Fram~ -- Data: Please Deliver Additional eopies To: Additional Dalive~ Iriscrueti~nsl RUSH Ci Pla~be Eall lp dilcues :noaed!atoly~eviev WE AXE TWINSMIFTINC FROM A ~UeOB RAPIeOM 830 (CROUP ~II), TE YOII IXP~I(Z$CE ANY PROBLEEIS 11 RECEIVING ANY OP THESE PAGES, PWRSE ULI US 19 SOON ~i W8SIBll AT (8111 474-6550, IYT. ~f, IliMlr YOO. OPERATOR : __ :3 lu BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SINT BYIIMPERIAL TOBACCO LiO ;10·11·119 ;IO:11AM ; S[CfimRllli 0116612221269111 1 aPe 110171989 IRdl(; ~A13 Trleeopicr 00,1 (51(1 931 699i Telephone Ho,l ISll) )32 6161. . ext,: NU~1ER Os )1101S Ilnr1udinp covet p,pel Name: ~rf~T_~CCCAt tsc~tion : nlcEopicl No, 3ste: leo~age t Il~(oE Ni' BAT Industries document far Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BYIIIPERIB TOB#CO LTO ;10-11-99 ;IO:lliW : SECAET~IIIIl· 011(111211169;0 1 ~E~T Jsan·1CUls MPZFlbl )I:lmat bnylFm V~ec ~~~idata ~IVIP1OII B~dl ~~~w Nichal b~P~I~_ Har~ts ~1'"F'4ux ~ortia~ ~eco Putdr'P82 9369 ,Ilb~r·,-_~~Y~aiB tO ,,Rcy BebralL. wt Qlolfep dll (( 1 211 (26) IUI~Vq":.sI KBnd~p~ all, ~TB8 i "02 566 897 Stan Lde 89au HecXay ~llia B, NsPilla,.l lsg~, elre~ato 615 238 (163 ·Jac~~ larlvlh,~ ~-" C~Up "1 Aoustoa Oand To~hia ]ahlel "1 Pctts ~LH~~ L N~1 1 Bib U1 87 led 16,10,39 BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:IHPER~AL TOBACCO LTD 110-1'1-89 ;11:22AI r SECREIARIAl~ 0111112 22a269 rf 1 au ''70Cr1989 -· a~p~~lras,u,llilu~i~ I~U~i~B. :I~se~es Tclssopiir No,! 1511) 9326980 ralephone Nbl: (511) 912 61(1 EXt,t NUMBeR OF mCES (Ineludlhg cover pegcl 2 Rame: I ~ ~cc~l~t IPCltS on t -~L_I_ ~cl~copicr H6, )cte: ~ 17 1o1_64 restage; BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SVII BY:IUPaIAL TOBIICeO DD 1111-11-89 111:1111; EQBRRIC 0114112111tlPln 3 orsTaJBuTIOIP LIBT J,·t~, Lxeisr R, Bfhvart~ a, QlalGn X, WI1L c, Ball S, hotter f, Barnes p,J1 Dunn BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 is ' eo i I EIIISAS CIT'i PLACE · P, 1 uw orrlct~ S. P, r: SHOOI(,HWlYaBAcaN ~socr nnn arlllmr~ ~WLIGIWMEITYILACE onaw~r: II,UI.IMIUI~WR 1L~61WI~RII ICA~~O~DI ,'unmn~aua~Pmnuwu P~rucnmwRu ij·": IG~WB~aUF~,UWdWIIWloI II~QWIY~ Cl~rrcs~s~ Iw#wuo Telecepy Number lort tobacco MdttOrO: (818) 411-1'108 TEZECOPY TRANBBIBSION Wslre sending 3 Rpes 1Sncluding Tbfe Cover Fag!) Dalive~y Instructions; ~5/S rmm! Date: Please Deliver Additional Copies ToI Additic~al Delivery Instrueticns: RUSH (] Please call to discuss fmpcdiatoly after review WE ARE TRRNSMITTING IROM A PICOH ItAPICOM 830 (OEoOP III), TF IILlU FXPGRTEN[IG ANY PROBLEMS TH RECBfVfNO bgy OP TIIE~B PACES, PLEASE CALL US AS SOON AS WSSIBLE AT (8161 414-6550, EXT. d~~69, TKRNR YIIU: aPE114TDR : S106EEZO1 BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 S;Nf BY:I#PERIAl TOB~CCO 1I0 ;10-16-88 ;IO:11Atl I SEGRETARIAL4 0l1d41222(289;X 1 16 OCJ 1989 ,I RS