I I~a ~~T~I11~ g~IBO~IEI~F~I~_~B~CCO _616166 This memorandum describes the current status, procedural n~aa,,. and likely impact of the geA study of enviromPaPtal tobacco smoke, mwarrr The gpoiranmaatal Protection Agency is artsatlf reviewing studies i:oncluding that HTf is a kowm human carcinogen, BP11 also map urge the sli~o~Pstion of involuntary uposure to BTS in r· the workplace, Tbe Igencg has op re9vlatery ~thorit~ in th~a area, as you know, but the fetla~l publication of its conclusions undoubtedly would have a major impact on agencies of federal, state and local governments that do have such authority', The impact threatens to lead to further restriction of smoking in offices and factories across the country, The industry is actively seakiag delay and moderation with respect to EpA'a action, TBB_~ XWIXII PI~S The EPA is reviewing various documents proposed for official issuance, pot example, the '86alth 13~feets of passive Gmoking' concludes that F~ is a 'Gtotlp L (known human) carcinogen', Another report, entitle 'F16 Guide to' workplace 8mokiag Policies", recommends that involuntary expoaure to 616 be eliminated, And the HPA is reviewing a related paper called the 'eompendium' on HIG, I": last year, the Agency submitted the Health klfecfs piper and its policy Guide to the BPA's 6cientific Advisory loud, The SAB accepted public co~ept and held hearings on December 415, 1990, The cigarette companies including B~W rubmitted artensitte coarments through The Tobacco Institute sad some of the companies fired individual papers, Independent scientists were invited to comment directly, The 6AB also received critical papers from more than 50 independent scientists at the industry's invitation and the industry presented scientific witnesses at the heating, There is reason to believe the MB is considering some fundamental revisions to the various papers and may recommend significant changes, Jt is now doubtful that the matter will BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 __I Plgs 2 L pot krorl ~i~'l ·~mtl~l odttle lt its Xpril rltia( bsosuso of dailrs in rlail~ lef·tilie ipput iroP pdpll chlrood atb s~tiPg ap tho sip p~ftiou, eongrsslmlo ~ Blilsy b~~ writtsn ape I,ttst nnd r~ writs Ipsin 1~~9 g to OPBP tbs PrOCIII q fbr 1MitfOlll industrl Ee~nent witb rsspset to tbo fwdamentlll~ diffsront absrsetst of tbs teisntifie tiY thst ~ b omsrping, Thsrs slso )ss kr ons UnProdUotits 0111 It L. ~UIlllllllrt I~ (P8nEbt klillll thst ~ tia of tbs r~~t~itl rsworkiop nndonnI ma~r arstinP ~~ tbs ~t~ has ~sl of gtsff mipbt rsiult in fsirst trsstmsnt on tbil fllW $ tbs ge in ~~r tbs t~l~D( of tbs B drift doepmsnts nl ~11 n oosr into tbs 8~ Ousrtsr of 1991, rIthsr ~~ eo~np ant 19 tho Ip~ bnP Mbn is It Islst ar 8lnos for tbs indnntrp to obtain I littlo pr, r bslsncs in tbs ultimsto produet, P~'~S ~18'1 IdbriQ to ~11~L tuot doMPmt~ ii Lr~ Ira ~ ststutory ditsetion