QUARTERLY REPORT OCTOBER - DECEMBER 1962 COMPILED BY3 D.G. Felton I.W. Hughes F. Haslam ISSUED BYz S.J. Green DISTRIBUTIONi Copy No. I - D.S.F. Hobson, Esq. 2 - Sir Charles Ellis. 3 - H.D. Anderson, Esq. 4 - R.A. Boothroyd, Esq. 5 6 - T.M. Wade Jnr. Esq. 7 - L.C. Laporte, Esq. 8 - W.I.I. Reid, Esq. 9 - E.C. Fieldsend, Esq. 10 - G. Simpson, Esq. 11 - Library. 12 - File 68. COFY No. 12 File 6E. BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 Research & Development Establishment, British-American Tobacco Company Ltd.9 Southampton. DGF/JMS/68. Ist Januaryq 1963. QUARTERLY REPORT OCTOBER - DECEMBER 1962 INTRODUCTION Since the last Quarterly Report, a number of changes has been made In the Programme and these have been taken into consideration In the present report. They arei- 1. Basic research on the chemistry of tobacco structural materials, formerly listed under Project 5000, has been transferred to Project 2000 sub-soction (2080), 2, A new project - Smoke Research, Generall Project 3000 - has been started and Incorporates Project 3100. 3. Work on Selective Filtration of Smoke Constituents, formerly 3230t has been reprogrammed as a new project (3400), now that the Selective Filtration Section has been established. MOJECT 1000 GENERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT 1100 Analytical (Miss C.W. Ayers) (7) Work continues on the compilation of ultra-vIolet and Infra-red spectra. An infra-red method has been developed for the determination of triacetin and polyethylene glycol present in filters and is being applied to various commercial filters. This method will be reported In the near future. (12) Work on the determination of a total nitrogen balance Is still delayed owing to pressure of other work. (13) A spectrographic method for the qualitative determination of metals in tobacco has been developed. Some difficulties are being experienced In attempting to develop a quantitative procedure. The existing colorimetric methods for the estimation of Iron, copper, al%ninium and manganese are being re-examined in an endeavour to improve their reproducibility. CZ::) BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 9 November 1999 - 2- 1200 Tobacco (1.4. Hughes) (1) The separation of C.R.S.9 at various levels, from an all flue-cured tobacco blend has been successfully carried out. The operator Is now attempting to familiarise herself with different types of tobacco such as Burley and Oriental. (Miss C.U. Ayers) (3) Preliminary analysis of Boxer tobacco using gas chromato- graphyg has shown that this tobacco contains approximately twice as much acetic acid as the control supplied with the Boxer sample. This quantity of acetic acid Is approximately twenty times that found in a Players (CNIOD) tobacco. Other volatile acids are present in small amounts. It has been found that the "acidic" aroma of the Boxer sample has decreased enormously since it was received in R. & 0. E. and before further work is contemplated fresh samples should be obtained. 1300 Clqarettes (S.R. Evelyn) (7) A further six samples of cellulose acetate filter rods made by the Threaded Roll process have been examined. A report is in preparation. (S.R. Evelyn) (8) Composite filters (paper-acetate) from South Africa (1.W. Hughes) reported as being possibly responsible for an Impairment in smoke quality have been compared with similar filters from Rhodesia. No major difference between the two filters could be found. A report has been Issued. (9) Cigarettes made for Project Crash has been assessed for filtrational properties and smoke taste. A report has been issued. BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 9 November 1999 - 3 - (S.R. Evelyn) (10) The sample of paper, which has been treated according to (H.G. Horsewell) the patented 'Filtrall' process (H. WhItefield) has recently been received. This paper and a control are being made Into filter rods by the Schweitzer process and will be compared. 1400 Process Research & Develorment (A.W. Cronshaw) (1) Ekco Limited checked the sealed sources for leakage to comply with the Factories Ionising Radiations Regulations. Though there has been further correspondence with the Factory Inspector on an "Approved Scheme of Work". the matter Is still In his hands. PROJECT 2000 MBACCO% RELATION OF CONSTITUENTS AND PRCPERTIES OF TOBACCO TO THE QUALITY OF LEAF AND S!,1OKE AND TO AGRICULTURAL AND CURING, PROCESSES 2010 Waterloo Part IV (D.G. Felton) (2) The statistical analysis of the results from Part IV has been completed by the laboratory responsible, but the report has not yet been received by R. & D. E. 2020 Grey Tobacco (D.J. Wood) (3) Laboratory examination of stored leaf from the second (R. Comber) greenhouse crop, 1961, Is nearing completion. During storage, (C.W. Ayers) changes have recurred in reflectance colour and In a number of organic constituents. It Is hoped to Issue a report early in 1963. (4) No work has been carried out on pigments In cured tobacco but an appraisal of the problem will be reported early in 1963. (5) The leaf samples from Pakistan have been found to be contaminated with very fine soil particles which are extremely