ffCii~lnhl TeleEopler Hb~l (514) 931 6980 Telephone No,: (Sll) 93t 6161 Ext,l NUMBER or PAGES (ineludlng cover page) Illr: ~Ta4RT CfC41FW f~oeation 1 I l~lampili 1~. bbte: - -- Nme: message: -- · · · - 411GrJ7 : BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SU1T BY:IHPERIAL TOBACCO IfD ;10-18-89 ;TO:2'IAll ; S~CAETARIALJ 011411222126913 2 FRme Ta Roger 8, AclPau~ 9w Dietribctior Lilt Pc~mts 9 Confidsntiai October 13, 1999 Re: edl 'Ph· Tobacco PS~6duatl`Cont~ol Act gup~iay Court of Qusbso Our ZiLu_ C-51 Tribl·-DRI1111 89W2~4 R_apo~t HDI le The proceedings on Thursds~, October 12, e~neod with the continued oro~o·wanination o~ Dr, Roidl Bhortly into ·t~ day's proceedings, a procedural issue arose c~nc~t7ling wideotlarp evidence, After a rocpcle, Jud~~ Chabot sdjcu~sd until a~day, October 13, for arF4nont by the lerjers on the avldentiarp issue, ~otal Ilo haw had diecuaaions with NIJ( Cr~mar, Bob 8ache snd other rspnsantativu n~ RDT snn RrrWn C Yltl(Prmnn nnannn~nn dnmmnlr Pl~mI I~I1UI~~ lr IlnlU meeting to be held october 13, R9RIlr enclosuts BPIT Industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BYIIMPERIAI TO8ACGO LTD ;10·18·89 ;10:29A)I ; XCR~ARIAL' 011U111:628911 5 DI8F1~840~ _t~hT p~rrmg h_CP~PI~TII~ ~P~rial ~obacpo t~a~ted JPp·IQld~ ~BPCj~Ot tilsat Tsnapeon Via Pto~~ddota Divi~~oa Ilsadl B69ional BPlu Diroetcro · Plant nanagera Hichsl Dslobt~aw BaFia Fortia Jmasro limited Rlrdy ~swiord,,pleaee c3re~ato to ,,Torsann nylie ,,Ray SChVLl~t21 BAT 9t9wut ~allen,,,plcdr eiroPla~ to ~~Niek Cdn~, BCW ~spd~ick Bells BATgB Btan Ildn Aaa ~aQR~ CTMC lillfplaa R, BwlUe,,Pieaaa e~wlat~ to ,,Jacpuw ~arioiat~s, Rctlstan ~E Stm Bwstoo R~and It~chia Lauuera I, Bbrm6r 9finan Potter revised 12,10,89 IV ·-- BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BV:IMPEI(IAL TOBACCO 1TO 110-18·89 ;10:30M ; SECRETC~IAL~ 0111112221289;1 8 DISTlrlBPTICW 1189 PRIVATe 6 ~II~X~G ~IFpednl Tobacc~t~i~ited Jesn·Iauio Nbrcier nilmat TPoqwn Vlee ProslLt~ Diviafon Hsadlr Xog~onal sales Dircctoxt Plant Ilanagsre niehol awalmr natL Portiar In\aecY, tintlted Purdy Crawicrd,,phaeo cfreulate.to ,,Torrancb WyUs ,,Rojl 9cnwastn, BAT Stwart Chalfen,~~pleaaa elsc~o to ,,Niele Cannar, Bbn XsndriJe rslle BII~B 9tan ~sda Xon ihcltap c~e IrlLli~n~ 8, roill~,,plsa# circlllats to ,.Jacguoo Zarfoiere, ~aa~tonCwPp 9tan ~ouetcm AFmand Tarchia r~pars L, Barnba 91wn Potter re~id 12,10,89 BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY!