CONSUMER RESPONSE TO ASH QUALITY BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 t W O ~3 )(n z Z 3 8W O OP 13 W W 0, ZW 3 20 W m r OO WFr 31 bn ~I W O ZI O Q O 3 I a Od O w 08 Z ~I O W a O az ZI Z O PO ~W mt3 W O O 2 P W o~ o:' ~O ~pZ W ElATCo document for legal Services : Health Canada 20 ray 1999 (3 > O 2 d a ,I 2 W O P O O 3 m P O O 2 C Z m O Z Z O a P Q O W W 3 Oze 2 z r O c a ms c3 m en r P I U O L e f t m O ze 6 52 21 t O rr (o O O Wt ~(Wb P C W C t· > c o s e er e ~~ Ow ZWa w at P " " cb O ~w C o z0 rI O 2 n w ( Ut (g ~P3 W 90 L2 PO~ ~I BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 W~ re o, z · a · a o w0 Z I- 3 O a O i- $ 5: LL P P 3 I " P ~n Ov, 3 Z Z 111 ~ ro u, a u, a. m I, z rr U rr z rr O rr i~ a a IL1 a W· W t~ Or" Wr It o p W qO O ~ O w 51 LLI ~Z I- ef re 9· ~ w P:V1 u. W V) ~ V1 W Q a a a a a > a ~ i W W 3 O 3 W P: Oer .ao~0aw5m a a > 0~ > ~z S W I~ w P~' WU, U. WW v, Z -I a Ip )10 L11 J t~l o 5 ~ LL ~ T ' u. 3 O O ~le ~~ ~lr ~~ mi] 33 y)[l p] o a O a a a a ra =1 3 ~p O O O O 17 3 .W Dc P: [e z L1 (1 L1 (3 O i~ O t: cu ~ BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 V) Zw 3 dn~n 3~ mlIu: o:IL ICd O W P i: er ZGct m a r c3 Zg II Od ti "o 00 u,,U "10 ~>I=1 W ;Z O 211 U, i-i- Z I Crl I! "z LLIO~ ea z (3 E· O 10 C1 01(; mJ0 u. ~O~LU'W -]WgleZ i d 5 ~ Q P Z IQWCrJ E· W 0ir w v, a-i C: 0 0: ~ IL ?1(6 ~O 2) rrlm wla OO zlz" Y g ~Idl r 111O L] ~·I ~~ IWX OZ[L~Crr(lll: II ~xw: S: wl~ 3~111 >d w uwS >·> P,O t,O,V) 10 O Z I~ C: 03d b~ i~lT 07 ~ talc ~~Oln~ fill~ m eel I- e dr Iw m cc Zd~V11L Qu. Og~ bollu W 4141041; OZ a ~~ZLL]1D 31=]10 f~ 00 010 > IPII] O (P1 V) W M a, W)I a w d~ flW2 c~l (i) UiLelll (lid 110-1 Z aO ~1~ W Orr, V] ;! Od O rrz U BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ~ap tW ~1'10(Q t 9' O d d b) dl~ldz dldlaid d cJ w u a] dldlf d to it dlw O i 1 t w kldli a a e o o 31 id i Pt 4 w fl~ tit Q i D O Z$J ~o o o a 3,0,b,P,Q a IO " " m bs Z10 w Wo a t~ P w V) WWr O O O I a ~m :I~l~if P t t 3Z a d o oZ d w m QW~a W wllLlO ma D 1 P W O ~l~lo~ cvl m LlI I I I to aia o olslg ~s a O a O QI~ >1~31 " ~IZ '100 O O i .( t P alZ olo Pt t~le t ~10 N n ~a PI I EI ~10 d Z 010101Q O Pi w mlm1~16 ro j n WZ ~Z pO m P C b Q 0 N ( Z Z0lr r IOtP > o a a wt rl~e p w13w o I bC rlolbll a e RlrIlOllmU P W V) 0 olcIOlo o a 014( ~lal , a ~rm~ x~ ~~ U ~l~lmlm c3 d C (1(1(1~ ( (. c O Q 7 r t3ATCo d6cument for Legal Senicea : Heagh Canada 20 May 1999 PRODUCT CBUALITY HBEFIACM`I' FAIDDLE TAR FEFnAbES TASTE BURN RAfi PACXlkdG (FIRMNESS) TOBACCO LOSS FILTER h;EEL (SIDESTREA~) SMOKE SIVIE1L BURNING E~D FALLIOU~ ASH QUALITY PACKAGING (FUNCTIOPa/APPEARANCEj MIDDLE TBR Pol4A1ES F1AYOUR BURP~ RATE HARSH~ESSICOUGH FIRMNESS .L11 E~D FAL1IOUT ASH STABI1ITY TOBACCO FAL1-~OUT PACKAGING (FUNCTION) BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 PRODUCT QUKITY HIERARC~ - -- ----- LOW TAR FEMALES fHROAT EFFECT BURW RATE ASH SfABIIITY AMOUWT OF SYOKE (SIDES~RE~Y) PACKING (FIRYNESS) FILTER PAPER (APPEARAHCE/FEEI) PACKAGIHG (FUHCTIOH~PPEARAWCE) LOW TAR YALES FIIIING COWSISTENCY flRM#ESS/100SEHESS TASTE FI1~~R TIP COLLAPSE SPE~D OF BURN ASH FALLIOFF PACKAGIHG (FUHCTIOH) SEIM PUIUTY (TOBACCO ROO) B~Co document for legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 PR08UG"T QUALITY AGGREGATE LISTING TASTEIFLAVOURIHARSH~ESS BURP\I RATE FIR~NESS ASH QUALITY PAC#AGI NG ENDS FALLIOUT COAL FALLIOUT FILTER COLLAPSE SIDES~REAM AWIOUNT/AROMA SEAM QUALITY BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 urce rrw C1 Z O Q P: O~ r O Oa v, C3 W a o wce 2 a OC~ Ct Z O L11 4 aZ j: O 13, 11] 3 Ommz ;1, Z d O Q W er w >Icr, u, z 9 O Z O ct 5 z w er: 1'0OC o z- g~ O V] V)~ Oirj (r) q o > I P II V) Z ~J W~ 11 Vi Q~ W LI~W I-DU)~ O q c co ul Z Y V111S pill. 3 UI Z II] O P: 5 OlllV) Z ~gw~ ~cccn 3 C3 d: I VI I I- zmO e~t V) 111 Za 1 O [rZ C~W a g W" Z r& re W O ao V) vl~J 0 0111 Q C SP Z tit P r O~ OPOO Si·u 00 mOO L?I F: ti BATCo document for legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ASH VOCABULARY I~IDD1E TAR FEPAA1ES COLOUR FLBXINESS EASE OF FLICK PREDICTABILITY OF FALIIOFF COMPACTNESS FRILLING' EIJE~NESS OF BURM SOLIDMESSIENCAPSULATION 1591DDhE TAR P~ALES COLOUR STABILITY PO\klDERINESS FLAKINESS BURM IINE EVENNESS PREFERENCE BAT~o document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ASH VOCABULARY LOW TAR FEYA1ES COLOUR EVENNESS OF BURW POWDERINESS FLAKINESS FLI CKABIL~TY CANDLE EFFECT LIKING 10W TAR YAIES COLOUR BURN II~E ~VE~#ESS F~AKY APPEARANCE F1AKE FAIL TOTAl DROPIOFF (ASH) ENC1OSURE OVERAL1 tl#l#G BATCo document for legal Senleea : Heath Canada 20 May 1999 ASa QUALITY PANEL TERMS ANO DEFINITIONS I COLOUR I The predominant impression of shade of the ash~ In the case of candle effect ash, the exterior colour should be judged. Evaluated on a lignE;hark scale. i BUAEI LIME jBUAN~1IMEI The extent to which the burn line Is even as i nspected around the circumference of the cigarette or whether some parts of the burn line advance more rapidly than others, Evaluated on an even-uneven scale, ( TEXTURE ITEXTURE The apparent texture of the ash by visual inspection in terms of relative coarseness and coherence of the particles, Evaluated on a compact·flaky scale. I 111X[ FAIIFLAKE FALL ) The extent to which particles of ash detach from the main ash while smoking. Evaluated on a low·high scale. I Ara FALLJ The degre· of ~rematuritS~ and unpredi cttbi i i ty ii th which the whole ash detaches itself from the cigarette. Evaluated on a predictabte-unpredictable scale~ i P~El BACX FRILLINGI : The extent to which paper ash at the burn line curls outward and backward forming a frilled/feray appearance~ Evaluated on a low·high scale. i CAIO1E EFFECT / The extent to which the paver ash remains entire and separate from the tobacco ash, forming a tube or sleeve enclosing the ash assembly, Evaluated on a low·high scale. I FLiCKABILInl Having got to the ashtray, how