C:?'.LLC,fZ v. :'fC. 3.3-M.14
1. San plainti:: pr-zqn all at the *182ant3
Mecassary t:
establialh :rsudultn% 2is:o9rasentation or
czacnalzont by
de!sndan-. Liqqett, ;rl*r %a 104S, of saterial.
fac--3
c*ncsrn-'~q a iqni ficar-t Nheal :h rina
&sacciatsd wit-t
Y42 W.
nag plainti!! Proven all of the elements
Asasssa.-t t--
!.tabil.sh irsudulant misrepresentation by
Xo=is, prior to lidd, of matarial facts ftnc4n,
!Aq
2 iqni!i:3At hSalth risk& amiaCiAt3d Vl'-'.
glq&7*tt*
Yes- No X
2. Has plsinti!f proven all of the els2ents
n;cassary to
establish fraudulent misrepresentation by 44,
prior to 1966, at j&t*rj&j facti etmearni-q
r-*3AS 4413004at6d 'Witt
Yes- NO
4 a conspiracy prior to 1266 to ftaUdUlantly
a.- andl:: Czncgal material facts ccncsrn.-4w
n
!health risks associated with cigazetza sxaXinq?
t
Yea- X0
6. If Y" kn8werld 'yes " to TAOS%i*n 14, Vert any
of tha
defendants atzben a! that conspiracy?
Croup, Inc. yen we
Philip xOrris I.-Ictrparatad yes- we
t4 rillard, 13c. Yes- X0
Z! answered 'yea' Itz q%ssticil nu"er 5, Us
Sint i proven all of the t1suants necessary to
establish
fraudulsmt a1sropresentation or concxalzent, prior
to 1966,
by any zember of the z*nspiracy?
Yes- go
EXHIBIT '2 (N.)
BAT Industries document for Province of British
Columbia 5 November 1999


7, 3hzc!d Llqqem ;rizr tz !)46, have warnad
ccnsa3er%
regard-,:tq hatit-h ri3~u ob, asoxing?
Yea Wo-
YCU answers'd lyss, tz Cr4*St1:n 7, was t:tat
:&!lure
t-z varn ;riar tz 1.264 a pr*xilzate cause a.'
&-'I or Sam: at
Xrs. cipallond's
yas-Y. No-
S. :! ycu answered OyssO to Tz*a*.L= 1, Vas Suah.
xackjr4 a
przxi.lats cauS4 of X-.3. cipollane's lung carica:
and
Yes\
4 No
you ans-wered lyasO ta question 9, did 03.
Cipollone
voluntarily and un:sasonably encounter a knotm
danger by
Snaking cigars%zas?
YSSY- ma-
il. Z: you ansv4r*d Oyes* to question 10, was this
conduct
by Xr2. Cipollone a pr*xl=aza eausa of her lung
cancer and
dest.10
Yea-Y. Xc-
you answ4red "Yea' to question 11, wna% is Wta
I or XrS. Cj;GllCA41S J.14%Wiag
4 n:-Iluzable tz V=h 0! t.;;Y1o11CVi1q par-tiss:
Mrs. Cipollone
Liggett Croup, Inc.
CNOTZ: T2%o sum of thasa percentaque 3rust Oqual
100%
13. Did LL9-q*t% Uks ex-,ross VArTxntisS tv
*zMsU34T2
riqardinq, the health AS;4cts of its eigarittas?
ya*-~L No-
you anzwe:&,d lye to cruestion 13, did any
Liggett.
producza used by Mrs. C3.111ono brvacA t-Ut
wArzantY?
Yes
BAT Industries document for Province of British
Columbia 5 November 1999


- - - - --- - - - - - - - - - - - - -
g iA 3 7-
13. 22 you answered -y-al to question it, -.0 Xre.
Cipallono's uAs at these pro4usta a proalma%w
cause oC her
lunq cancer and death?
We_
It you at ShA fZ11OwIRq
question 1 vha% damaqem did Xrs.
.n:,.1;,
CIP011 4
you &n&w:rej,'yfta' Is
2 3. a. 9, r Id r. clpoLlsaa,
5%14%&Ln?
v-e t," 7
a. It 4LR;qem :gAinen one ow more jr ascend
yes- ..!!Z
i:-pTr,y*u.&i%:w,.reA. *yoso so queasLon la, tm
wha% anount
26,, wt,,Ye,4 awwr-Seqd a &%= un4or q-tion
2.9,jw%a% An.unz as
So .1 a to each of 'the to I OW Lr~q
par%Laa?
L1 qqeft% Group. Zzw,
Miliv Morris :Acer7oratot S
zRa.
Excvrx* th.:; ..04nt 14 add up to the to%at ava"aa
%uld ques=1114M.,
FQAxPxx341(
BAT Industries document for Province of British
Columbia 5 November 1999