to oonduot rssoIrch ~ to dissstainsto informstios shout 11I sspoets of iadoor sir ~11~~, hpsnq bit no srpliait r8ylltoV powar rsgsrding tobsceo #ke, lts ccpellsionsl hownsr, sro libb to bspo I iotcdol impset on I Plti~b Of Popstnmsnt Yilt, 89~ ~11, for 4~111 itclods bssltb dspat~ot~ It tbs lalt Iml of loesZ go~smmont wbo do bns tbs pawr to l~t ~~ag, in plrt, tL fares of tbs EPA conelpsto· will ea tra thsir tap6t~tioP in tbs nnws ~11 ~ thrwPb tbs ontind IPPPartits pronaunesmants of tbs Llgloo Gsnsrsl d tbs · latlon~l Pssssreb Couneil md otbsrl, Tho nsdis d~l prottids strong hasdlina support to tbs EPn documsatsl Tbs wfdslFrcportd affott of Philip Worris to insinsbts its rfsP r into tbs Geiantifie MPinorg losrd tbrougb tbs agpointnent of 'f~i6odb' scilntllts doubtloss bss ~b 11~ to tbs pressurs thlt tbs aeisntittt ~aniap an tbst bosrd tsal to c6r pp with 1 tiPginp andorsemsnt of tbs fPA drifts, I1 in iroaie fishion, tbs PhlliP Horris sffort Undoront tbs indUstrl's e03lliPt tlbt tbs daeh bid been stacled against it, lho Dcapltioall Gafs$ a asilth ~sna (O~) in the f~~r Dspsrtmsnt ptobbblJ wil~ bspin its preeadfnpi In 1991 to th$ tb ETS itsosl llltbougb tbls Igag bss bsa·~i,t os ETa in tbs past it is bound to sanas tbs Pnntinp moDsntum sssacistsd _ with th8 ~ t:adi8s lad tbs ittsndlnt msd!i ittsation, OsW proPlg~tss t~pPl~tio~, tbs tsstrictioos will bios i#dists nitionwids dffeetlnd cln to aids to Ippb ovon It tbs fsotorp la~ell lP tbs ~~ipl sristing ststs lid Ibest ~osttlcti6nt blp( ~t IWlild to fietorl prsplisss, lorkinp with tbs otbsr tobaeeo aolnpIniss Ind tbrouph Bacht, $anesr, wa ale tqin~ to mitiga~l bS~'s ultimlte regulatoq ~ction, BATCo document for Legal Services : Heath Canada 20 nay 1999 _~1~1 page 3 Congresswoman L~an Ilattfa has been named Gecretarr of Labor and map pf~e the ~nduatq a fair hearing ip thil` qlrd~ Thb EPA cd~clusf6ns, unless amended and re91led, else e',ll encourage state public health entities and stats OSHA's to fans ~m~~ing restrictions, in some states, those agencies may act before the federal OSHI completes its pn~caas~ For I - · stample, California could fit the I~A publications eaai~~ into its proposition 99 anti industry advertising campaign. in this regard, 666 Spencer is urging governor Iqilson to divert $10 million out of an estimated SrZO million in tobacco tax revenue from ~nti·tobaeeo education to prenatal care prograPs, mdustrp adoet#tiaa~, who lobbl'for tobacco bans at the state ( mb teal letrel, Ilnld~ see the gpa move at I big help lad they expect to create a prevalent public perception that gl6 causes lung cancar, Further ED~ action during 1991 threatens to 16116 additional impetus to tbs conviction that trclpethfng needs to he done, Tb6 sat~*tebaeco lobby certainly wilt try to persuade legislators rod other elected offieiala to move forward aggressively with more restrictive limitations on public and private