difficult to remove, even by chemical treatment. This BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 -4 - contamination accounts for the very high content of irong aluminium and silica. The report, which was held up because of these new findings, is now in course of preparation. (6) Storage of leaf from the first of the 1962 greenhouse experiments Is continuing. Colour measurements, which are being made at regular Intervalsq show a very definite relationship between nutrient treatment and colour changet the sample with the highest levels of iron and chloride darkening rapidly. Visually this sample now appears grey. (7) There Is nothing to add concerning the second of the 1962 greenhouse experiments. (8) Plants of the third 1962 experiment are still In the greenhouse, with harvesting and curing now In progress. Nearly all leaves from plantsq fed a combination of iron and aluminium, have cured to a dark grey-brown colour. (9) The Initial work on enzyme Inactivation by dielectric heat has been completed and a report will shortly be issued. The colour change of leaf In which enzymes had been inactivated wasq after two months storage, virtually the some as that of untreated leaf. From this It Is concluded that the reactions which lead to change in colour during storage after flue-curing are largely if not entirely non-enzymic. (10) In an effort to find the causes of sponging in flue-cured tobacco from Cyprusq samples of the tobacco and of the soil from Cyprus have been obtained by Leaf Department. The leaf samples are now being analysed. It is not yet known whether this defect is In any way related to grey tobacco. BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 - 5 - (11) Soil samples from Pakistan have been sent at our request In the hope that analysis of trace elements might help to elucidate the nutrient causes of grey tobacco. A much more comprehensive soil analysis Is simultaneously being carried out in Pakistan Itself. 2 D40 (1 & 3) A report has been prepared on the results obtained by (R.G. Hook) multiple redrying and thermogravimetric analysis. This work has been of little help in determining the nature of water bonding, but has shown it should be possible to develop an oven test to determine moisture content without organic volatiles. Such a method would have great use in R. & D. E. (2) Initial work with differential therma I analysis Indicates that this technique will probably have little value In determining the nature of water bonding. (4) Work has commenced on the vapour pressure studies of tobacco at different temperatures and moistures. (Miss C.V1. Ayers) (5) Owing to various requests for accurate moisture contents of tobacco, the various methods for estimating water, such as Karl Fischer reagent and near-Infra-red spectroscopy, are being examined. Initial indications suggest that the near-infra-red method may be the better one. 2060 Fennentation of Tobacco (W.B. Fordyce) (3) A theoretical study of the carbohydrate balance In fermentation has been started. 2070 Colour of Tobacco (D.J. Wood) (I & 2) This project has been Initiated in order to learn more about the colour of tobacco In generalt how the reflectance colour Is related to various fractions of extractable coloured substances, how It Is affected by processing (including primary C BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 - 6 - processing) what chemical changes are involved in the latter, etc. So far the work has been concerned with establishing suitable techniques for studying the relation between reflectance colour and extractable colour. 2080 Chemical Structure of Tobacco (W.B. Fordyce) During this quarter the determination of molecular weight (A.R. Cousins) using viscometry has been completed and a report has been drafted. Further vi3cometric Investigations will be carried out and reported as a complement to the light scattering technique (M86). (W.B. Fordyce) (1) Re-examination of the periodate consumption of flue-cured tobacco xylan Indicates that the oxidation Is virtually complete (100%) and not 75% complete as suggested by earlier experiv*nts and reported in the previous quarterly report. Work has begun on the minor polysaccharide constituents of Burley tobacco. Use of a slow cellulose column of high resolution for the separation of the sugars obtained on hydrolysis indicates the presence of three hitherto un- detected sugars. (2) A report has been completed on the comparison of cell wall carbohydrates in various tobaccos and P.C.L. This Investigation is now suspended. (W.B. Fordyce) (3) An examination of the constitution of flue-cured tobacco (A.R. Cousins) pectin is being made. The pectic acid is reduced, via the ethylene glycol ester, to a galactan, whose structure Is determined more easily than that of the parent uronic acid. (_77 CZD BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 (W.B. Fordyce) (4) Preliminary measurements of the mechanical properties of (A.R. Cousins) leaf have been made. When all the physical properties have (P.J. Nicholl) been studied, the examination of the polysaccharlde constituents will be started. (W.B. Fordyce) (5) An investigation