easy the ash is to tap off, leaving a neat burning end to the cigarette. Evaluated on an easy-hard scale~ I OVtRkLLIUAllnlOYfRALL QUALI~ An integrating judgement evaluated on a good ash · poor dsh scale, BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ASH ATTRIBUTES IYPORTAHCE HIERARCHY F1AKE FAL~ ASH FALI FtlCKABIIITY PEELIBACK BURN LIHE EV~##ESS TEXTURE CAWDLE EFFECT COLOUR BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ASH QUALITY PA1IEL SCORE SHEIT NRnEI·I)III(1··I(III111·11(1111(11(11 I I I-I I I I I I LIGHT I I I III I I I I DARK CCtOUR i I c~ ~[ I I I I I I BURN LINE EYEN i I I I I I I I I_ I UNEYEH II I I(l[jl I TEXTURE COMPACT I I I i I I I I I FLAKY FLAKE FALL LOV I I I I I i I I I HIGH PREDICT- I I I I I I I i I UNPRg:::· ASH FALL ABLE I I I I I I I ABLE PEEL BACK I I 1 I 1 I I -I FRILLING LOU I I I I I I I I j HIGil [~ I I I I 1 i I "IANDLE EFFECT HIGH I I I ~~II i I I I I 1 FLICKABrLItY EASY I I I / I I ( I I I HARD 6000 1 I I I 1 I I I I POOR OYERAL1 pUklIiY ASH I 1 I I I I I A~H BA~Co document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 mf r~ i ~y,~ d $~~t30 I IgOrSo mr 8 w8'd mOrmco I I II q4IrJyu W W~dZ Sim ,s > 0?P~r~r m bmOb m Ompo~a( mmtm0000 tmoo 3 p ·; a I\ : G; I i 3 ----- Y q wLrI d4 4irtw y P a to~tftu3 r PL IrQWdnow u (C 3~m Z O au~~~, U tyxer C ~dP ~IZ r ~T~~oe 0~3 d o m a O '"J c3 O B~Co document for legal Services : Heath Canada 20 May 1999 CONSUER RESPONSE TO ASH QUALITY BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 Z W W O w z u] tll I? =3 Q ct d a O O~e L1. tl, bbl )Ier w3 a u 6g >1 5O W Op II~ O W ~Ic an w wv, O nl 8 i~rr, o ~3 mP ]6 nO~O O ag: ill (J) oo, z I! CrJ~ V)W: O ~1 P· 8 a (3z ~rrurcr, al I- u, E· E· o aO wocJr wJ mZ i5 O o 3 wPer: v,uzw Zv, d OI Our LI W ee P: BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 Yay 1999 (3 o 3 O C c C W IX: W d O n > O Q I m a a: o a z c~ c w z d (n O Z O C d a tL 4 O W ate z Z P3,~ mr a e e c u O F n Zb 0 d ~3 3P Z O rr (o O $ O Wt ~(W( f P L > > o a 4 c wamlwb a ~P 01 all UI Pt W O O P W 5 3 O 2a wI 0 O Z e O W ( Wa Qo ma " 00 03 pOc BATCo document for legal Senlces : Health Canada 20 May 1999 L?I Z P: r r O O UO 2 C 3 O a O 40 C I C Z I~ P 3 p 3 Z O r o~ 3 ·~ O~ Omo~ O. (n I, ta OazeeOa Ow p OW· W I wr c O oY (O O O ZZ O Ou a U CI ~2cB c g. (e a (D < 0 6 a LL O .p a a a a > p ~ I W J V) 'PO aOPW 3 O > 6> > rz a w s~ w Pt IU ac w V)Z d a ~PqP U O P~t~ n 3 ·O O ·r cn U n d b a O 3 3 3 IP O O O O d t t t ,, z d O d O a 0' BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 LC ~w Cr)llS ml~F ,LL eCe7J O 5· W P HELP I W ce z ;t~lp? a rr zg V) OQ Q rn ~Z tr O 00 VI F·O ~[O ~r13 Ill ZOI--I t ~(rj Z ~Z LL~lOc: pa Z O 10 P 010 E· m(0 O~~r,er IL ~ 0 qWI~ -]W BIQZ i- P Z ix O d Z1Bwv, F. W 03 w ro SJ3 oee Zu. rlll ~o 3 alcl w (I a: Cl~l~p OOZZ G aU~ Oz -Ina: re ~xwcnim a: ~1111 >W >b btllO LII~ Ir) L11 ce a ,o a:a]T h (g Z Im s sit o G -'Ile W re Q1~ O 3 P V) o rJ MP LLI m aZ~ul ~111 ~1L O fiGdInl;u W C"lOdi; 020~B2Wg ,I~lO~lf 002 co O~lal>nl ~ ~o u, L11 M P, L~S· 13 t~~ "IW r reW h~ UI W~b (Il-p C10~ n GI cn Z 4, O c t~ c (3v, G m3 u] w Z oa o o CCZ o " BA'TCo document for legal Services : Health Canada 20 Nlay 1999 ~bP C~ I" W tlflOl~ t t 0 t P> dl~ldlhi Idldl~ld d > PW J W u w C d 'dla ( d d 3 ~ala a> d d d I~ P c c,~ 00 olT z flfld Z i r i P O 2$IQ o O P 0 3,0,0,0,0 o a Do m D m ,i ZIO u WO "0 u UW c a a N t O 4 alal~l~ t t t N n 330 O o 05 O V)P W ~4 D ao, b W W IrlO c r~ Z P ~~ale,(l o e LU a Dicic 3 01 I I 0 olmle ~e c 0 O ~lw ~1~51 P 61~ Ug a 31 11 I I I ~I llu-II elZ olol i I I I I I ~ o c nlW ~B ol I I IE ~10 h Z 0101010 O i w mlmiole m j A WZ N2 pO a a a a C O 9e Z Zgl' r 3 o > P 0 0 W uz C(~r 0 w13u d 3 ~a *IRlil~ a O ~ITElOrlmU P w a O 0101010 a 0 a ela( Nlm~ X~I~~ I (U 0101010 8 d d 'I rltlcle ( ( ( ( ~lme o31 I I I I I I I I " 1 r BATCo document for Legal Services : Heath Canada 20 May 1999 PRODUCT QUALITY HIERACHY MIDD1E PAR FEMA1ES TASTE BURW RATE PACKI#G (FIRM#ESS) TOBACCO 'LOSS FILTER FEEl (S~DES~REAY) SMOKE SYELL B~RHING END FA1LIOUf ASH QUALITY PACKAGIHG (FUWCTION~PPEARAHCE) YIDD1E TAR WAIES FLAVOUR BURM RATE HARSHPIESS/COUGH FIRPjlPdESS .LIT ~WD FALL·OUT ASH STABILITY TOBACCO FA1I~OUT PACKAGI#G (FUMCTION) B~Co document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 PRODUCT QUKm HIERARCHY 10W TAR FEYA1ES ~HROAT EFFECT BURH RATE ASH STABILlfY AYOUWT OF SUOKE (SIDESTRE~Y) PACKI#G (FIRMNESS) FI1TER PAPER (APPEARANCEIFEEl) PACKAGl N G (FUNCTI ON~PP EARAH CE) 10W TAR YA1ES FILII#G COHSIS~ENCY FIRYNESS/100SENESS TAST~ FI1TER TIP CO LLAP SE SPEED OF BURN ASH FA11IOFF PAC~AG1NG (FUNCTION) SEAM OUiUIY ~OBICCO ROOi BATCo document for legal Servicea : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ~e~·c~-"~~ PRODUCT QUALITY AQQR~GATE USIHG TASIEIFLAYOURIHARSHHESS BURN RATE FIRYNESS ASH QUA1IIY PACKAGIHG EHDS FA1L~OUT COAI FA1LIOUT FILTER CO11APSE SIDESTREAY AFAOUNT/AROMA SEAM QUAIITY BATCo daeument for legal Servioes : Health Canada 20 May 1999 w e: c p I- rr Z O B aw to O P O O r 3 3 P O O Z O T O a w Om m z z d O O w z t .O z 5 w z w ~aoa ,,I gm (u z- 0( O I aqo> rP J 5 Z ,ru: W LW ~POb O O r a Y ~u W Z O Z OW~Y~Z Z O ~Ow~ Z~o 3w Y r O 6 2 L ~1 Z m uaSb O F 71 P W' Z Z I> o (b : : 5~ O' w e w O P O r rP Z o~ o~,o oa I5~o noo B~Co doeument kr legal %enlces : Helnh Canada 20 Ysy ~999 ASH WOCABULAWY P~IDD1E TAR FEPAALES COLOUR FLAKINESS EASE OF F1IC# PREDICTABILITY OF FALL-OFF COMPACTNESS FRILLING' EI(E~NESS OF BURM SOUDMESSIENCAPSULATION MIIDDLE TAR P61A1ES COLOUR STABILITY PO\BVDERIIPIESS FLAKINESS BURH LINE EVENNESS PREFERENCE BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ASH VOCABULARY LOW TAR FEiF~AIES COLOUR EVENPIESS O~ BUW~ POWDERINESS FLAKINESS FLICKABltlTY CAFPD1E EFFECT LIKING LOW TAR FI~AIES COLOUR BURN LINE EVENNESS F1P\KY APPEARANCE FLAKE FALI. TOTAL DROPIOFF (ASH) ENCLOSURE OVEPIA1I LIKING BATCo document for legal Senrices : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ASH QUALITY PANEL TERMS A110 OEFINITIONS I coun7 T~e predoinant impresiioa of shade of the ash. In the case of candle effect ash, the exterior colour should be judged. Evaluated on a lighr·aarr scale. I JIIRU L~ij The extent to which the burn line is even as Inspected around the circumference of the cigarette or whether s;~e parts 3f the burn line advance more rapidly than others, Evaluated on an even·uneven scale, TEXTURE The apparent texture of the ash by visual inspecti on in terms of relative coarseness and coherence of the particies~ Evaluated on a compact-flaky scale~ ilsr ;111IFLAKE Fdll I The extent to which particles of ash detach from the main ash while smoking. Evaluated on a Icw·high scale. I AS;( FALL/ The degree 61 prematurity and unprediaability vith which the Whole ash detaches itself from the cigarette. Evaluated on a predictable·unpredictable scate~ I PEEL BACX FRILIIIIGI : The extent to which paler ash at the burn line curll Outard and backward forming a frilled/feray appearance. Evaluated on a low-h:gh scale, I csci~ EiillT 1CANDLE EFFECT I The extent to which the paper ash remains entire and separate from the tobacco ash, forming a tube or sleave enclosing the ash assembly, Evaluated on a Tow·high scale. / :ircxAnllln /F1ICXAOILIIYI : Having got to the ashtray, how easy the ash is to tap off, leaving a neat burning end to the cigarette. Evaluated on an easy·hard scale, I giiuu allnln(OVERALL OUALITI I An i ntegrati ng judgement evaluated on a good ash - poor ash scale. BATCo document for Legal Senrices : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ~ ASH ATTRIBUTES IBd~PCBRTBN@E HIERARCHY FLAKE Fall ASH FALI FLICKABIII~Y PEE1IE3ACK BURN LINE E~ENPI~ESS TZX~UFIE CANDLE EFFECT COLOUR BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 ASH QUALITY PANEL SCORE SHEET NAMEIII·II)I·IIIIII11)111111··1111111 I I I ~ i I I I~ I I COLOUR LIGHT I DARK I 1 I / I I / I BURN LINE EYEN i I I I I i I t UWEYEN j I- i i I I I I TEXTURE COMPACT I I I I I I I j FLAKY i I I I I i ]- I I j FLAKE FALL IOW I i I i I I I HIGH PREDICI· I I I I i I I j UNPREOICT· ASH FALL ABLE I I I I I I I I I i ABLE PEEL BACK i I I I I I I I FRILLING LOU I I I I I I I I_JHIGH I I I I I I I I I I CANDLE EFFECT HIGH I I I t I I I I I LOU I 1 11111)1 1 F1ICKABrlI'TY EASY I I ) i ) I ) I I I HARD 6000 1 I I I I i I POOR OYERAL1 9UAL In ASH 1 I I ~I I t I I I I ASH BATCo document for legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999 V)O I(3 ZO r WQOZg W G rQImr I w ~-O O Y[I Q O 'O O (1 O~a rmNm oYYI1W~rl tSi II II Il it ~Z~tCCIL~ WIL13I ~Z~-lcye -I _1 a u~x dl a O~W~W~~ z V1n(01 UmPO~LL~ Q 00010 U Clmr[CJ W \ I II II `T\ II II II Il F: ~I ~moa J a w a 4 IL "; CI (3 ~1 I w cn Q dmr~r~xzw Y t~ ~ ILa: Za u.w·IL IV]W WqW UI ~n: 3 Ym 2 wJ zaylu a ~O o D 3gw z c 2 ~4~P[T 0 C LL33 U O a BATCo document for Legal Services : Health Canada 20 May 1999