~~PERIAL TOBACCO LTO 110-18-89 ;10:30AY t SECAETARIAL~ 011aP1222k2691r 1 DlBTRIBDT50N LINT PIUVATE Z CD~DE~TZ~ fmperial Tobaooo_Lioitod Jlan·loui~ asrclar ni~P~t Twnym Vies Pwddont~ Divfoion B~d~ Regional Salon ~irs~tpn plant n~na~~ Wichll DHpbtoaw Harie~orEisr ~malea fiattsd Rud~ bmiord.,pl#lrp eirn~lat~ to ,ITorraRes nylb ,,Rey Bchwartol I~T StcwaFt ~alfan,,,pl~as~ Eireulao to ,,Nick Qnnar, x~ndrick nails BFSBB Bten Lda Rosa ~ac~a~ En~ nilli4 A, AoOilll,,plea~l eireslatb to ,,Jao~t~l tarivim. Itauetp~L~I1OPP Bt~nRou~tan Amand Tot~hia ldlfPara L, Barnel 9in~3n Ibtt~ roviaed lt.tO,I19 BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:IRPERIAL TOBACCO 1TD ;10·16-89 ;10:31AM ; S~CRETAAIAl~ 01111122212891118 PRDI TQ aogpr QI Aolown 8# DLtribjtion Ilst Privats t Cbn~ldantial October 11~ 1989 Re: c151 The TPblceo BroduPCs CentroX ~et Gupuior Co~t oL PuPbs~ ~k ii1llI _C~il TEIB1. PPI1P BeWrte RdP~t Not 9 EnQPPd horotitJI you will lind Report No. 9 for ~y~y perulll, iik41~· XBA:cb ,fic~o~urr BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SEIIT BY:IMPERIAl TOBACCO LTO ;10-16·B9 ;10:39AY I SECRETARIAL·I O111Ct 2221269;018 FAOM n, Roger 9, Ilc~n see DistrSbution Ilet Pci~ats C C6nZidsnt~~ October 6, 1989 Rat e~sl The Tabbcco Produ~n bintrP1 Bot bhrPILTf4~ COlrrt O~ P~O~C ~ ~i~Ls: _ c15'1. Trip~ LPailP_llan~P~a RoPort Ao,'l Ilttached is EtopcoJf No, i, ~o~sring the date 58dneeday, October i, which should be attached to ny note d oetoba~ 5, RBA~eb encloeure BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:I#PERIAl I~BAeCO LTO ;1G·16·89 110:5448 t SECREIAAIAL· ~111412221269;539 DI82aTBII~~I~K1362~ PRNAT~IQ3~D~NTUlt raaerialbeeto I~imited Jwn·toufs 13~ei~ Wilmat Tann~loa Yiee knidentr oividon Hada Regional WILs Dirsebrs Plant 8anagere Illchll DWedtMux Watie Portlor lraeoo Limited hsrdy cra~nerd,,plwre ckeuhta to ~~BrMel ~is ~~Roy Sehw~rtz, Stewb~t Chalian all 44 i 222 6269 Hfck CPMar P11 44 1 212 3659 Kandrick &IL BATeS Btan euda Rose Maday crwe william fl, 5tsolll..lplpas clr~ulate to Il;acquel harfeilrp, troue~on C~n~E Stan H~uatPn Armand 'lorohia L, Buno~ Bia~n Potter ahe~k, ~Is~I~au Quck Wall 1 816 411 5447, rsvisd 16120,69 BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:IARIAL TOBACCO LTO ;10-IB·PB ; 3:51PH ; SECRETARIAL~ BllC~12220289;t 1 noll; ~ Il~iili~M~a?i Tcl~copirz No,: (51(1 Olt bPBO iu "~M"~3 T~lcphohe Bo,l IUIIBER O) PlbES lincludlng tear p~gll l~i· 'Por Ran~o: i-· · ·--I LLY Location I Talteopfat Na, - . ----~-~ ~ltc: ~-- Time: I]Plsspr: ~_~ LLIII ----LICCCI · ---~C- BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 SENT BY:IIIPERIAL TIACCD 1TD ;10-18-89 ; (:02Pn ; SECRETARIAL~ I OllP11221126P;P 8 e~WhDb C6DR UI~1IB~tt ~rsTR~eT PI~RoYDet bt aol f0010).00)1101111 f~tME~ 10)ACCe rXPI o~lnnt~l u PRDCORaOf e~gn;n~ Po CAN~LI fnlbil ·etl td ~ROC~Fd OBHE~U~ DI pv~sael fII·QP·CLYIII JllOln~W~ Z1 trlbur*l #t w~d db dlVln~l obj~ctibn~ (PU~)· vCcs dm~ 1a cabre g(nlral d'uns ra~lt, ~dur jull~atn~ ~ltk· ratoin antqtle d~a~ 11 ded~t 180·OSt009t5]·183 plf aJR· MaeDonald at daal le do~~l~t ~00·05-001116~·111 Pat Sp,~ld T~bwaa ttd aoPtra 18 Ptoc~luc Binir~t d~ elhJ lllant I illn decllr'# 1a bi ~qlmntant Ic~~prbduUI dr Clbr gul Cat la ~Lpitr~ 1DI