regarding the use of freeze-drying as a means of recovering tobacco flavour constituents has been started. (A.R. Cousins) (6) A light-scattering instrument, for the measurement of absolute weight-average molecular weights, has been Installed. Calibration experiments using sucrose octa-acetate as a standard are In progress. (7) The determination of number average molecular weight of constituent polysaccharides of tobacco using ebulliometry and vapour pressure osmometry is awaiting delivery of apparatus, PROJECT 3000 CIGARETTE DESIGN Smoke research - qeneral. (D. Cleverdon) (1) An attempt to measure the free radical activity of tobacco smoke condensate has shown that It Is rich in inhibitors for free radical reactions e.g. condensate is able to suppress the polymerisation of vinyl acetatet Initiated by benzoyl peroxide, This suggests that smoke condensate contains constituents which are able to react with the growing chain radicals and convert them to low energy entities incapable of further growth. Inhibitors are often odd-electron compounds themselves or are very readily converted into odd-electron structures. This work is being pursued. (C.I. Ayres) (2) A survey of Nblished information on the effects of smoking on cilia has been started and it Is intended to report in the form of a critical survey of the evidence. BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 - 8 - 3100 Smoke Formation 3110 Characterisation of tobacco as a smoke producer (C.I. Ayres) (3) The contribution by repyrolysis to benzpyrenet tar and nicotine yields has been studied, using a long (102 mm) cigarette. A report has been prepared and will be Issued. (C.W. Ayers) (6) The determination of product efficiencies for tar and nicotine for cigarettes made from single grades of flue-curiad and Burley tobaccos Is under way. This work is being carried out to determine the range of product efficiency values likely to be encountered. 3120 Study of Pipes. ciqars and ciqarettes (C.I. Ayres) (2) Following a visit to R. Barling & Sons (pipe manufacturers) a supply of rough-cut mod blocks was received. Soma different pipe designs are being made from these and will be Investigated. (3) The yields of benzpyrene from cigarettes for which cigarette paper of different porosities were used are being determined. This Is the first part of the Investigation into the effects of combustible and noncombustible wrappers on smoke production. (4) Nothing to report. 3130 Characterisation of the combustion process (R.G. Hook) (1) The feasibility of using a number of thermocouples to enable a more accurate definition of temperature-distance profile In a burning cigarette to be obtained has been assessed. It is considered that the maximum number usable will be four. Work will continue along these lines. Other factors likely to affect the combustion temperaturehave also been examined. 4 ~ BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 (a) As the oxygen content increases above that of air, the combustion temperature rises. (b) Using the reverse smoking machine originally designed it has been found that the combustion temperature drops 1000C below that measured In 'normal' B-A.T. (suction) smoking. This finding has led to a modification to the existing reverse smoker such that the divergence from Onormall smoking is minimised. (2) Nothing to report. (J.D. Backhurst) (3) The first report giving the first results on material balance In a burning cigarette, using side and mainstream smoke collection has been finished and will be Issued shortly. Briefly, the work shows that although the transfer of nicotine to main- stream smoke during puffing Is efficient (85%) It Is only 50% efficient for side stream generated during smoulder. The overall recovery of nicotine Is of the order of 60-70%. The investigation of the effect of changing cigarette parameters is now completed and will be reported shortly. (C.I. Ayres) (5) A preliminary examination of possible techniques for (N.E. Willis) splitting the puff h6s, been started. First thoughts suggest that the valve designed for micro-sampling of the vapour phase of cigarette smoke will represent the first working model. (R.G. Hook) (6) The thermal analysis (over a temperature range of 100 - 7000C) of tobacco and tobacco constituents has commenced. A first report, In preparation, describes the results obtained during the thermogravimetric analysis of various tobaccos and tobacco constituents such as the carbohydrates. 