aPoRIngI EP/dlb February 18, 1991 BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 I hrNzyJCi:~ cl-t d~rUnr ~dall Ile ? roo Prlriplll ~rl~lnteadd for dl t~~ of E~tei~ eorparltioao Id toll fot:- 1, hotleciol of tbs UorlhlrO :IJ~~I Id ~aa to Ir~irtC rcl6oos of pollutsots uriq dIlle to ths Pit, vstor, or clreb or its ilholit~lt~. Slfsguard hPbltJtl e rivsrl, l~r, Irloods, ecl~rP *nst od oce~~ od ~~IMle Eonerihtiq to thl gtsmhosle cffrct, depctlol of the oat Ilyi, scid tlk or ·of· 2. (UUIP1~11 II1 of XotoTd LPCI : ~b oItoiIbli dl of aoturol rsOourcoo, Itb I Ittr, 10~11 Id btlltll CoaOoroo poarsnsnblo rtr8 r~~o~c~ tbroogh offiOioot rl od ~cf~ ploooioIl bltcet dld~ta bbbltlt, ops oPoOLo 1Pd ~61~111, ~1 ptooonio8 Il0dbartitfe 31 ~&tiol Pod )~~ Pi bta : lttnloioo erc~tiol of rlll, clpcf~ll a~nrdn arte, Pod vhorstor losolblo tleF1~ oatstiala, Dlopooc of ·Its throosb #fa od ralpriblt +tLdl, I, ~( II( of I1Putf : Lh ma offott to cc airo·ca~lt rfl std IPoteinobll acrg ooureool ~a~t io $tot~ toorIJ officisoef Pod e~n~~on ~ our oporstioI, ~~11~ oOorg)r diic~) of PIOaPtl 1 ~0lrl or IC11. 5, ~I1 bl~t~ : InB111 enrir~s~ lc4b od oofotl r~b to oaplorsss 1d oIolmitioo io ~id I oyntl b a~lo~~ rfl toOhnoloIiss d opcrltioI ~ocd~sl Id bt bcig copstsntll )tcyrcd for soorgsooiso, 61 h~~ of Solo PTbd~EU Pod SonfoU : ICU PTodUCta Or Icnifel cht drlrioo I~iro~~ta ~pctl Id Its rls II ao~·~l ooo thr, ~fo· coplalrt of s~lrolr~l hplctl of prd#t~ or oorpfooo, 7, DoIDs ~)CWdg : bb te~pa~~ni~ for L~ · ooIP to tho CmirPat b IkioI svorf dfoa to tBlf rootors thl Imirormt ood CDPOUII prlOPI dllflllJ Iffectcdl I, I~Qo~~e I Di~elo~e to aplo~~l d b pdlic inOidootlr rll~tla to opr~tion~ that odoso CrmiroooCRtsl LD or pll hoslth 1Dd Uflt~ horsrdo, Dilclooe p~nti4 anilolcn~, hl~~ or ~lfat~ hsrsrdo paid bf operOtioas od tolcs po sctioP ~piblt llploycol ~o rlptt copdir~o~ tbot cralte 1 d~per 0 the ewialat or pie hc~eh ~ olfctt hr~rall b Y~·~ Incm wl luytn :knit ~I~ nlrel to iolloIot tlcll hlPCII111, 10 rdepr ood rOFort op ioolooortstioo, rd to oootain o proosoo to Iooto thlt the Bid Id eo 111 tlpt iPioned of Pod re foil) r~l~~l~l~ for ~miro~·ta Ilttct~. Ltlbli~h I ooolittss of tba bird dtl ra~pribilit~ for Imia#ntd offlirll ~e ons boord Inbar e~ifid to teyllnt Imi~o·lnla kt~ec~tll 10, Llllllllt Pod IPWI) ~f : Cetdutt Pob IJro' pdl~C r rPd ~~li-ealotiol of prolrcll in ~pl~mtiq thooO $inffplll rd 11 Eapl~$ dtb $r ~pplicJ1~ 1I1 Il1 roIulotlool tk0Plh0lt nrlddde opnlioPII Brt toIrd tBclf crrtloa of iDdspeod(nt emitooent8 oodit proced~a~ olaolstod ooooollt d Ids ndl~ble to the publiol 22ad lobnurl 1991 BATCo docum,nt Ir LoOal Olnkss : Hoolth Calldo 20 ral 198 12- Iha rce lolinc~l Chrtcr Bnrirpmentrl lr~ne~l~l i. Corporate priority : To recognise envircnoental ~aPageeat 08 aPPg the highest corporate priorities and as a Ireg detersisant to sustainable dcvclopcat; to establish policies, programs sad practices