Itll9tl du canada pa 18811 eontrolre I 1C Icl cahstltotlanvlL dC Illf 31L ~h#tl aInadianna - -------~ QI dEbill Ct Ijb~~tl~ L ebjrt~Pnl dtf awlav88l dfnl L P~brl plr· tlsulk d'un I~bp~oll~ dwtl taaUa dgn14L ov I(ln ~1(F1~10 P 1a Protuihlr dnbral L amaldme lu nprlCCntCnt Idn r~pulrmt~~ dbnl C9PI d'lPPOrtar lylO lui lot, de l'~xsni~n spslr dl~w~o gut tCaO laol pCp dal h ats de RJR.bPon~la If C~ 1 ICI~L dill coa~al Un intlrrqltoira Iwl Il danl b e* adl P1 la adntlnuara 6cans un lntelrqlalalre loul r d'lportcf dana un dltlajn aaabra aa dbcu4mtl dont !'lnupllr~tloh appatnlt rux p~qrrph,~. 1 1'I1 b bJe,a tacua Ma~d~ du I dOe~bn 1)8111 CaPCI tanu de k canlldenti~~41 I1Jgu~e da CUrtCInC de c# doouount~~ II, dCllC okoun dCa dCUX ttl dollLn ont plCkntl Un) p;llBinda ~ abhtrohnt une etdenaanee de o~nlldatigfci, One antenta BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 64 B~P;T INDUSTRIES Wcsor HwseSO\I clona StieellondonSW1HONL Telephone01·2227979 Fax 01·2220122 legalg Secretarial Depanme~t Your Rel. The Sdlcllor: S. P: Chall Our Rd SPCS 6 O/JMH Ist June 1989 BY FAX Mr. R.S. Acloaan Imperial Tobacco Limited 3810 St· Antoine Street West Montreal, auebec HQC 185, Dear Roger, CHAUENGE TO BILL C51 Thank you far your interesting letter of May 25th and attachments, I gather from your letter that Mr~ Justice Chabot will, perhaps by nov, have delivered his judgement by the Attorney General for production of Daculaents~ We have a Board fleeting here on Tuesday next, June 6th, and I am guj~te sure that Justice Chabot's Judgement would be of interest to the Board, Perhaps you would telephone me to brief me if the decision is rendered before the Board Meeting~ Yours sincerely, S?YI S,P, CHALPEN Bn T wtollww DIC InCOIW13~dnl(ndbn No 211112 b~epr~Phe ~MmsBa~vd lo~on I Te~l BBP5 O BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 t ~ ~ TEP,IISMISSIOH FESI'IT REPORT i JBi, 2'90 lj:~S i t t f EIIT IIID11STPIZS 1:11 2~2 ~I1C i~T~1 i~;Es ilC, 1,Pii ~62 i~·;E5 iEt!llT [I·li ~Ei~; BA~ Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 9999 t ~ It MMCIRY T(EFrlFIT ( JUII, E'39 1[1:52 i t t ~ ' 'IPISFEF. "ii .I. rli: ... jj:, la~EL .r*:·r i~jllZ TIX I''''' ~isl ISH ~::c~ ·-------·-··· ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- n, : t I !I i·: 1?·~3~ ·: ~~: ;5 1·~1!71 ~6LL~ il~l ~~.i I I ~ I i N C~i a O o u BAT Industries document far Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 ~·hT T!i: WiPID5( II; ~il~llC 222 ~'i;~j, $(~ 43bdY~ Me: a i~l~ictihj C~!I·ll'dCI~ I~~ik~ rg~c~ ~~~~ FRl'lhl ~F~fi~( ''"'""''"""'"~~"""' 1 niu\~~~!ssel PaCE3 I;irlT (Illi:Lll[ijiili CllyE~ SHEEi;: ...