3150 Transfer and Pyrolysis processes (S.R. Evelyn) (1) Further work with the addition of nicotine base and citrate BATCo document for Province of British Columbia 9 November 1999 - 10 - to paper "model' cigarettes has shown that the choice of this model vas not a good one, owing largely to losses of nicotine by evaporation. Furtherg high draw resistance andfIltration of the paper models tend to wake this approach unrealistic. Consequentlyq work with paper models is being suspended. (S.R. Evelyn) (2 & 5) The third report on the release of nicotine from (J.D. Backhurst) tobacco and models has been issued. The study of the release of nicotine added to tobacco cigarettes has continued and has been enlarged to include side- stream evaluation. The results suggest that the product efficiency of the added nicotine is somewhat dependent upon the form In which the nicotine Is added. A report is in preparation. (S.R. Evelyn) (3) Experiments to measure the rates of release and decom- position of nicotine have been re-started. The original apparatus has been modified so that samples of the heatad tobacco and distillate can be withdrawn and assayed at suitable time intervals during each experiment, in order to determine the actual release and decomposition rates at fixed temperatures. (C.I. Ayres) (6) Work has commenced to find the pyrolytic precursors of the (R.E. Thornton) phenols which occur in cigarette smoke. Yihile a G.L.C. apparatus is being calibrated, the colorimetric method Is being used and the Initial results showt (I) repyrolysis of smoke may make Important contributions to phenols yield (11) different tobaccos can give markedly different phenols yield (III) increase In the moisture content of a cigarette depresses the yield of phenols per cigarette. BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 - 11 - 3160 Development of Smokinq Machine (N.E. Willis) (3) Tests on the modified valve for free and "restricted" smoking have demonstrated that the changes vdiich were incorporated have adversaly affected Its sealing during the puff period. This Is now being tackled by re-arrangement of the valve. 3170 Weiaht of material burnt In a nuff (A.W. Cronshaw) (1) Work on the Beta-Ray equipment has been further delayed by absence but an attempt is being made to analyse the traces obtained with the Interlorscope. At present the chart is being cut Into sections and weighed. The early Indications are that the method Is extremely tedious and not sufficiently accurate. It may be necessary to go to an electronic computor technique. PROJECT 3200 CIGARETTE DESIGNt MODIFICATION OF SLUKE AFTER FORNIATION 3210 (2) The effect of changes in relative humidity on the (J.B. Backhurst) particle size distribution Is being examined. (4) A comparison of the particle size distribution of smoke from Burley cigarettes made wholly from Burley tobacco and flue-cured tobacco has been undertaken. The Rank Cintel Flying Spot Particle Resolver is being commissioned for use. 322D Mechanical Filtration (S.R. Evelyn) (1) Evaluation of the filtrational properties of Polythene tow and sheets has been carried out for project 4260. There do not appear to be any unusual effects due to this material. Owing to other committments (e.g. 1307) progress with this Q-17 BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 - 12- project has been slow. (6) Initial results Indicated that the efficiency of a synthetic filter Is dependent on the smoking tobacco; with Burley tobacco enhanced efficiency was shown. This effect is being studied but there is nothing to report at this time. 3240 Effect of Temperature on Smoke (K.D. Kilburn) (2) The study of the effect of temperature an the composition of the vapour phase has been discontinued. (C.I. AyTes) (3) A report has been Issued on the effect of temperature on filtration efficiency. PROJECT 3300 THE MAIN FACTORS INFLUENCTIZ TASTE & FIAVOUR 3310 Analysis of smoke with resvect to flavour compounds (K.D. Kilburn) (3) The first three fractions obtained from smoke distillate CH. Dymond) after preparative scale gas chromatography have been examined using various analytical tools such as Infra red and mass spectrometry and quantitative small scale gas chromatography. The first fraction Is mainly composed of aliphatic hydrocarbons and furans. The second fraction is mainly composed of benzene, toluene, xylenes plus some monoterpenes, while the third consists of carbonyls and esters. 3320 Mechanics of the release of volatile flavour compounds (2 & 3) A report Is In preparationt attempting to allocate the contributions of (a) pyrolysis of volatile and non-volatile components of tobacco, and (b) repyrolysis of both volatile and non-volatile components of smoke, to the vapour phase of smoke. '0 L-n c0 BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 - 13 - 3330 To establish a chemical basis for sensory testinq (I & 2) Cigarettes containing the fractions Isolated under project 3313 are being assessed by the taste and flavour working party. The Initial trials showed some promise and work will continue along these lines. 3340 To establish a technique for assessinq the taste & flavour of (D.E. Conway) Whole smoke (4) The investigation Into the effect of stem an Irritation should be completed and ready for statistical analysis within three weeks. (D.E. Conway) (5) Further "ork on cigarette smoke aroma has led to the establishment, within the working party, of a flavour profile method for describing smoke. Results so far show that It Is applicable to a wide range of cigarettes and good replication of the profile has been obtained. PROJECT 3400 SE =-IVE FILTRATION 3410 Selective removal of phenols. (H.G. Horsewell) The evaluation of filters made from cellulose triacetate, (G. Rayner) secondary acetate and from paper has been completed. The (D.U. Carroll) effect of such additives as polyethylene glycol and triaectin has also been assessed. A report is being Issued. (1) Paper filterst impregnated with a range of additives such as bentonite treated with quaternary salts,are being evaluated for phenol filtration. The work Is not yet completed. 