for conducting operations in a environmntally sound maDPer, 2. lntsgrated hnqplmt : To integrate these policies, ~ogra~es ad practices fully into each business as a essential elenent of I , nanageoent in all its fPactiona, 3. Roctu of 'lnprovaent : To continue to improve corporate policies, F~ogrlwl and sovironetotat performance, ra~og into accP~mt technical dmelopents, scientific uPdersraading, cope~cr needs and emoooig expectations, with legal regulations as a starting point; and to apply the 8alpe enviropsental criteria interpatioo~l~, a, psployeeldncatioa : To educate, train and motivate aplagceo to conduct their activities in an environsentally tvlanaible mnner, prior bHsaseat : To assess mviroPPental i~pact~ before starting a DCY activity or project and before decc~iaaiaaiog a facility or leaving I aitel L, products and S(rvices : To develop and provide products pr services that have no undue cn~iroP~cntal iPpact and are safe in their intended me, that are efficient in theft fOM~PtiOD Of energy and natural resources, end that cap by recycled, reused, or disposed of sadalfl i. E~W~U~u;hlrm~,Dila~r.dn~~dulf~. nVI.CI custooers, distributors and the public in the safe use, transportation, storage ad disposal of products provided; and to apply sinilar considerations to the provision of services, 8, pacilities ad Operations ; To develop, design and operate facilities and conduct activities taldng into consideration the efficient we of energy and Ipatcti~s, the sustainable we of renewable resources, the lialloatiop of adverse anvironoantal i~paet and mate generation, and the safe and responsible disposal of residual ~a~ste~. 91 lutltch : To conduct pr support research on the enviroeental !Ppacts 'of raw ~oteri~L, products, procesacs, e~iseions end wastes associated with the enterprise and on the ~eane Of dDi~isiPp such adverse inpacts, id, precautionary lpproach : To modify the Ip~nufacture, plbeting or use of products or services or the conduct of activities, consistent with scientific and technical understanding, to prevent seroos or irreversible environsental degradation, II~ Co~merPn mi SPp~llcll :m paace ~he ~dapliw of rLe principles by contractors acting on behalf of the enterprise, In enco;raging ad, where appropriate, tcgdring i~provaenta in their O practices to uh the consistent with those of the enterprise; and to ~3 encourage the wider adoption of these principles by euppliersl 11t1 i BATCo document for Legal Services : Heath Canada 20 May 1999 ~ .. . · ·· ··-·~· ,r·: , -...