R E:::'.- TOBACCO DIVISIOrj BOARD OF MANAGEMENT Fridav. 25th _'une 1976 at 10-00 a.m. Present: Mr. P. Sheehy (Chairman) Mr. C.H. Stewart Lock1jart Mr. I.B.D. Bluett Mr. C.G. Bo~ra Mr. B.P. Garraway Mr. N.W. Goddard Dr. S.J. Green Mr. R.St.C. Walmisley Mr. P.L.. Wright In attendance: Mr- B.G. Pearson (Secretary) Mr. H.A. Morini Also a~-Lended: Mc. G.t-. Dennis Mr. P.j.H. Rackham (0.138) D.138 Planninq The purpose o~ the meeting was to identify the issues facing us ir, the next terl years, so as to be able better- to plan the next three years at the November plann-f-ic -neeting. The meeting considered and, subje=t to certiiln chanqe:3 and clarifications, approved the following papers:- The shape of the tobacco industry Assumptions and strategies for marketing The shape of the process The shape of our business A financial view -.~f the Division Specific pointsmade were:- 1. In certain selected are.%s, particularly in the developed and profitable countrips and in export markets, we ma, *, have to be prepared to forgo some immediate profits in order to match competiti-- by investing more on advertising a,id promoti,_)n and in development work in areas which are seen '-,, h.=tve abng-term future. but only after we are confident Lhat the product is right. 2. The present big four companies (which may become the big three) will in--rease their total world market sh-i_--e and lh:ez implie,~ zompany acquisitLons. CD C) C:) 0% C71 C:) BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 28 October 1999 3. There _S need fo!:- consumer te:3ting in developed mar'-ets on :--T vs. PC7, before committing ourselves by 4. Conside-stLan should be given to R,&D work moving a!.-j=_-_-- from t"s emphasL3 on saving money in production pr_,cesses tcwards quelity and control of the product, i.e. ac~_-eptance and lowering biological activity a:; F, t co n t ro I .For example, possible ne-a of z-~ttlng tobacco which do not erriploy the ~:o:-:--:,essed '~:heesel technique. It waa reported that the Group will search _'.3r a hoL,---3 -35 a rossible acquisition. There -.-as a discussion on Dr. Kilburn's technol:)gical fcre=ast th-, as the major cost of secondary minufacture is -=bour, reliable computer controlled madiinery should be and that this will not be achieved by the .1 ac:7--nery manufacturers following their, present policies. - -...-"-s felt chat such machinery was recalisable although ~_ e -.- =-'. opment of it would involve many other considerations, 'nc' _,dLng te-:Lslons on the extent of our involvem,rit. "-1r. :~ow,-3 %7-*',l prepare a paper on setting up a group to L,,-lr-=-e this. with a considered time limit of per-hars -., -ionths ~-)r the or-oup ' 4 to report. 7. In cou~-ries whe,~e BAT moves into a minority ::-;r authority and influence would be exe z is e-4 :,~e or o~ the F-)llowing: a Board represent'a tfve: owne--=-'n-;p; T&A arrangements; approval of ar.oointmenzs ::5 Senior r-nagez; a-.-,-.' training of future top manage-- * if _:~: is no: possible fjr, Lie representative on the Soarrf* (hc'~_-Tng a :.-roxy from BAT)to be a Millbank based or Millbank- expat_;a~e then, to avoid a possible conflict of in:a:.-est, he should not be a locally employed national. S. On the question of future central support for over- Sess compar'as the following points were made:- _0 2:-itLnued SAI' autho-7i~y implies ,z:7-itLnued BAT support. (b) T*-.e dilemma that the smallest proFit em-rners te-id to need the greatest suprort: the d=gcee of support must be in .