-) i.: II nneNr~ sS BAT Industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 4999 ~ INDUSTRIES ~~I h01 HOUw $O Ycbna Stat london SwlH OH1 Telephone 01222 7979 Fax 01·P20122 ~9j~ Seaar~l Depanme~ $~ 'J SPC5SO/JMH erSadrjPC~~m lJt June 1989 ~L~BX Mr, R.S, Ichan Imperial Tobacco Limited 3810 St, Intoine Street west Montleal, putbec A(C 1B5. Gear Rogct, CHALLENGE ~TO JILL C-51 Thank you for your interesting latter of May 25th and attachments. I gather from your letter that Mr, Justice Chabot will, perhaps by now, have delivered his judgenent by the Attorney General Ior production ol Documents, we have a Board Meeting here on Tuesday next, Jone 6th, and I am quite sale that Justice Chabot' s Judgelen: would be of interest to the Board. Perhaps you would telephone re to brief me if the decision is rendered before the Board Meeting. Yours sincerely, R S,P, CBACFBN 81~ *a~a olc kCWWIJI*n londMNo233llZ I~ilclla Ballnd kl Lb 911 BAt Indust~es document br legal Services : Heath Canada 21 May 1999 - *~C B·A~T INDUSTRIES Wlndsor House 50 Vstor$ Street london SW1H ON1 Te'ephone01-222 7979 Fax 012220122 YourRd Legal b~ Secretarial OepaRme~t Oli' "' SeC6B4/SMD TheSdwlor:SCChalen ~Hay, 1989 Roger S, Achan, Esg Vice President, General counsel and Secretary Imperial Tobacco Limited 3810 rue St-Antoine Street Montreal, P,Q H4e 1B5, Dear Roger, BILIn..C51 CHALLENGE Thank you for your note of April 26, with which was enclosed the case summary, I would be interested to know when the case is now to be heard, Yours sincerely, S,P,CHALFEN B~At~duslaD,LC, hcWonlcdnlcndonNoZJ1P Tekpa0~irE~d~s~Belnd~ndplSN1 TabtJS195 N BAT Industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 Imperial '~bacco limitedilimii~ 1810, n~ SI·:\nloine Slrl!rll ~fob~rCnl, I'P. II·11: Illi P.O. Bos 65UO I:.i', ·2RPK irdY ·,~~j~c:2t'~~ April 26, 1989 Mr, S,P, Chalfen BAT Industries p,l,c, Windsor House 50 Victoria Street london jW1H ONL England Dear Stewart: Bill c-51 Challenge Pur file: Ctl - Correspondence Please find attached a copy of a ease surwoary and chronology concerning the Imperial Tobacco challenge of Bill C-51. Yours truly, ROGERkj~P~CKt~AN Vice President, General Counsel and Secretary RSA:eb enclosure BAT Industries document for Legal Senrices : Health Canada 21 May 1999 I B~T INDUSTRIES Wlndsor Hwse SOVEtor$ Street london SW1H ONL Telephone 01·222 7979 I~· :······lrwl~ Fax 01·22201 22 ~bwRe~. Legalg Secretarial Oeparlmen~ Ou~ Rel. ThcSdsitw: a, P. a~lC SPe574/SMD is March, 1989 Roger S, Aclonan, Beg, vice president, General Counsel & Secretary Imperial Tobacco Limited 3810 rue St-Antoine Street Montreal, P,P, H4C 185 Canada, near Roger, Thank you for your letter of 13 March enclosing an Opinion in respect of the possible application of Bill C-51 in light of the relationship between Brown a Williamson and yourselves, On the subject of Bill C-51, I would be very interested to understand how the constitutional challenge is progressing, yours sincerely, b-w s,e cMyseet B~T hd~plnrple hCgdrmd n LcndOlNdrJ31P Te~cprsO~icMdnaBsl~ ladon~n ~Ha 915195 N BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 S~ P, C. 20 MRR 1989 ]mperiaJ Tobacco limited ilimiii (alJI !1:121il1; I C;I IIIII,( :illlr "T~~lilllll' li~la·c,TCL~ Ili$·lilllif:l 3 :]· March 13, 1989 5~ 1~~ "C~L"L~L~~Y nl. Stuar~ Cheltap BAT Industries p,l,c. Windsor HouseBox 345 O i~· 50 victoria St, London, ENCIAND SWlH ONL Dear Stuart, I an enclosing herewith an opinion recently obrainpd regarding the relation between Brown & Williamson and ourselves in light of Bill .C-51, Yours t Rogerff, Ackman Vice-~ es iden~ , General Counsel i Secretary BAT Industries document for Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 NCITE99R MR,_BRUE~L SPC41'1/MJR 1BthJanuaru, 1989 Canada- C51 I attach for your information a copy of a note which I have sent to the Chairman today, j I lc'l BAT Industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 anuary 13, lst~s C·· 4 WBSlmO~nl ~llrl MOnlrU, CaPad~ H3t 288 R.W, Henchldy or Solicitor Tslephona· (514) 937 911 ~r~ ~.C, Brookee Telecogier: (514 9Jt4An company Secretary Tcltx: 05 24176 B.A~T. Industries pie jO Victoria street lPindsor House SH1H DNL Sirsl to my telephone conversation of yesterday with r. R. Henchley, please find enclosed copy of the made by Messrs, Crawlord and Mercier on gecelaber 19, 19881 1 x apologize for not having sent you copy of these two announcements stoner, rf IOU hbYe any questions roqPraing there annaunccmants, lease do nut hesitate to communicate with me, n Montcnlm osures ,3,: could you please send us an update at the orqanizatldn chart of both of secretarial and L~gal departments of B~A~T, indu9trios, BAT Industries document f6r Legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 r ~~cb ~t~ )ortd of Dirtc~a~l Imaxo Umltd Divieionel ch~~~6n r Preaidenra · Management Co~~rcw 4 Wanmoun~ Spu~n lmalco · foronto, gee lor~, ~m~~crdc~ Mono~~l, Canada · CCrPb'Ltl Canrn Hct~cl lolld H3~ 1SB Telephone; 15141937 B r LO, 1988 Tslccopcr: (511831~· BI~C~W Yet: 05 24176 am plaarsd to announce Lbe foll~vin~ appointPenla and the formation of an Operetiona ~110~1 Ct~it~ec effective Juluarf i, 19891 Jo~o·lol~l Mercier it appointed Vic~-Cb~irm~n of h~co li~iudl Jcan·l~uil will rataiP hil ongoing reaonaibilitiea ea Chairman and Chief exacurtve Officer af'fmptrinl Tobacco limited, ; gel CU~rtt and Torrance 4ric are appointed b~cutivs VI~~·AllldCPtl Of XIDLICO tiliTCd, ::i also continue their current rl~ponlibiliti~, for Corporate Finance and hblic ~ff rcapcctivtlJ~ Ref Schi~~r:~ vill plslMe rbe pP~lt~oa of SaDIDr Yie~·Pralidanr, Ia(ll lad CorpPare Dave 1"r"'' John aepnetr will join IPuaco limited u Senior Yic4·Preuideat within the Corporate Crlltre,lalld vlll a1a0 aaaume the poairicn of Chairean, PrPaidcnr and Chief lxacutlve I Office of Imaleo Plaancia1 Ccrpolatioo~ b...i created Operationa ddpi~orl cowaitreo will he c&iFcd bT Jeee-twia Mercier, and CI11 be IO~C OP of i pell Itoup cePsl~~~JII ol rha luder~ oi thr oplnrlnl Dlvl~lonl and txecurlve Ilic~·~ral~donrl of rauco to asaiat the Chairman of ~llc~ end the LPdcr, of thr ~pPrlting boupe in, among other things, continuing and building on the momentum achieved io date rwnrda rL objactive In our long gangs plan of greater prod~crivir~ fro~ ewl3llng .e ewP~t~v will nor f0Dltltlltl I defiaion ~~~n6 luthoritf~ gather, idsIa and bppor~unirrIt from the varioua operating aectosa of the ctpai~ltioa will be examinad and lliacusaad In depth, enabling I11 participants to benefit fra the ~d~iel ad clpcr~anc~ of iheir coll~lguee in the Lplole~tetlon of plPn~ to enhance the profitobilitl of corporate pelr~rion~/ in tall, C ctE:a focua of the Coelaittee will cm~tl on the continuing improvement of our pparat the appointmant of I Chief Operating Officer within the Cmtn is not Contemp Bovaver, in viewing the deliberationa of the group a be of the utPcat lmportance/ to the Cotporarion ae a whole, at Chairmen, Preaident end Chief Zxscutlve ''~'"" to be involved re an er olfiFio lae~blt 91 the Committea, Illcar 1 rirhljcm·~oui~ ao tbs CooIPittee Cbdaen, otber nwbera vifl he: David I'lcom · ChPiwn i CfO, I1l#o DNI petalling Group Jlclr Ishgh~rt~ · Chairman, ~rllldsnt i CEO, f~leo OS11 toe. I111 ~r~rLr · Preaidenr COO, Ltdll'~ pood S7Irln (deal~nPud by Mt, toughett) Morn btovskf · htsidoa t GID, Tbs M;S Group Eucu Yie~·~n~idlnrl of Im~lco 1MLldl Heaarl, &~ eu)att and Torrmca WJlie, 1 f an operating Iroup, who is on the Cc~ierll, hea been givan discretion to ignare ~nl additional officer from hla group to aenre on tL C~ieu~l ,,,I; BAT Industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 FRay 1999 A A ·2- P1 Ind ~lcrc~~rl~l t,~~ure~ within tbl eIntrI IndIliPiDIfI ~a dYPIICIEIOI PI eiIOll. wldlte of the rl~t~lceur~d LII'1~ CPrporItI ~lllplt CIIP 1111 hi 10 hi ~~ ~ Iad Jler~r~rill dlPI~~IPfll Yirb Ihl l01101 IItIbliIhin(l I IolI Ifi~clcn thlI ro~e Io~ lchvIrrr ulll rI(Iia hit onloiIl Ilc~~llblli:isl ~or rbP opc~l~iPn~ 1 ftPQ~tiPI to bL Ipd tar cctpotIrl DIVIloPPIn(l to ~q rcblrtl in rhlI POlitigp 1111 be IOPIP LDICIL - eOQO~I(I flelltlllt LEflMII · SIniOl COllllt Id ~C JObiq · KIIUlIr CorPOrItI PIVPlPPlIIPrl OP thOl( rrrr, r,~ltinl ~~ IhI iIIIco Ikleld lolrd oI Dinc~~r~, lo~n nonrell, 1, Coqerlrs r,tIrt till ce~unic~te Ilrctrlt virb mi, iIIuIl foPfrPntlnC Ioplrill flleco hnl btele e[ PIrIDOllnt Bpo~ace 10 thI CPtir PIPInr. ~~rctbn, Fwcurrln~ YIFh rbl Ibwa Ehm~l~l loy~r bchn vill be IppolnrId Ics·Prrli~ane Ind Oln~r~l Counlll plthia thIt atlIoltItlen II autlintd in the reeomp~n~ln u~clm~pr ~ra~ Jccn-louiI Hlrc~~r~ kL (tPPCtt JOIPI II fallowinl I IUOCIIIIU1 ~llrtl II 1 IInIPr IXI(UC$llilh icotll Hcll~d. ~ob hII been I buIlocIl rlIPeiIrl