~·c- ·3- 12, ~lg hytldnul : m dacloy ad ~~h~, uhero liDoificant ~~PeQ dir, ·qtP$ ~epachcl~ pleoo is conjlctipn deh the aorgoool Ilniclt, rQAlt ~pt~rltir~ eod the 1#~ c~dt~, rccoailiq potortlol trsaehpundlrg iopoeto, 13, b~fet of rc8nolog : 10 coP~~lte to the trlloflr of Iffin#PralJ loJ reelle~ ood Irtaalt Ithodr rhrolholt the ~wrtl~ ad ~1~ Iectorl, 141 Q~kt~ to the baa ~t~ t To eootrlbuto to the dmolopat a pllle pliq ad to huolaoe, toff·hotd ad ~trta~~n~ ptgrra ad edlICotloOal Bitilttll thot YiU cphipce Il~oa~ elnrepeal ad ptoteetioll 15, DpcMeoo to er~ :I footer opoDoeoo ad dielogae dth rpLpl~ ad the pdlic, entioipetlog end roopoadtog to their eoPecn ahout the poteotial heardo J ~pct~ of operpttona, prdrtl, lpoteo or ~cniell, iooludiry thoee of ~1P~bo~V or glohrt ~ilnifieaell 161 C~li~nc~ ad L~~~I : To ~~~rl airo~n~ petfonace; to coodoct rcllr ~dro~a~ Ilitl ad aoeoloooto of capir~ wlth caff r~dm~rtl, hta t~rrat~ ad theoe prioeiplee; d p~riodePb to prorile eppropriate inforoetiol to the hoard of Yrrctorl, ehlreholdert, apoyal, the ~boriri~~ ad the ahlio, 1Y YaV')I ( BATCo document Lr Legal Services : Health Canada 20 lay 1899 PRINCIPLES 1. CorPornt, ariodv To rlcdgnlse snvbPnmental management as Ivneng the hip~urt cJrpdl priorities 8r~ a a key ds~nNnam ID surtbina~a dsvelopmsnt; to establish polidet, programmes and prrtlws for conducting 0psrrb~ol In an sndronmcnklly K#md manner. 1 Inllpra~sd maneaement To Inleprale these pouoies, orogrammeaand pra~n fully Into seen bwiness as an essential element of management tn all its fundjons, a, ~p~es5 or ImPtpvement To #Imirrrs to Ifnprrr~e eo~pote~e pdides, pmprMurrm and environmental psnwmane, laking Into ~cwunlbc~cal developments, ~d#ni6e understanding, consumer needs and #xmfiunay wrpePmtions, with Iseal mguiafions as a ttaNng point; and to apply the taame M~ohmenhl eri~e~a Int~matiw~lv, a. EmdOvCe educariPn To educate, uatn and mdivi~e employees to ronduttthe~ d~ses In an environmentally responsible manner, a Prior stFI#merR To assess envicnmnP impacts before ~a~t~ng a new Ic~y or project and beiore decommissioning a fbdlity or IbPving a s~e, Plodub and FervlFa~ fo develop and provlda products Or services that have no undue wi;Pnmen~ impad and are safe Intheir intended use, that w sllic~nt in Uleir consumption of energy and rstula~ resources, and hat can be recjded, reused, or diSPO~dd 018al~yl 7, Customer adrles To advise, end where re~ei~ant educate, customers, dislrlbulom and Vie Public in the safe use, transportation, storage and disposal ol p~Pd~ets provided; and to apply ~jmila~ cOnslderallons to ma pro~aion of ~afirca~ 1 Facilltica an_dnnesll6ns To devalap, design and cperale ~a#T~iu and eondud aet~vKkl taking into consideration the sf[ident use of energy end matsdals,lhs sustainable we ct renewable resources, the minimldwl of adverse environmantal Impact and waste generation, end me safe and nspcraiMe disposal al rsddul waal~~ a, e~l~Eh To conduct or s~pporl reseeroh on the er~iretlmsdal imoaas of raw matsria~, products, processes, emlsslpns and wastes associaled wRh the enle~t~s and on via means of minim~tng sucndverse impadr, 10~ Pt~ea~dlcn_erv apprpaen Te modr3r the menufaclore, marketing or we of produds or ~eFdcas or me oondlld of activities, consistent uiEh sdantfhe and ta~rj~e~ unda~landinp,to prevent sedas or Irrsva~sibls MuirDnrmnU degrads~os~ 11. Contractors end t~PD~la to promote Iha adoptkn of these pr;ndplas by conuedm adrg on behan or the enterprise, encouraging and, umars approprtate, requ~g Irr~owmenlr, in hir prsdees to make them Eoosi~nlwZh(hDI( 01 the er,leryif e; and to encourage b waer sdapfion or re prindples by slpplin. "-c' ~-.