-)r'-ion to total income; but that c-siderat-'on must also be given to the -::_~sibilitv of long-term improvements profitat-ility in each case. (c) 5-_::~poct must- be reduced -to countries. i-- wh_:,_-h we -n..)ve into a minority -Ituation t:~d which cannot repay the a--::-Por-t b,.. income to U.K. BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 28 October 1999 - 3 - 9. Before the November planning meeting it will be necessaryiD review:- (a) The degree of authority desirable and possible In the case of each company. (b) The level of support to be provided to each. (c) The proiected number of Millbank- o'.1/ned e:,!:atriates. (d) The Mill'--ank organisation. 10. Because of t-.e number of companies likely to move from subsidiary t,:~ a3sociated company status over the ten year period, cons -1-Jerat ion will be given to recommending equity accounting --o the BAT Board, so that BAT's percentage of the principal associated (minority holding) companies appears _'n BAT's published Balance Sheet and Profi~- and Loss A=-.Dunt instead of simply being included in dividends recei-:ed. 11. Substantial are likely to be available tor investment, in adci--ion to any likely tobacco acquisitions, and consideration must be given to the use of those funds. The past ad hoc =--',::-roach is no longer acceptable. There should be an intai--rated Group approach to future diversification a-_ it would be desirable if there could be divers if icaticn into an industry in a developed countr,.., which could tie ir. .-dith development of operations in developing countriSS. (Mr. Rackham) D.139 Chairman'S ReDort Mr. _Sheehy reviewed the principal activities since the last TD:.: meeting. D.140 Finance ::-:-rector's Rencrt Mf. Garraway revie~%,ed:- 1. The ofc :=Sh from Tobacco Division to &iQ. 2. The proposet :~rporate structure after the TST/BAT merger. D.141 C3nada Sheehy reported cn a visit. The Ret-iii D;Ivisic;-, comprises miscellaneous compar-.t_ively smi'l businesses. Most are profitable and dc-ing v. P--z::---3Sso Foods in USA Ls profita',Ole and has ambiti-ous P12--z. C) C) r1 i C:) C7% BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 28 October 1999 D.1-42 Oriental Leaf Mr. Walmisley reported on a visit -_:~ Greece, Yucsslavia ~nd Turkey wit'n Mr. W.H. Scott from 8&*.-.-. It has been a sellers' market for t".e past 2-3 years due to small crops and big demand. Prices have increased approximately 100% over the last 3 years in Turkey to USS3.65 per kilo, with sharp increases irl. other countries. However the 1976 crop in Turkey haz greatly increased. Pdces will level off ln 1977 a7d may go down Eor some types. B.A.T. total oriental purc"ase thl_z year be 6.E'30,000 kilos. Owing to a big increa-ze B&W fequiremen-.s, anticipated purchase in 1977? will he !'-.500,000 1-ilos. Staff has been reduced to three. headed b,..- Mr. J.M. Westwood who Is doing an exce--lent The net income to the centfe in res::ect of commis-z-'ons and buying expenses be $850.C: : Ln !':~'745-77 ard is forecast --: be $1,300,000 in 1977-7::. D.'-!43 ;-'!alavsia Mr. Goddarj reported on a visit. Incidence o~ communist ins-red v_*:,'_ence _iS more widespread than published and the::7"=_ is c::-=ern about t'-e abilit- of the milit-mr-y to control the in the longer term. The real cfowth in GNP last year 'z ez~-imated at 2.5% but forecasts are 6% for 1?76 ris-:ng to S sutsequently; the inflation rate is currertly 41:!~ Market share remains 72% ('-?75 and ma-in brand-z are selling -1-:e1l. The 1976 leaf crop is of be:ter q,_~a-lity but 25% Ic%.er in quantit- -.- and this will en-zble z~.=_ over- s--ocked position to be re--tified. Prclit af"er tax is estimated at 551. higher than last -ear and the c-ash position continues -*-= :norove. C..-2.q '4chweitzer - kezonstituted Tobaczo Reference TDB minute D.136 :)f Dr. Green reported that a -.aymer: :f 1p cer kilo the Sch,..jeitze--- British paten: "as been agreed z,.- 5ch,.-je.:-=ec and a formal agreement is being pre-.-aredl. L14 C) C) 0% BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 28 October 1999