p(l p~lt ~! pIppl, virhin iIIIco Cbirld Io~ roII rl~l, rod vlll brin~ ~D hit nn poliFi~n In cxFIIIIivI blck(round in fin~n~i~llu rml. I gl ~~1 ~111.1 lr3PL ~~ r~lpon~ibllitl~l ui2hln auc nIv Yorlr oEllcI, lIIIco lold~~( Ine. hnl lxplndId /ilPifieIailf ui~hin thl pIlr Illr or rwD md hnl h~cM her~~~in~ flOInciIl!l ltiFntld. I hcoordinllJ, Iloyd Schnlll . V1CI-~fl~ldldE ~nd ClacrIl n~n~l~~ of thil affiel, currlatll ttPPltl ta Zhl tlr DCPI~TIIPZ ·i11 report dit,crl~ to ~ GOlI',t · ExIcurivI r~l~ihenr, Ch~l~ tlnInftIl Oiiiclr UId Itl~~lt~r, I~ICO tlOldingI iDC, lillpptllU( the corbor~td ol[iEe rer~~libla lot vIriouI llr11 LIIUII In th, Unie,d SLITII 1~1 On I1III~II IlOld sehnIllvill rlpot~ to le~ 5c~lrl~. ~1 IbovI PICPflll Ip)019t110tl TIPIIIIPf I IPICblF ItIlObt~dlC ~~hlp th( IIO1Dr r.l~lcrll ~ld~ oI our ealm~ I11 thl IltlJlilbll~ 01 1 bmrl~ ~~g MLbC Irovid~~ I cririclll7 Inpot~~PZ iOrnm far tbs sXchIP(I of ~1111?0~ COnetptl IPd ttrIlClliI t lorf ~~~~redl 1 will hInIl!t Ehl tOqOtltiOP II L lh0l1( il,rrl I joih It in CWltllPlltipl JI1P.Gil LTEIIT) I~ CU~llfl lorrUlPI qli(l ScLlrlt Ind logIr Ick~o on thIir nev ~p~oinr~n~l, Ind I1,6 In ullca~~ John I~M~~ tbI Iu/c~ linitId Irlaotirl yroopl 1 hrd) etPfotd Chinr, In~il~or Chilf ErIEutiwI Offictr BAf industries document for legal Services : Health Canada 21 May 1999 Ve ,, ,,r A A lqBi Tql ~rill ~~cr Vic~·)rl~idmt~ ~ Dirilim Irodo ~n ~· Ys~~s~~n~ Dlctlbor 191 1911 ~wn~~, i' C :~C 3L ~Y~ I~~, ~~mr dPleeaoala tht poot two or tbrll fllrlr r4"1~1 tob~fso, LPd the e(nodillo rbb~cee Indulr~~irlal~ hit wi~n~~~ld ~a ~PIICld~P~ld incr~ll( lp 1~111 i/ruas coln~Ci~ fron ~11 lash ot I~lmm~, 1~ ulll ~~ fra bu~in~~l ~~d public ~wreo~. rp ardct to oPIUtl thl CIIIPII~I I1Cflll Of our cqlql it hi) b,ar Ixerc~sl~ ~orrl~r rh~ ~1I1II~1 wstoro b~ ~ddrll~~d ~~dilc~l~, rlarsl~bll, ~a virh rh~ utOoot prPtc~~i~nlli~, ItcPrlllllfl I r 111~~16 LP LI~C( I& LPPOIP~IE DI lo)rr I. ~Lp tb thl pa~i~lo~ or Vic(-Prclidsnr Ipd Clnl~ll e~~l ol tho CoopLal. Thia lx?cucivl pPlltlon vill rlpare dlnstl) to tbe ~d~rli~td, ~pl 101"r vfli ~l~o ~~~~, reabershIp on thl I~lri~l ~b~cco n~o~l~Pr E~l~rls, IPC'P ho, pl~~ld o koI rolo ou sh, eOOodioo Bblcco Lnfrturlr~ Coulcil tpr ~c~cr~l Il~t~l ~d blo dills attl~i~llt, 0 our b~b~lf, with both arc~oc IDd rhl public Ilccpr oo o vida ronlo O[ 1IIo1 I,~ialptl, Balvsr, thl ~port~ac~, eapl~~t~, lod vol~l ~f thi~ ~t~itl ~LII it dparlt~l to bn, I hll·rBI Ilolor oliic~r oithla shl OTI~Dit~E10D dlrc~lll ~I)P6PI~II (Ot 111 11111 Ut~l~l IfflrIkg fhl eap~, ~t I~1CI1P( Rotor to ~alSiL1 fOboEcOl I CPII~~Cltlfl hlo )p thil ~ppdinrunl, vhicb will I~~( ~ifrr JI~~~ I,t, I~a~ lod lltoOd q ~,~ bios viohlo ~or rucc~ll to ~~ in thl~ cririulb ~6r~~le ~dlrt~~al, Jlro·hi, ~~eilr ~inl Qlti lucutlvO Ofiiclr BA~ industries document fer legal Senices : Health Canada 21 May 1999