-- -~-- ~ -· ------ - -- - ----·---~1. ~O BATCo document for legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ·_ 12, Ermmsnew,omdna~ To devskp and maintain, ~t~n lipnEesnt newdl 31 ~ms~ancy p~parsdnsss p]Mr in eoniuneSon withVu amerOanoy u~ica~, nlsve9 auulaiit;as and the local CMlmUnity, r~oogFj~ing polwlil Irw~bo~ada~ bnpads~ 13~ trdnmrPlt~ndenuTo eorrtrlbule to 01a uanttar ot ~nvlronmu~t~j lavtd taohnolOW MQ management methods VlrOugh~ the indflrtrlal and pubic Wdbrt· 14, Contrfbulin to the eon~ona(od re Eo~ibvle to tha davalopmanl o( pub(ie poucy and to business, g6verm~ntal and I~povemmantal programmes wdadueatiDnai (nitiativaf thgl J e~hanee anv~onmanti~ awaraneu and protaetion, r5~ bDmna leronmnl To foster OPaIIWII and ~D~UI Yllh IMPIDyMI and the i Wa~~~panrla~~nap~no,ed· c~ncerm abouttha potantll hdzadg and impacts ol opwatiws, p~odue~r, water a senio#, ~dudblg there olt~a~bwndary wglobd rlpf3icanee, id. tamP1IM1P andtrPsrlins To maerwe snvirornnental pslfamtner; le eQnluEt rsgula~ ai~nmamal audits and arscstmlms of eompl~u 1 wmpany requiramenu, Cgd requi~msnlr and these prlndplar: and ps~bdie~y to provide : . approprlMe inbmu~on to the Board o~r~eclPn, ~hb~ahdden, empia~F, lha ~,ulhorf~ot~Fdthcpublic - -- CD --· BATCo document for legal Senrices : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ~3cx ~w~ fer ~ ~ -.~ Fehtyary, ~1 side~swm S~e! E(e~Bw ~me~e are ttR assets of Sfdestream $3)(8 rerhuXiaI ~t~irirg an a~ecd Qcup S~iYte3YI i, Rextl~ttP~_Reaukea~n~s -~~rm farm se d~r~ir~im cb ~Bd~ bj Sid~StR~ aaisirn is a reel r~Kaihilitv ieX ~G djbrre; this ails icr a ~Sasive Strabagy, 2~ E~a~o?tim C~xr~a~ties - 119inl a ~f~Jible sidesheam eaissicn as a d~ierentiatfrj3 fEi~aa of prc~cs; this ails i~ an Offesive strategy, Badmraa~B ~e~i~sirg PrsPm ~o~t IQgulatory Eblins samrmdirq Passive $okirg may ~ lerd to Solrattr ~w~s on tba sideJhm~ emissirn al dgarettes, ~D~tia~ this might ~ka the fOt~L C~ clasiricrt;m of cigafftt~ brards by sidestr~aP ~clfveriLs; later this aold o~alve iato rastrietias a~c~ as pe~a~itted mrdPa of tar ard niootina CT ellen to otter ~D~O! ~fdtt~ of t~i~t~ CP is the cb~i~s first eanlidata. At present there L rn aee~ted sta~ard nethol ed mPr-~ira sidestream deliveries brt Ceresta has a ~J~drg C~p tbat has a lPg te~p him of ac~intfrq stardardi~tim for ~en it is rm~dod, ~ has a gwJ mPthol ier rm~arrrrirq sid~t~mn ~od vs have a ~irl~ e~aerrrive set of data PI ~W deliveries are jrbluaced $ dnsian p3t~at8r5. F~ arsiderirq the ~8gula~mlr asFeY~ts i,e, the