342D Selective removal of volatile acids (H.G. Horsewell) (1) A gas chromatographic method Is being developed for the (G. Rayner) determination of volatile acids in cigarette smoke. The (C.W. Ayers) following acids can be determined quantitatively : formic, BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 - 14- acetic, propionic, n- and Iso-butyric and n- and iso-valeric acids. A titrimetric method for 'total volatile acids* gives values which agree reasonably with those obtained by the gas chromatographic technique. Tests are now being carried out using the titrimetric method for determining filtration efficiency. A report Is in preparation. 3430 Selective removal of aldehydes (H.G. Horsewell) (1) A method for the determination of volatile aliphatic 0. Rayner) aldehydes in cigarette smoke is under test. If it is shown (C.71. Ayers) to give reproducible results, it will be used to determine (D.M. Carroll) filtration efficiency. PROJECT 4100 PROCESS RESEARCH 9 DEVELOPME11r: PPINIARY 4100 Primarv Process Research (F. Hasiam) (6 & 7) It has been agreed to make the simplest first approach to the problem of vapour losses in primary process and to fit an FMB stainless steel water cooled condenser to the Southampton Branch dryer exhaust system. This condenser has been designed and quotations are awaited. it will later be Installed and quantities of condensate collected. (D.E. Conway) (8) A method for uniformly reducing tobacco lamina to small pieces diameter) without producing dust has been derwnstrated. Tobacco in this form has been made Into cigarettes and also used as filter tips. The experiment will be repeated an a larger scale and a direct wmparlson made with conventionally cut lamina. It is thought that such cigarettes may have saw unique properties. BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 - 15 - 4110 Production Flow Problems (D.S. Goodfellow) (2) It was decided during the period to hold the scheme in abeyance indefinitely. Willis) (4) The modified South African load cell is being fitted to the test conveyor. (A.H. Wright) (5) The electro-mechanical device for controlling the level of tobacco at the foot of the pin band has been completed and has operated successfully. A report has been prepared. (F. Haslam) (6) The Merchen Weighing Conveyor has been shipped to Liverpool and Is awaiting Installation prior to testing. 4123 Primary Process Development (A.J.0. Thomson) (2) A pair of stainless steel rolls has now been Installed in Liverpool Branch. There are therefore three sets of rolls at present running under normal factory conditions. Equipment for accurately positioning the doctor blade has been ordered from Messrs. Vickery. It Is hoped that this may reduce the wear an the beryllium copper scrapers to even less than the 0.04 lb. per million lb. of tobacco processed i-thich has been recorded to date. (D.S. Goodfellow) (3) The design for the skip diverter has been finished and the order placed with Microcell. Queries arising from the Install- ation of the automatic skip filler In Southampton Branch have been dealt with - with the help of Mr. F. White - and all out- standing technical points are settled. Delivery has been delayed but is now expected in January 1963. 4130 Basic study of Tobacco Cuttina (N.E. Willis) (2) A Mark I Molins Tobacco Cutting Machine has been adapted Cl\ BATCo document for Province of BritiSh Columbia 9 November 1999 - 16 - 4140 (W.B. Fordyce) (J.D. Backhurst) MOJECT 4200 for this work. Independent tachometer controlled T.A.S.C. drives have been fitted to the band and cutting head to enable a range of cutting conditions to be examined. A pneumatic loading system has been introduced so that a range of pressures can be Introduced for experimental work. A further system for assessing the local intensity of pressure on the cheese is under construction and will be fitted at a later stage. Stem processinq (7) The study of the effect of solvent extraction of stems on smoke properties has been discontinued. SECONDARY AND PACKAGING 4210 Claarette Makina (J.W.H. Segar) (1) The High Speed hik. 8 (No. 18258) has been used to assist (N.E. Willis) In Branch production In conjunction with modification trials (A.W. Cronshaw) arranged at Molins request. (E.B. Wilkes) An examination is being made of the quality of the winnowings produced on this machine with the jet diffuser and some routine analysis was made of the cigarettes produced. (N.E. Willis) (3) Designs are complete for special equipment for adjusting and defining the settings of (a) long folder (b) short folder (c) tongue piece for a Mark 8 M.C.M. Manufacture has commenced and the first items should be installed within the course of the next few weeks. (J.W.H. Segar) (5) 'York on Molins Mark 5-8-5 No. 18516 has been discontinued (N.E. Willis) pending further modifications. Discussions have taken place with