defensive Faritien m silnstream re~i~n, it rmst be stressed t~t ~at xill be ~zFe~I~ is the ~as~r~i~ emission of sidestre~ (particulate mater, nicotin! rm~ ca~n nmadde) I~neratrd bj s~nkin? t~ cigarettr. Ibe a~n~t rate of sidestre~m tar fc~a~ticn t~icf~ marifests itself as a da5ree ci visibili~ of the pllme, is r~t eb I~q~P~rPe tp I~egula~a~a~s, n Is, ty mrhast, the basis pi mad(etable dii~Ierentiated Eaemcts, Ibe te~lo~c~ nears 05 r~difiirq to~ sidestrea~iP ~ visible sidestre3p arm rmt the wme. B~~.T. COSiiDE~TI~1- CATiC'ORI~I: ~lf~jESOT~ TI)B~CCO LITIGA~C~ BAT~o document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 lhe ~eiash Sat~rFI ·.~~ridesaecn i03frtio s~ition i, a ~ ~t~i~ ci~et~ee desi~gs Fa~etc~ ge~P~ aidestltun~ iCPPbti~nl 1) ~kiF~xt ~ tc~arm ~xard, $a pe~awbilitu, t. a ba a Jllpte C~EI* pmpana cnahlfnJ sidatreae missiaa (~~ ~r ~ to ~ a~aP~i~a~d gh·Pn details d 'ej~arott~ ar~uctirn, 3, osirg this tariiltiey ~ delitt~ies dee an J IY nrm~iti~ brards can be Irived, l, ~ ~ws ~ t~u?re is Pariabflity in sides~ ImlJ d ~, acrdirq ~ 1 aPvey r~~ i yas aqDr ~ a a~tcic~ a de nct ha ~ ~ ~CBd; L att)eTS a c. C ~all a tq~dat~ fhis Infotaticn ts a ~et~ napetitcn ~1 staQqpl ~ this a), 5. lbe ~ E~eriarx b3 Ite Sh31S tbat tOtal Side5~6~P olrot L r~rd vithart a la cd Bddnl ~b~t~: tbis 1~ be rerirys at ~ or r ~ rsjlcbcn ~ dll hi LiPitatla! at b~i~er levels a rmre rzdieal dta~s in pe~3rt a noaled. plis vill Ll~ut ~al~np ~ itlll asxxa pIP~h1691 $fi~i Pafsibk Folicirs in nspect ~ side~s~e~am goissiers ~ ~ en~e ~hae: ti) a k P ~mls at ~ biFPect lovP1. srd~cr all 4 brar~ a lCa than 4 CZ~q~QtftiM bra~f~. apyc~ (~) a sball ha a, F~Pbably airar, ~aard t ~ lonst Fe~iticn, ze~in aaftnt pesitirn ba ~ ~ a Ixsitiat bs ~ charges te$Plically i n#d~d I all cases, it is s#rmwrded ~ srm]drq ~ali~l 3 rat be i~airea in aaiwirg b target. b a plliq, it is b reee~Pd ~ a It ~ attentifn ci ectesral b~dir9 (~ael~dirq c~pet~c-icn) to L ~t~ata~n~ pnapd in irdivirhal cantries. L a iir~ step, it is rec~erded ~ BaJ, Ge~any d BF~I~I(E ~ a~cpd tc Qvel~p Inc~t~ dlerq the agnel guidclir~ ts etabli~ L ~ pld~ity/sidestre~P red~tia! relat~nr~hie e fa thsir p~hrt ~~ B~~~T. CO~FIDEXTIAl - CA~GORY E bn~iSDT~ fOBACCO 1I~G~~O~ BATCo document k~ legal Services : Heath Canada 20 May 1999 ~ O~ab~ St~atlW - ~ ~~r~ide~Jt~egl Ctffotitis St~s Ihero r beem ~ attempts bl cloq~etit~ ts lmrch a baard ~ L visible fic'i~trea~P a its ]reY fe~t~ak 'WssFdc, ~t~ b Ih~t~ars ir Carada in 1983 ~J~ilo~ a tbe gra~s eS Im~o~eptable ta~te, Il~e~Prctly 1 12PP~Bj P~mtage ~3321; this ~ ~ visible Eides~a~ te~u~t~m Y bas g tl ~t~e~m wJ r ~axEPls~n~l in tbe ~ m~k3t. VirgiPia SL1IFe ·wmli rezntly Imrdwd t ~ ~ces 1 ~elera#t tp ~I la ~pk3 ttcm ~ lit dl it C~BNY bss (,21 n~ado?t st~nn in 8 ~'I PPSltll~ B~scd a ~I~ier ~ttmpt~ tm deA3xp Ib visible sidcs~ean~ p~c~et (Initalty thmuF~ I~IXE ~ later thrc~ srolr) r kw ~ tedaalo~iral c~allaqeJ ard L ~ iwrs ~rma~dirg ptomu~ c~a~s: ~ also ~ tbat tbere is veFj Little, ill 1, 'tz~d~ott' that mwmprs vill orreje in cr~nntiasl stm~ud~ ei taste C, tO annnmktp 1~D~t ~ hidl~ otfetz; ber~its to ottrers rat~er tban hlnsali, ~ trd~dn~nldal )gy ts bvidble ~ides~ezrm ~tJ ~ ~ a d rsw71~1 C~ette paEer· 1 vo~Anl in ~l~aat;a Witb L ~t~it im PralJL, ij~RII. ba dCYC1~ZBd ~ I~tCl~d 1 spcrlnr paFPr baela a t~a~biratirn ~ wp/Qm, as Eiller, h ac~j~tives ~ g lcv PPPr rranaahiiftg. ~irnssias vitt de ~mrh~lt P td~ ~ a4P1Y ct this papr a wcLl aava~ed ~ P~a~r~psl E~ar~itg Dcpartnmt. Ro~b~ts cabt~tPd ~ a e~binati~n cd this paper 1 ~ trbmP cei~t @i~ c~ardsl) give ~E~lh~, toQI si~estream (~~ neattvo to ~ mtra ~llld) a veil a b visihill'ell tbei ~ ~ Ir~f~ptahle taste a ash c~arr~ter based ~ 'irrtrrrso' parts. 1~ ~ ~ a palltrjve ar~ ~ ~ i Frarrx, teTcirq L FP~nh~t ~ varitus c~mani~dtipl ~x~epts, plis vill be ioUeJed 4 laref! sale p~tltative rmnm~ test m~ket a tfr FPcd~t~ n~ae S~at~nics Ch? rd tbe ~ ~s;ues ha is ~hetber the ~rep is prpparel tO 'qo p;rmic' a & ~idestze~ iea~res d a FPI~Y;tE. Irtritably 1 Wtlatiw vill thrc~ 1 questiers Y in rolaticn tO & a~i~e Ip~Ct d tO all a Qt~ F~OS;tS. ~I ard Ilpt~ at d~ttr~nt tlms a to baM cmsed this ~eibp Y we bave · dire~t irsj~t into tbe issue~ tbey ~sa~3, Is~tbet ajer Issr is ~het~ the troet E~IY ~Rmts ~ a Folc~t~t. To date F~o~t~ ~ead~t~irq tbe test market (F~thmarr;, LJ.L) bave ~ prJr ~ality ard give ~ base ~ as~esslq ~ ~ p~etrtiat. pr? fee~dr ~ tbe Itrials ~ Franx ~ ~ b~phtl in tbis regard. ~Ef/se o 1~ Fcbtuari 1991 N R~T ~O~FfDE~TIAl· CA~~OR~ I: ~B~ESOT~ TOBXCCO IlncArros BATCo document for legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ·· I'3b Tc~aan S~ate~FI Raviea ~ 1~ Ee~S~awrr, 19111 ~d~ti~lP~nd~ct I~aapister i, ~eP~tati~n is rar held ~ all zupecd B~. d ~ rr~e~nl~ (a~veri~ a oxmMes), ~L~~~ Tom, Phintdued ~m~ seaae mditias. Tc~w~o additive drmwtati~n, ircl~birg legal stz~a, is I I e~uter data base d o3ded seoai~ broa~c;~ pwe~t wy lihility ci direct captter EPirlc ~ · an identiliable branj basis. Ileliarce eentinuc~ cn 1~ A~i~Y details el irdivi~al, additive coqositla en their f~rmlatit~8 for legal nwxls. i. ~kSI limitatias cf tbe data irc~: (i) 3 ~Cb, c~mpa~os yet to sqply data plo~x~ts sold, M ~ m3s~facb~rr~ a C~wp nn~nl~, (m) c~anie~ Inwi~sly speciilealty e~e~ded i the SLWeYI 119· Ce~Bt~ ~ainl rPateria~ in ~ss ad c~pletidn ol ~~c~nr~nt d data sqplied ~ ~B d Germ~J. ~datin3 of anrent records ~ be prc~pt~8d ~1 d~ilm letter to C~e~atirq O~panies in ~ t Pxlth. f~ ~JIPCil)ll dtau attertticn ~ tbe reed te idr~i~j ~ pro~ts mar)cetfd ~ caplanies, rat just Parufacb~e~. q, lit this stage the F~iQit~ is to o~pleta these rerminirg details ~ the ~i~iMsrPre~Eb~Z Register. lh5 will be filllc~ed bY ~a~irg coverage to ct~ E~cd~ AZlp33~t~S. ~q/SC icth Febntary, 1991 B~Co document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999